East of Chicago Pizza

Enjoy our handcrafted specialty pizzas, flavorful wings, fresh salads, and more. Order online from our diverse menu for convenient delivery or takeout!

East of Chicago Pizza of Shipshewana – Facebook

East of Chicago Pizza of Shipshewana, Shipshewana. 1341 likes · 3 talking about this · 170 were here. Dine-in w/ Buffet & Carryout/Delivery.

East of Chicago Pizza | Visit Shipshewana

East of Chicago Pizza … Conveniently located next to the Shipshewana Visitors Center and across from the Flea Market. Great family-friendly prices. Try our …

Reviews

EGGMAN goo goo ga joob

I stay in town on business a few nights a year and look forward to the medium pan. It always comes out hot and quick. I have yet to try the oven baked subs, but it’ll happen. The pizza is solid. I never complain about chain style pizza because I usually know what to expect, depending on the franchise. EofC is better than most of them. If you’re expecting “Guido’s Trattoria”, you’ll be bummed

… more

Jeff Whaley

FANTASTIC PIE!!!! Excellent bite with buttery crispy edges and perfectly baked insides. You can see the quality in the toppings and the care and attention and preparation. Definitely must try!!!!

… more

Martin Wilson

Great pizza pie, ordered on Door Dash, so cannot comment on store or employee presentation. Pizza was fantastic, ordered a supreme without the olives and green peppers. I wish they had a tradtional garlic butter (maybe they do just was not an option on door dash) to dip the crust in, I went with the zesty garlic which I was not a fan of. Will definitely order again though!

… more

Leah Johns

Went there for dinner last night got there at 630 not one person told us the buffet closed at 7 there was little to know food on the buffet mind you there was four of us two being children! The girl that was at the register allowed us to pay for buffet and didn’t tell us when the buffet closed! Let’s just say we paid for one plate each maybe got two pieces of pizza each and that was it to say we were pissed is an understatement! Not to mention a gentleman came in around 650 and also got buffet and she also don’t let him know buffet closed at 7! Service sucked food was old and gross! We will not be returning first impressions are everything when it comes to a company! We wasted time, gas and money for a terrible first experience!

… more

Kihla Shepherd

Have been a different time and did the pizza buffet and wasn’t overly impressed with options, food was kinda dry. But most recently made a carryout order and a fresh made pizza from here is exceptional. We will be returning customers. Pictured are parm pops and the chicken bacon ranch pizza with stuffed crust. My husband really liked the marinara, and the cheese sauce was good too.

… more

wendell troyer

Not sure why I give it a one star. Table in corner was dirty.did not get a menu so really couldn’t see prices. Looked like 13.95 on the net. Got 2 orders of blah bread sticks a large pizza and a 2 liter for right at 50. Never again. Place seemed slow. Seen next three folks walk in they finally left.

… more

Erica Jo

The best deep dish pizza our family has ever tried. We visited here when we were staying in Shipshewana and it is now a family favorite. The deep dish pizza is so good and the garlic cheese bread is amazing! We also love the Parm pops with marinara sauce. The prices are very reasonable and everything is always fresh. They also have a buffet but we were not there when it was running. If you go at lunchtime, they have the perfect size personal pizzas called flash pan pizza. Highly recommended! If we lived closer, this would be our go to pizza place!

… more

Beth Baus

I have celiac and eating out is risky. I took the risk after having all my questions answered. The gluten free pizza was delicious and I did not get sick! I’ll definitely eat there again when in the area.

… more

Karen Longino

Food was good. Pizza buffet. They opened the buffet early to accommodate us. Good salad bar. Reminded us of the Pizza Hut buffet. Had pizza, bread knots and desserts. Very good.

… more

Julio Cardona

Great food at an even better price and such a friendly staff. I highly recommend it to everyone

… more

… View more

East of Chicago Pizza

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results