Low-key space serving pastas, pies and other classic Italian eats & an array of homemade desserts.
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Pueblo’s East Coast Pizza closes but may reopen with new owners
East Coast Pizza has closed after 40 years of bringing New York-style pizza, lasagna and sweet cannolis to Pueblo.
Order East Coast Pizza Menu Delivery in Pueblo – Uber Eats
Use your Uber account to order delivery from East Coast Pizza in Pueblo. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your order.
East Coast Pizza – CLOSED, 1638 W US Highway 50, Pueblo, CO …
Get more information for East Coast Pizza in Pueblo, CO. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Cassy
In Pueblo for a few days and a quick google review showed East Coast Pizza as a top contender. It’s located in an area that could easily be missed if not looking closely. We ordered the garlic knots as appetizers and the sauce was delicious. We got a medium jalapeño and pepperoni pizza and a pasta with meat sauce. Both entrees were delicious. The house salad and their house dressing was really good too. We left room for dessert and tried peanut butter cookies, pressed cookies, and red velvet cake. I’ve never had pressed cookies like these and they were delicious. Definitely recommend.
… moreGena
I would have preferred to give 3.5 stars but that’s not possible. We had the house salad, small…it was good. We ordered wings, but they were soggy. The waitress explained they are baked, not fried, this is why they are not crispy. She easily took them back and easily removed them from the bill. I do believe they should put on the menu that they are baked, or have the waitress explain it when ordered. We ordered a lg the works. It was really good with the exception of being wet from the toppings. We did take a cheese pizza home for the kids that didnt want to come. This pizza was good too. Tiramisu was ok. They were out of cannolis….but had some pretty neat desserts.
… morealan r. smith
East Coast pizza is the best that Pueblo Colorado has to offer. On the one hand, the the folks that run this business seem to put a lot of thought and effort into their menu. Everything I’ve had there was delicious. I really appreciate what they’ve done, especially their new robot! On the other hand, if they were in another market they might not shine as brightly. The restaurant lacks the ambience and pizzazz to make it truly great.
… moreMichael Giltner
Hostesses are rude and uninviting. The food was horrible tasting and some plates either burnt or horrible flavor the Alfredo sauce is thick and unflavorful. The pasta wasn’t good at all and prices on pizzas was high.
… moreLindsays A Happy Camper
I hate leaving bad reviews but this pizza place was awful. 1st all but 2 of the tables were dirty and stayed that way for the 1 hour and 30 mins that we were there. First they have a robot that makes the same sound every time it comes out. It is very loud and gets old quick. It took almost 30mins before the server came to get our drink and food order. While the managers were having a meeting while the restaurant was getting it handed to them. They forgot to make one of my kids their meals, so he waited an additional 20 minutes. Both his pizza and my husbands pizzas were wet???? My calzone was so bad it had a hug amount of Ricotta cheese in the center. All of the pepperoni were at the bottom and the mushrooms tasted like they came from a can and not fresh. It was also super wet and greasy. Would definitely rather eat at the Pizza Hut right down the street. At least you can eat that pizza.
… moreRyan Anand
My partner and I visited East Coast Pizza for the first time and were both thoroughly impressed. The restaurant had a very friendly, homey atmosphere and a very courteous staff. We were seated right away at a clean table. This restaurant had an entire gluten free menu and makes their own gluten free bread and crust in house. We ordered a large gluten free pizza and they happily allowed us to half our toppings. Everything was delicious. They have an awesome selection of deserts that I hope to try next time!
… moreJames Rustle
They’ve got good subs and the chicken parm is great, not crazy about the pizza but the cheesesteak is absolutely atrocious. 2 steakums on a giant roll is NOT how you make a plain cheesesteak, especially on the east coast. Serving this for 10 dollars y’all should be ashamed of yourselves.
The other image is what a normal cheese steak is supposed to look like.
… moreThe other image is what a normal cheese steak is supposed to look like.
Katie B
What a great pizza place!! We stopped here for dinner while passing through Pueblo on Thanksgiving week. The food and service were excellent! The dessert selection was vast and made choosing just a few to take home so tricky! But… the robot waiter was an unexpected and delightful surprise! We’ve never seen one before! Our kids were entertained and so were we! This was our first time, but it certainly won’t be our last!!
… morehaedoug llc
We came in just to get a couple of drinks, saw the pastries which we couldn’t resist. All the pastries we tried were so good, so we tried the Italian Sausage and pepper sandwich which was huge and very good too. Will be back for more.
… moreSherae Reich
Best pizza we have ever had moving here. Thanks for the yummy goodness. The taste of it is just amazing
… more