Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
This long-standing establishment serves up traditional seafood & meat entrees in welcoming environs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1007 Simonton St, Key West, FL 33040
Phone: (305) 296-4900
Website: https://www.duffyskeywest.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House | Key West Restaurants
Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House is Key West’s favorite steak and lobster house offering an extensive selection of dishes and a friendly local atmosphere.
Duffy’s Steak and Lobster House | Florida Keys & Key West
Duffy’s Steak & Lobster House in Key West is a classic surf-and-turf restaurant offering premium seafood, steaks, and a warm island ambiance.
Duffy’s Steak and Lobster House – Key West, FL – OpenTable
… restaurant. Duffy’s Steak and Lobster House – Key West, FL. (0). $31 to $50. Steakhouse. 1007 Simonton St, Key West, FL 33040. Overview; Menu; Reviews. About …
Reviews
Destiny Brincefield
Loved the atmosphere in the space and our server was very good. However, as much as I’d like to love this place, the food didn’t meet the standards. The filet was good, fries not bad, alligator bites were tasty. But the lobster tail was WAY overdone, I had to saw it with my knife with force to try and cut it up and it was stringing together not cutting. And my prime rib was very mediocre. The horsey sauce is the only thing saving it. So, overall not a bad place but the food has some room for improvement. Our bill was $165 before tip. Which included 1 appetizer, and 1 mixed drink, 2 steak meals with one lobster tail. Which would have been ok if food matched pricing. Maybe other items on menu are better options.
… moreRossana Portaluppi
Excellent. We ordered 3 Surfs and Turfs, the buffalo chicken wings, a key lime pie, and the chocolate thunder cake. The restaurant was delicious, the steaks were cooked perfectly and the lobster was delicious. The service is 10/10, even though in the menu they didn’t offered coffee with milk, the server was nice enough to provide us with hot milk to prepare our own coffees. It was excellent and the price is fair for the amazing quality of food and service. Will 100% return, and I highly recommend it. The key lime pie was delicious, the server said it was the best in town and indeed it was. The music was in perfect volume and the restaurant was neat. Our server’s name was Brenda and she was excellent and extremely nice. Would 100% recommend
… moreBen Johnson
Everything we had at Duffys was good, I would eat there again, but nothing to write home about. Or server was fantastic though. Key lime pie was excellent.
… moreCarmella Feasby
Amazing!! The lobster bisque is to die for! Definitely going back for that. We split the prime rib and lobster tail. Super tasty. Prime rib cooked perfectly. The lobster tail was my first time and it was really good!
… moreCathy F
This review would be a perfect 5 star if the hostess and two waitresses wouldn’t have been so stereotypical. My partner and I spent the day exploring Key West and before driving back North we decided to try this place out and get some dinner. We were sat by the bathroom on a tiny table, we never got a water refill, and our waitress wouldn’t even check in. Thankfully the busboy did and it made dinner much more pleasant.
Before our meals we had a basket of fluffy, warm bread, salad, and a delicious Lobster Bisque! The catch of the day was Grouper fish and I was soooo excited! We really enjoyed our dinner choices and the charming, relaxed atmosphere.
My partner had the surf & turf and both the filet mignon and lobster tail were cooked perfectly — tender, flavorful, and served hot with butter and sauce on the side. I had the seafood pasta and it was packed with fresh Grouper fish and shrimp, not skimpy at all. The sauce was rich and absolutely delicious. A great spot for a classic Key West dinner!
… moreBefore our meals we had a basket of fluffy, warm bread, salad, and a delicious Lobster Bisque! The catch of the day was Grouper fish and I was soooo excited! We really enjoyed our dinner choices and the charming, relaxed atmosphere.
My partner had the surf & turf and both the filet mignon and lobster tail were cooked perfectly — tender, flavorful, and served hot with butter and sauce on the side. I had the seafood pasta and it was packed with fresh Grouper fish and shrimp, not skimpy at all. The sauce was rich and absolutely delicious. A great spot for a classic Key West dinner!
Erik Noel
Excellent restaurant! The atmosphere was great! The food was delicious and the drinks were even better! The prices were really good compared to other Key West restaurants. And their New England Clam Chowder is to die for! Our waitress was extremely nice as well as the rest of the staff! Highly recommend eating here!
… moreBuzz Grant
Food is excellent. Lobster is fresh and ribeye is prime. Prices are reasonable. Key Lime Pie to die for. Value is good. Service is fast, we had a 5pm seating.
… moreKevin James
Enjoyed the food. 1st time trying alligator tails…not bad! Only complaint is the booths are not accommodating for larger guests!
… moreGwen Bradley
Best meal we had in key west. Wasn’t too sure when we walked in and were the only customers but it was early and off season so we gave it a try anyway. So glad we did. My husband and I had the blackened grouper with mango chutney, and it was so good! My friend had surf and turf. The lobster was perfectly cooked and the filet was tender and very tasty. The service was great too!!
… moreNicole Scheidemann
Had a yummy diner here. Gorgeous restaurant with beautiful decoration and yummy food. Services was amazing.
… more