KarenM A
Simple and small place. Appears the person at the front was the only one who was working there (maybe one other?) Appreciated the menu on a pamphlet I can take home, also the pictures on the wall with the names of the Salvadorian dishes was helpful. Good price for it all. My friend and I ordered the pupusas (there were so many variations of the filling you can choose from) and fried plantains. I was full off two pupusas, and brought the rest of the food home. Overall, straightforward and would come again. A hidden gem in a small town nearby. I recommend.
… moreJeremy McLaughlin
Some of the BEST food I have had in the Greater Yakima Valley. The owners are so friendly and accommodating, and so is the staff. The Pupusas and Flautas are out of this world. The prices are very fair. You won’t be disappointed going to Don Mateo’s!
… moreJorge Rojas
The food was 2 or 3, the service was good, but you have to be humble with people. I’m Cuban and I make better Cuban food than someone from another country. A Mexican makes better Mexican food than I do, and I’m not Mexican. I hope my comment is clear. It’s not right to humiliate people.
… moreMarisol Cuevas
Such great experience. Customer service was great, everyone was super nice and friendly, very welcoming. Food service was Amazing ! Quick service and food was fresh and delicious with great flavor. We ordered pupusas and agua de orchata, I recommend for sure. ♥️
… moreGabriel Prout
Awesome little family business. The Pollo asado plate was excellent. Great rice and beans too, and homemade tortillas! Also the pupusas were excellent.
… moreRuthie Elizabeth
so i’ve been trying to go here for the past 6 years and we just can’t sync our schedules up. last saturday i was up in tieton to get a gift for a friend at tieton nomad and lo and behold, don mateo’s was open! i wasn’t hungry and i was headed to a graduation bbq, but seeing as how this was the first time i had ever seen it open, i thought i had to try it.
the papusas were excellent. i had asparagus and cheese and the pickles on top really sent it. we sat outside and it was perfect.
i would love to see tieton pop off and don mateo’s get the traffic they deserve.
… moreAnna Bloxham-Bliss
Great little place! Food was excellent and the staff was very friendly. I had the Pupusas and a side of plantains. Will be my new go to, can’t wait to try other menu items.
… moreRobert Grimmer, DC
We used to eat Papusas all the time back when we lived in a more Urban area where we had access to it. We were thrilled to hear that there was an El Salvadorian restaurant here in the valley. We got the pork and cheese. They were the best. They were decent sized and not too greasy.
It was worth it to drive out to Tieton for it. Definitely recommended.
… moreKristen Gomez
We happened upon this small town square of Tieton and decided to eat lunch here. The exterior looks like it was recently renovated, which had a nice simple aesthetic appeal. The interior looks like it could use some work, but you really come for the food which is really delicious. My friend ordered the cheese/spinach pupusa and a side of rice/refried beans and plantains. I just got the enchiladas, which had a little kick to it but were still so good. Service was great–friendly and attentive. Highly recommend you check it out if you’re in the area!
… moreAngelica Lopez
I have come to this place for a long time now, every single time I received a really great service, the food have the same taste, always delicious, especially their popusas, the place is always clean and the staff kind and helpful, waiting time is reasonable because they prepare the food fresh. I highly recommend it.
… more