Frank Mattioli
I think some of the harsher reviews on here are unfair — this is definitely not frozen pizza and the sauce is not SpaghettiO’s. I ordered a classic cheese and pepperoni, which is always my go-to when trying a new spot, and the flavor was much better than those comparisons make it sound. The crust is thinner, leaning NYC style, but with Buffalo touches like the cup-and-char pepperoni and sweet sauce.
That said, I was left a little conflicted. For $25, the large pizza felt small (barely covering three-quarters of the box), and it was greasy enough that even after resting, the slices couldn’t really be folded like a proper NY slice. On top of that, I’ve tried calling multiple times in the past year during business hours with no answer, so I was just glad to finally get an order in.
I’ve heard great things about their wings, and I can see the potential in the flavor here. I plan on ordering again to try the wings or another menu item, because I really want to see where Diva’s shines. With so many pizza places close by, they’ll need that “wow” factor to stand out — but I’m hopeful it’s there.
… morericki k
NEVER AGAIN. Well i thought this place was going to be good with all the good reviews but sadly id give no stars if i could. called and ordered a small chz and pep, what i got was an old cold half of pizza. I am so beyond disappointed, i was expecting a fresh pie and this was disgusting. So i either got a half of someone elses pizza from however long ago or leftover slices.
… moreDiona Ellington
I’ve been a customer of Divas since I was a kid when they were located on Walden & Ruhland Avenue in Buffalo. Back then we use to get a coupon on the pizza boxes. The pizza recipe has been the same.. Very good.. Favorite pizza place..
… moreTubby Ranks
For 22 bucks I’m not complaining, it was a decent meal. Slices were thin like NYC style which I love, sauce was ok. Wings were fried extra crisp at my request, bbq sauce wasn’t that good. I’d eat there again.
… moreAaron Koscinski
Excellent pizza had large sausage with cheese. Cook to perfection
… moreT W
I can say easily this pizza was top notch! Ordered on Super Bowl first time ever trying here, and all I can say is WOW! Super delicious, and well worth every penny. You gained another customer! Thank you so much for making some good pizza! Anyone interested in trying this place out, you will NOT be disappointed!
… moreWanda Bystron
It’s a bare bones place for takeout only pizza…BUT..the absolute best pizza. You’re not going to get chicken wings or the other fanfare some places have…if you want the best pizza. DIVA’S is the place. A thinner crust where the sauce spills over and becomes carmelized and scrumptious! Consistent in quality and the owner is one of the nicest guys.
… moreLiv Kaetzel
Amazing pizza! We stopped in for two slices, chatted with who we assumed was the owner, and it was a lovely experience. We complimented his menu and prices, and he took the time to kindly thank us. We will 100% be back! Classic buffalo pizza, and I am sure the rest of his menu matches. We are excited to explore the rest of Diva’s menu. Thanks so much!
… moreKris Herbanek
Love this family owned pizzeria but I do feel like they changed the sauce from the origional version.
… moreadam derose
It’s my favorite place in Buffalo to go for pizza! The owner, Kenny, is very nice. Divas Pizza has been in business for 50 years, so that has to tell you something about their pizza!!
… more