Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–1:30 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–1:30 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–1:30 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1:30 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3848 N First Ave, Evansville, IN 47710
Phone: (812) 773-3195
Website: http://www.orderdimaggios.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
DiMaggio’s Pizza: Order DiMaggio’s
Tri-States best, traditional Italian pizza and pasta serving the Mount Vernon, Indiana area. Delivery and carry-out ready for dinner.
DiMaggio’s Pizza – Evansville 3848 North First Avenue – Order Online
Pizza Menu · 18″ BYO (Cheese). Cheese pizza, with your choice of toppings. · 18″ Deluxe. Topped with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions. · 18 …
DiMaggio’s Pizza – Evansville, IN – Facebook
The Italian Stallion has entered the kitchen! Juicy, stacked meatballs. Rich meat sauce. Melty cheese pulling with every slice. This isn’t just a pop-up…
Reviews
Amber Barrera
OH MY WORD!! THIS FOOD!!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — Great New Spot for Pizza, Sandwiches, & Pasta on Evansville’s North Side!!
I recently tried this new pizza place that also serves sandwiches and pasta, and it was an awesome experience! We ordered a ham and cheese sandwich, a roast beef sandwich (which reminds me of sir beef, IYKYK), a calzone, and Bosco sticks. Everything was fresh and flavorful, but the real standout was the marinara sauce — you can absolutely tell it’s homemade. It’s rich, perfectly seasoned, and takes the food to another level.
The sandwiches were generously filled and delicious, and the calzone had the perfect balance of cheese and fillings, especially when dipped in that incredible marinara. The Bosco sticks were warm, cheesy, and a tasty like none I’ve tasted before!!
If you’re looking for a spot that offers more than just your average slice, this place is definitely worth checking out. I’ll be back soon to try more of their menu! Congratulations DiMaggio’s on your new addition to Evansville!!
… more⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ — Great New Spot for Pizza, Sandwiches, & Pasta on Evansville’s North Side!!
I recently tried this new pizza place that also serves sandwiches and pasta, and it was an awesome experience! We ordered a ham and cheese sandwich, a roast beef sandwich (which reminds me of sir beef, IYKYK), a calzone, and Bosco sticks. Everything was fresh and flavorful, but the real standout was the marinara sauce — you can absolutely tell it’s homemade. It’s rich, perfectly seasoned, and takes the food to another level.
The sandwiches were generously filled and delicious, and the calzone had the perfect balance of cheese and fillings, especially when dipped in that incredible marinara. The Bosco sticks were warm, cheesy, and a tasty like none I’ve tasted before!!
If you’re looking for a spot that offers more than just your average slice, this place is definitely worth checking out. I’ll be back soon to try more of their menu! Congratulations DiMaggio’s on your new addition to Evansville!!
Heath Harlan
Pizza was great. The sauce I heard was a little sweet and I agree it does have a sweet flavor to it. The breadsticks seemed to harden a little fast but went well with the dips which outlasted the smaller portion of bread in comparison. Overall worth a repeat. The medium pizza looked like a large to me which was ok.
… moreEvansville Reviews
Just giving an honest review based on my taste and my experience.
The ham and cheese sandwich comes with tomatoes and lettuce and they wrapped the toppings separately which was great! The sandwich tasted good. The bread was especially good. The amount of ham on the sandwich was honestly a little ridiculous. One small thin slice on the sandwich. Unfortunate. It was $13.25 for one thin slice of ham. Stingy.
The chefs salad was just okay. The Kraft packaged ranch does not taste good. Again, stingy on the toppings. Maybe about half of a slice of thin ham and maybe 2 pepperonis. The lettuce was really fresh and crispy and clean. Just disappointed in the stingy amount of toppings. It was basically a $9 bowl of lettuce and low quality ranch.
Penne Alfredo Supreme……I’m sorry but all I can say is this was disgusting. I love mushrooms. This tasted like unsalted pasta with heavy cream and mushrooms and mushroom water. Does not taste like Alfredo. No salt/seasoning. Really bad. I ordered a cup of marinara as a side and I’m sorry to say but I found it disgusting. I’m sure it’s just a personal preference but I’ve never had such sweet yet salt-less marinara. I’m not a fan. The Alfredo was painfully lacking salt and any flavor.
The breadsticks that came with the Alfredo were EXCELLENT. Really great breadsticks and I’m really not a breadstick person.
I’m curious to try pizza. A little nervous since I really didn’t like the marinara. I will try pizza at some point. I’m sorry to say this visit was really a let down from the hype.
Another issue – and I do understand they just opened so there will be kinks, but I placed an order online at 4:55 and it said the order would be ready at 6:30. I know there’s a wait because they’re so busy so no worries. But I got a text at 5:11 that my order was ready. Don’t get me wrong I’m thrilled that it was so quick, but was almost an issue as I was headed grocery shopping to wait. So once I got the text, I turned around to get the food.
They forgot to give me my salad at pick up, but called within a few minutes telling me of the mistake. Again, no biggie as these things happen sometimes. Especially when a place is so busy. I did appreciate the call.
The breadsticks and the bread (from the sandwich) were delicious.
… moreThe ham and cheese sandwich comes with tomatoes and lettuce and they wrapped the toppings separately which was great! The sandwich tasted good. The bread was especially good. The amount of ham on the sandwich was honestly a little ridiculous. One small thin slice on the sandwich. Unfortunate. It was $13.25 for one thin slice of ham. Stingy.
The chefs salad was just okay. The Kraft packaged ranch does not taste good. Again, stingy on the toppings. Maybe about half of a slice of thin ham and maybe 2 pepperonis. The lettuce was really fresh and crispy and clean. Just disappointed in the stingy amount of toppings. It was basically a $9 bowl of lettuce and low quality ranch.
Penne Alfredo Supreme……I’m sorry but all I can say is this was disgusting. I love mushrooms. This tasted like unsalted pasta with heavy cream and mushrooms and mushroom water. Does not taste like Alfredo. No salt/seasoning. Really bad. I ordered a cup of marinara as a side and I’m sorry to say but I found it disgusting. I’m sure it’s just a personal preference but I’ve never had such sweet yet salt-less marinara. I’m not a fan. The Alfredo was painfully lacking salt and any flavor.
The breadsticks that came with the Alfredo were EXCELLENT. Really great breadsticks and I’m really not a breadstick person.
I’m curious to try pizza. A little nervous since I really didn’t like the marinara. I will try pizza at some point. I’m sorry to say this visit was really a let down from the hype.
Another issue – and I do understand they just opened so there will be kinks, but I placed an order online at 4:55 and it said the order would be ready at 6:30. I know there’s a wait because they’re so busy so no worries. But I got a text at 5:11 that my order was ready. Don’t get me wrong I’m thrilled that it was so quick, but was almost an issue as I was headed grocery shopping to wait. So once I got the text, I turned around to get the food.
They forgot to give me my salad at pick up, but called within a few minutes telling me of the mistake. Again, no biggie as these things happen sometimes. Especially when a place is so busy. I did appreciate the call.
The breadsticks and the bread (from the sandwich) were delicious.
Donald Hancock
Northside Evansville just got lucky! You can’t beat the sweet sauce, crispy crust and it’s from an Egde Conveyor pizza oven. It tastes like it came from the brick oven. They only use the highest quality ingredients and you can tell from each bite. I should have gotten a canoli but it slipped my mind. They are so good, I tried them at the Mt. Vernon location. They offer carry out and delivery to a good portion of the Northside but could meet at spots along 41 for those outside the delivery area Welcome to Evansville DiMaggio’s Pizza – Evansville, IN!Northside Evansville just got lucky! You can’t beat the sweet sauce, crispy crust and it’s from an Egde Conveyor pizza oven. It tastes like it came from the brick oven. They only use the highest quality ingredients and you can tell from each bite. I should have gotten a canoli but it slipped my mind. They are so good, I tried them at the Mt. Vernon location. They offer carry out and delivery to a good portion of the Northside but could meet at spots along 41 for those outside the delivery area Welcome to Evansville DiMaggio’s Pizza – Evansville, IN!
… moremike bellamy
I really wanted to like this place, but the pizza sauce and bread stick sauce were over the top sweet! Adding the option between that sweet sauce and a more traditional sauce would be my suggestion. Otherwise we won’t be returning.
… moreChris Carter
Anyone leaving a bad review here has no taste. This is hands down the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. I took some home to my family and they all agreed — it’s the best pizza they’ve ever had too. I genuinely can’t think of a better one.
The sauces are out of this world, and the breadsticks were phenomenal. I tried one at a company event and didn’t order them this time, but every single pizza I’ve had from here has been top-tier.
So far I’ve had the Hawaiian and the Super Deluxe, and at the company event we had pepperoni and a meat lovers. Every one of them was amazing.
Highly recommend this place!
… moreThe sauces are out of this world, and the breadsticks were phenomenal. I tried one at a company event and didn’t order them this time, but every single pizza I’ve had from here has been top-tier.
So far I’ve had the Hawaiian and the Super Deluxe, and at the company event we had pepperoni and a meat lovers. Every one of them was amazing.
Highly recommend this place!
Elise Mckeethen
Absolutely hands down the best pizza’s in the tristate area! You can’t get a better pizza anywhere else, and don’t get me started on the sauce. Absolutely delicious! Always worth any wait, the staff is kind, the food is good, and family owned. It doesn’t get better than DiMaggios! And don’t forget it get a tiramisu for dessert! So good!
… moreAlex Zimmerman
This is by far the best pizza I’ve had in town. A bit of sweetness in the sauce, but good balance. I’m coming back soon!
… moreRyan Sermersheim
Hands down the best pizza on the north side! Love it!
… moreKimberly Smith
I have had DiMaggio’s pizza from Carmi Il. for years and enjoyed thoroughly. So excited when I learned they were opening in Evansville. FINALLY………. just tried the North Park location. It was a beautiful pizza, plenty of good quality ingredients, good crust, BUT, I do agree with some of the other reviews, that the sauce is a little too sweet for me… tone that down a bit and it will be perfect.
… more