Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
A large, straightforward dining room serving hearty Amish-style dishes such as roast beef & pot pie.
Hours
| Friday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 445 Jefferson Ave, Plain City, OH 43064
Phone: (614) 873-3414
Website: https://dhgroup.com/restaurants/der-dutchman-plain-city-oh
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Der Dutchman | Plain City, Ohio
Enjoy Amish kitchen cooking and a bakery just west of Columbus, Ohio. Stop by for our hearty buffet, fresh-baked doughnuts & more.
Der Dutchman Restaurant and Bakery in Plain City – Facebook
We’re your destination for Amish kitchen cooking, located in Plain City, OH. . Follow · . Details. . Page · American Restaurant. . dhgroup.com.
Menus – Dutchman Hospitality
Restaurants / Der Dutchman Plain City / Menus. Der Dutchman – Plain City … Walnut Creek, OH 44687. Office. 4985 State Route 515. Millersburg, OH 44654.
Reviews
Maggie M
It had expanded since the last time I have been. Had a cafeteria vibe now. Lost it’s coziness.
Food was decent. Service was good. I got the buffet (13.99) thinking I’d get more bang for my buck from menu prices but it was a little limited it hot food area. Bacon looked better than it tasted. Had a rubber texture even though it looked perfect/ crisp. Offered Scrambled eggs, mini pancakes, French toast stickes, biscuits(dry) and gravy. No sauage patties. Only links. Great fruit bar and offered beautiful mini donuts on the bar. Took a dz of full size donuts home. ($26!) Definitely not budget friendly and most seemed bulk purchased and not from scratch. Very busy and popular place to meet up so be prepared to wait at busy times. * Rest rooms were spotless
… moreFood was decent. Service was good. I got the buffet (13.99) thinking I’d get more bang for my buck from menu prices but it was a little limited it hot food area. Bacon looked better than it tasted. Had a rubber texture even though it looked perfect/ crisp. Offered Scrambled eggs, mini pancakes, French toast stickes, biscuits(dry) and gravy. No sauage patties. Only links. Great fruit bar and offered beautiful mini donuts on the bar. Took a dz of full size donuts home. ($26!) Definitely not budget friendly and most seemed bulk purchased and not from scratch. Very busy and popular place to meet up so be prepared to wait at busy times. * Rest rooms were spotless
Svetlana Lee
My first visit to Der Dutchman was truly an eye-opening experience. I had never heard of this restaurant before attending a family dinner party here, and I was completely taken aback by how impressive the entire place was. The building is enormous, featuring a two-story gift shop filled with unique items, as well as a full bakery offering freshly made pies, fudge, donuts, and even fresh-brewed coffee. They clearly spare no expense when it comes to creating a welcoming and enjoyable experience for their guests.
When our party of 30 was called to be seated, I was genuinely impressed with how well the dining area was arranged. Even though our tables couldn’t be fully combined, the staff went above and beyond to ensure we were seated close enough to talk, laugh, and enjoy each other’s company comfortably. The service was excellent—our waitresses were friendly, attentive, and quick to take our orders and bring our drinks so we could start enjoying our meals right away.
The food selection was outstanding. There was a wide variety of options to choose from, including a full salad bar and two additional buffet bars offering an assortment of entrées, sides, and desserts. Everything looked fresh, plentiful, and thoughtfully prepared.
Overall, Der Dutchman exceeded all expectations. From the atmosphere to the service to the incredible range of food, this restaurant delivered an exceptional dining experience. I highly recommend it and will definitely be returning!
… moreWhen our party of 30 was called to be seated, I was genuinely impressed with how well the dining area was arranged. Even though our tables couldn’t be fully combined, the staff went above and beyond to ensure we were seated close enough to talk, laugh, and enjoy each other’s company comfortably. The service was excellent—our waitresses were friendly, attentive, and quick to take our orders and bring our drinks so we could start enjoying our meals right away.
The food selection was outstanding. There was a wide variety of options to choose from, including a full salad bar and two additional buffet bars offering an assortment of entrées, sides, and desserts. Everything looked fresh, plentiful, and thoughtfully prepared.
Overall, Der Dutchman exceeded all expectations. From the atmosphere to the service to the incredible range of food, this restaurant delivered an exceptional dining experience. I highly recommend it and will definitely be returning!
Josey Acton
Der Dutchman provided another great experience today. Server very good. Large buffet line was clean and well stocked. Buffet had their famous chicken, ham, roast beef, and pork for meat selections. Large salad bar. If you’re reading this review, please hit the “Like” ❤️ button.
… moreAnh Pham
We have visited several times over the past ~5 years. Some items are great while others are just okay. Overall it’s good place for some Amish style food. I’m sure we’ll be back again in a year or two.
… moreCraig
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Der Dutchman in Plain City is a must-visit if you love great Amish kitchen cooking. Everything is fresh, hearty, and full of that homemade comfort you just don’t find everywhere anymore.
The breakfast and dinner buffets are excellent, with a huge variety of items to choose from—something for everyone, and it’s all consistently delicious. You can really taste the care that goes into the food.
Der Dutchman is part of Dutchman Hospitality, which also includes Dutchman Valley and Berlin Farmstead restaurants, with locations in Bellville, Berlin, Walnut Creek, Sugarcreek, Plain City, and even Sarasota. They’ve clearly perfected what they do across all their locations.
Don’t skip the bakery before you leave. It’s packed with take-home goodies like cream pies, fruit pies, cinnamon rolls, cakes, donuts, and more—dangerously good and worth every calorie.
Friendly service, comforting food, and an overall great experience every time. Highly recommend!
… moreDer Dutchman in Plain City is a must-visit if you love great Amish kitchen cooking. Everything is fresh, hearty, and full of that homemade comfort you just don’t find everywhere anymore.
The breakfast and dinner buffets are excellent, with a huge variety of items to choose from—something for everyone, and it’s all consistently delicious. You can really taste the care that goes into the food.
Der Dutchman is part of Dutchman Hospitality, which also includes Dutchman Valley and Berlin Farmstead restaurants, with locations in Bellville, Berlin, Walnut Creek, Sugarcreek, Plain City, and even Sarasota. They’ve clearly perfected what they do across all their locations.
Don’t skip the bakery before you leave. It’s packed with take-home goodies like cream pies, fruit pies, cinnamon rolls, cakes, donuts, and more—dangerously good and worth every calorie.
Friendly service, comforting food, and an overall great experience every time. Highly recommend!
Russ Aikman
Such an amazing place. Either order off menu or hit the buffet out. Try the pie, its a 1/4th looking size. Finally on the way out, check out their 2 floor gift shop. They are closed on Sundays.
… moreMegan Dinatale
We did a banquet room and let me tell you how absolutely incredible it was!! From the wait staff to the food to the set up! I am so thankful this was an option! Everyone was so please with the food and I think it was worth every penny!
… moreDan Mast
Great place. I usually have the fried chicken but everything is good. Stay away from the bakery because I can never leave without a bag of goodies. Cookies, rolls, jam, etc. it’s all good. My wife loves the liver.
… moreAlan McFerrin (amcferrin90)
I haven’t been here in probably close to 5 years. We visited on Valentine’s Day and they were very busy. But there was a steady flow of people going in and out. They did a good job of facilitating the crowd. The food was good as always and expected. It was hot and fresh like my grandmother used to make. The buffet was well stocked too. The server was Garrett and he was very friendly and accommodating. A great experience as always.
… moreTravel With Rolando
Enjoyed a peaceful night’s rest through their Harvest Hosts Program. Woke up and stocked up on many delicacies and a few baked goods. Definitely a must stop for everyone traveling through Plain City!
… more