

Address and Contact Information
Address: 413 S Burritt Ave, Baraboo, WI 53913
Phone: (608) 678-5550
Website: https://www.dawnmanor.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Dawn Manor: New & Family-Friendly Restaurant in Wisconsin Dells WI
Dawn Manor | Baraboo WI – Facebook
Dawn Manor Restaurant, Bar & Speakeasy | Wisconsin Dells
Reviews
Our group ordered the dates, meatloaf with mac and cheese, prime rib, and chicken pot pie. Everything was delicious, hot, and fresh. Not to mention the portions were huge! We brought a lot of food home.
Before we left we hit up the speakeasy which was such a cool hangout spot. We enjoyed a couple after dinner grasshoppers which were SO incredible. Definitely a meal we won’t forget.
First the Speakeasy where it should be, in basments with touches of a bygone sportsman club. With just anough modern touches that it does not feel stuffy. Brandy Old Fashions, local craft beers, and long forgotten cocktails are to be savored while letting the atmosphere relaxes as unwind you from your day.
The original House was moved to its current location, then carefully retouched to give the vibe of dinning in someone’s home.
The menu is a mix of local classics and dishes from past eras. Bacon wrapped dates, a blast from my past were awesome. All dishes were received. One small disappointment, the chicke pot pie was beyond bland.Put some Bells spice blend in it, please.
The staff was awesome.
We will definitely visit again!
Let’s start with the positives. The staff at Dawn Manor are incredibly warm and attentive. From the moment we walked in, we felt genuinely welcomed, and it’s clear they care about giving guests a good experience. The drink menu also had a fun twist—particularly the Dream Soda, which was surprisingly refreshing and one of the highlights of the night.
That said, the main issue here is the food—specifically, the lack of seasoning. The flavors were just flat. We ordered the potato-crusted walleye, a dish that sounded promising on paper but was executed with almost no flavor. There wasn’t even salt on the table to try and salvage it, which felt like a miss for a place serving dishes that really needed a flavor boost.
Next up was the meatloaf, served over mashed potatoes and topped with macaroni and cheese—a quirky combo that had potential. The textures were fine, and the dish was comforting in its own way, but once again, everything tasted under-seasoned and dull. It felt like they were holding back on flavor across the board, which is frustrating when the kitchen clearly has ideas worth exploring.
The cheese curds were decent—crispy, not too greasy, but still lacking the savory punch you expect from a Wisconsin classic. With such fierce cheese curd competition around here, being “just OK” doesn’t quite cut it.
Overall, Dawn Manor has a lot going for it—great service, a cozy atmosphere, and a menu that shows ambition. But until the kitchen gets more confident with seasoning and boldness, it’s hard to recommend the food wholeheartedly. I’ll be rooting for them, though, because with a few adjustments, this place could be a standout. Here’s hoping they find their flavor soon.
The Chicken Melt was very tender and moist, and the bacon was really good. The Prime Rib Cheese Steak was large chunks of tender lean meat. Probably don’t need the fries on it, onion straws would be much better, but the sandwich was still a good choice. Lastly, the Uppy Burger was wonderful – full stop! I ordered it medium, and it came perfectly cooked, a little pink in the middle, the beef had that umami taste that I just can’t duplicate at home. The portions are huge, so we had to pass on dessert, but they looked great. The prices are much more affordable than the other supper club on Mirror Lake, and they take reservations, so no 2 hour wait. However, the “on Mirror Lake” is a little overstated, not the views like the other supper club. I would highly recommend Dawn Manor to anyone. I took the service down 1 star because they clearly are still learning, having been open for only 2 weeks, a little awkward delivering and clearing. I’m sure they will be at 5 stars very soon.