We are a dedicated NY style pizzeria, serving traditional style pizzas, calzones, and salads, with a collection of tap Dempsey Brewing Company beers. We have already been part of the Brookings Community for a year, and we look forward to the future! We have seating for up to 50 People, along with an outdoor patio, and a friendly, unique environment.
Owner Sean Dempsey is a Premiere member of the United States Pizza Team, and has won more than a few pizza awards nationally and internationally. This is our 4th location.
Pizza so good, it’s dangerous!
Herb
Good size portion for the house salad at $4 a portion. Pizza was decent size for the price. Not my favorite, the buffalo sauce was way too mild and you could hardly taste it. Overall I would say they are about one star above your typical Papa John’s location. No need to go out of your way to grab a pie from them.
The lemon cake was delicious and moist; however, for $6 the slice was about half the size it should be. If they charged $4 I wouldn’t say anything.
Staff was friendly and very accommodating. Couldn’t ask for more.
… moreRemington Lanenga
I have been here a few times now. Best pizza in town hands down. Fresh ingredients, classic and unique flavors. The staff is friendly and helpful. The Detroit Style was light and fluffy with that classic crust. The King Sausage is a must try
… moreKyra A
This place did not disappoint! The options you had were unique and all sounded delicious, but went with the Royale Hawaiian pizza, with that hot honey on top – how could you NOT choose that. I
also treated myself to a cheesecake cup and boy that was a solid treat! Rich, creamy, a little messy with the graham crackers, but i think it would be even better with a berry compote or chocolate syrup on top.
… moreLuke Johnson
Had never really found a good calzone until Danger Von Dempsey’s. Haven’t found one here I’ve disliked so far. Just pure class. Service is quick and the workers are very friendly. Overall just a great time. One of the places I’ll miss most when I graduate.
… moreLinnea
Friendly staff and clean space, just disappointed in my food. I ordered the steak Alfredo with mushrooms and onions and it was lukewarm borderline cold as soon as I got it and the mushrooms and onions were literally raw. I would not have ordered Alfredo if I had known the vegetables would be thrown in and not cooked. I feel like that’s something that should be advertised when it comes to hot food.
… moreIna Gk
Best European stile pizza around, with a wonderfully baked soft, thin crust as opposed to either thick crust or thin cardboard like crust in usual pizzerias.
… moreJenn Anderson
Danger von Dempseys Brookings is AMAZING!!!!!! I’m not a huge pizza pertain typically, but this pizza was INCREDIBLE! all of the ingredients were so fresh and flavourful. And the crust is so excellent. I’d seen tons of great reviews, so my expectations were already high… and they were exceeded!!!
The staff were also outstanding!
Pictured: The Greecian Strikes Back.
… moreLiam Murray
Very nice pie that they made. I got the classic, little to no grease, tasty crust, good flavor and texture, overall great experience. I will be returning for another. Staff was friendly when i picked it up.
… moreRichard Harkins
This is our new favorite pizza place in Brookings! Great hand-tossed crust smothered in lots of tasty toppings and mozzarella. The salads are outstanding, and way too big for one person. We split a pizza and salad and had plenty to take home. Try the raspberry vinaigrette dressing! Great variety of local beers, too.
… moreCorben Leo
Waited over an hour for calzones. No sauce or cheese. Hardly any of the ingredients I ordered in it. A hot pocket would’ve been better, which says everything.
Thankfully, I had some pizza sauce at home, but the attached picture shows how little was inside it.
Threw it away and ate elsewhere.
Dempseys in Watertown is great. This one, not so much. Nice staff, but do not recommend.
… more