Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 112 W Tiffin St, Fostoria, OH 44830
Phone: (419) 701-7028
Website: https://www.daddyandkayspizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Daddy and Kay’s (@daddyandkays) – Facebook
A mash-up of your favorite foods awaits at Daddy and Kay’s Pizza and Cheesecake, 112 W. Tiffin St., Fostoria, OH. Co-Owner Patricia “Kay” Julian explains …
Daddy and Kays Pizza & Cheesecakes EXPOSED – Fostoria, Ohio …
Our NY-style crust, gourmet cheesecakes, and fresh twists like pickle pizza deliver superior taste (4.8/5 vs. competitors’ 4.0-4.5), plus fast local delivery …
Daddy and Kay’s Pizza and Cheesecake | Ohio, The Heart of It All
Many pizzerias in Fostoria offer more than just pizza, so try some other local top dishes. Pasta, salads, calzones, sandwiches, and more can all give you …
Reviews
Tam
We ate here this evening for the first time and definitely will be returning in the near future. AWESOME menu very hard to pick just one thing my goodness it was delicious! We ate the steak and the chicken marcella. Both items did NOT disappoint! We’ll be choosing something different every time we go back, we want to try it all!! Staff was amazing and very attentive. Great job everyone See you next time!!
… moreJessica Buckler
We only wish this place wasn’t 5 hours from home. All the pastas are top notch. Cajun chicken is better than most places in New Orleans! The shrimp scampi was perfect with massive shrimp and several of them. The foldovers are a must if you like calzones but it is a bit different as the middle has cheese and then more toppings on top. The amount of cheese on the cheesy bread was absolutely wonderful. The neatest surprise was the pizza is made with imported Italian wheat. It will forever be on our list of places in Northwest Ohio just in case we find ourselves in that area again. The kids want to go back for their birthdays so it may be sooner than later.
… moreBELINDA BOCKBRADER
The Entrance Not Pictured.
Oh Yes!!! The steak was done to Perfection with a crusty sear on the outside “The Salad is a Meal in itself,” my Mom’s words. We Love loved the food!!! I have already told some family to go Here!! Excellent Everything!! Go just to see the Entrance, GORGEOUS !!!
IF I were to criticize Anything, it’s that you could give smaller amounts of dressing, which isn’t a Bad Thing to Me. I’m just Frugal… A You’ve Got to go SEE place!! Wishing you Well, Miss Kay!!
… moreOh Yes!!! The steak was done to Perfection with a crusty sear on the outside “The Salad is a Meal in itself,” my Mom’s words. We Love loved the food!!! I have already told some family to go Here!! Excellent Everything!! Go just to see the Entrance, GORGEOUS !!!
IF I were to criticize Anything, it’s that you could give smaller amounts of dressing, which isn’t a Bad Thing to Me. I’m just Frugal… A You’ve Got to go SEE place!! Wishing you Well, Miss Kay!!
V A Lew
Drove 45 minutes to try this restaurant. Ordered a pizza and a salad. After 35 minutes my salad arrived it was told my pizza would be out in a few minutes. About 15 minutes later the server told us there was a mistake and they never got our order. Mind you they were sending out carry out pizzas left and right. Their Facebook page said they prioritizing customers in the dining room. I sure feel like I was not a priority tonight. The salad was good. Now I have to find someplace to eat that is not closed, because I was not waiting another 20 minutes for them to make my pizza to go.
… moreHeidi Weiland
I love chicken bacon ranch pizza… ive had a lot of chicken bacon ranch pizzas… and this was the best I’ve had! Ive tried different cheesecakes from different places multiple times and its just not for me… Until I tried Kay’s buckeye cheesecake complete with a homemade buckeye! It was amazing. The staff was very friendly and our food was brought out quickly. We will definitely make the 45 minute trip again and spread the word about daddy and Kay’s pizza and cheesecakes. They currently don’t have a sign up so it can be a little tricky for out-of-towners… it is in the venue 18 red building!
… moreCharles Titus
Man our daughter bought us dinner here for our anniversary and it was literally amazing! We had their pizza many years ago but today literally showed us we have been missing out! You will not be disappointed!! The cheesecake is so good it will literally melt in your mouth!!
… moreBrooke Brandeberry
Hidden gem of Fostoria. Pizza is outstanding, but the pasta dishes rival that of a big city fine dining Italian restaurant. The chicken marsala and lasagna were amazing and full of flavor!
… morePamela Moore
Dinner was amazing!
Wings available for dine in and to die for! Fold over and Italian sub also for the win! Haven’t tried the cheesecake yet but it’s super huge! Our waitress was so sweet and very helpful. We ordered so much food to try a variety and the bill was very reasonable! Go try for yourself; you won’t regret it
… moreWings available for dine in and to die for! Fold over and Italian sub also for the win! Haven’t tried the cheesecake yet but it’s super huge! Our waitress was so sweet and very helpful. We ordered so much food to try a variety and the bill was very reasonable! Go try for yourself; you won’t regret it
Melissa Combs
Let me start by saying we drove 2 hours and 54 min to eat here and we were not disappointed! A few things you need to know….EVERYTHING is made from scratch,that means it takes time,it’s not out of jar so you will have to wait about 45min maybe a bit more,especially if it’s busy. Their pizza is not only handmade,it’s made in a stone oven. They only have 4 so BE PATIENT!! It was definitely worth the wait! The cheesecake is….ON ANOTHER LEVEL!!EVERYTHING we ate,and it was alot,was delicious! The owner Kay came out to the table multiple times and talked to us,the waitress Randi,was exceptional. 10 out of 10 recommend
… moreAlison Godfrey
Second time having Daddy and Kay’s, first time dining in. It is phenomenal! The atmosphere is lovely, staff is so welcoming and sweet, and it’s beautiful! Such a hidden treasure!
We ordered a chicken sub and a steak sub, both were absolutely delicious. The ciabatta bread was fresh and the perfect blend of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, they were large and super filling! We also ordered the chicken chunks with the speedy sauce and the sauce was AMAZING! As my kids would say, it was “bussin, bussin!” I would order it by the gallon!
We also ordered the sea food scampi and some Alfredo and again, delicious. Highly recommend for those that love pasta dishes. We ordered a sausage pizza to take home and also took some cheesecake cups to go. The pizza was just as good as when we got it the first time, it’s a delicious crust and definitely the best pizza in town. Honestly it’s the best restaurant in Fostoria hands down! The cheesecake is dangerous, I may gain 300 lbs knowing that’s in town so please keep it sold out
I definitely give our experience a 10/10. It was the first time I have left absolutely thrilled and satisfied at a restaurant in a LONG time! Felt like I traveled back to 2019. So many places have went down hill but this restaurant is truly raising the bar! I hope they continue to succeed and are in business for years to come!
Thank you!
… moreWe ordered a chicken sub and a steak sub, both were absolutely delicious. The ciabatta bread was fresh and the perfect blend of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, they were large and super filling! We also ordered the chicken chunks with the speedy sauce and the sauce was AMAZING! As my kids would say, it was “bussin, bussin!” I would order it by the gallon!
We also ordered the sea food scampi and some Alfredo and again, delicious. Highly recommend for those that love pasta dishes. We ordered a sausage pizza to take home and also took some cheesecake cups to go. The pizza was just as good as when we got it the first time, it’s a delicious crust and definitely the best pizza in town. Honestly it’s the best restaurant in Fostoria hands down! The cheesecake is dangerous, I may gain 300 lbs knowing that’s in town so please keep it sold out
I definitely give our experience a 10/10. It was the first time I have left absolutely thrilled and satisfied at a restaurant in a LONG time! Felt like I traveled back to 2019. So many places have went down hill but this restaurant is truly raising the bar! I hope they continue to succeed and are in business for years to come!
Thank you!