Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 214 Lenora St, McCall, ID 83638
Phone: (208) 634-5005
Website: http://crustysmccall.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Crustys Pizza – McCall
Live Music Schedule 2025 · Crustys Pizza · MENU. MORE. Crusty’s in McCall,ID: 214 Lenora St McCall,ID 83638 · (208)634-5005. OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK 4pm-9pm.
Crustys Pizza Idaho | McCall ID – Facebook
Crustys Pizza Idaho · Hot laps at @brundagemtn. · @benbreidingband live tonight @crustys_pizza_idaho from 6pm-9pm. · @benbreidingband tonight from 6pm-9pm.
Crustys Pizza (@crustys_pizza_idaho) · McCall, ID – Instagram
@benbreidingband live tonight @crustys_pizza_idaho from 6pm-9pm. Catch his latest interview with Crustys Addict. Link in the Bio above …
Reviews
Heather Feather
What a great pizza spot! Yummy beers on tap!
Love the old-school feels of the place with the VHS movies playing and oldies music
They also occasionally have live music here too, but we visited on a quiet Tuesday night.
… moreLove the old-school feels of the place with the VHS movies playing and oldies music
They also occasionally have live music here too, but we visited on a quiet Tuesday night.
Niclas
Crusty’s Pizza has completely exceeded my expectations and has become our go-to spot in McCall. Brian, the owner, has created something truly special here – a neighborhood eatery that perfectly captures the mountain town vibe while delivering exceptional food and atmosphere.
The homemade sourdough pizzas are absolutely incredible. The Big Crusty and 4-Pigs are my personal favorites, but I have to give special mention to the WildWest pizza with elk sausage – it’s truly out of this world and you won’t find anything like it elsewhere. The sourdough crust has the perfect balance of crispy exterior and chewy interior that only comes from authentic, carefully crafted dough.
What really sets Crusty’s apart is their expansion into BBQ offerings, and wow, are they knocking it out of the park! The wings are perfectly smoked and sauced and their homemade southern coleslaw is the perfect complement. It’s clear they’ve put the same attention to detail into their BBQ as they have with their pizzas.
The atmosphere is fantastic – the outdoor patio is cozy and inviting, especially around the fire pit on those cool mountain evenings. Their selection of beer and wine perfectly complements the food, and the live bands on Sundays and Wednesdays add such a great community feel to the place.
Brian has truly established a top-notch eatery that welcomes everyone. Whether you’re a local or just visiting McCall, Crusty’s is an absolute must-visit!
… moreThe homemade sourdough pizzas are absolutely incredible. The Big Crusty and 4-Pigs are my personal favorites, but I have to give special mention to the WildWest pizza with elk sausage – it’s truly out of this world and you won’t find anything like it elsewhere. The sourdough crust has the perfect balance of crispy exterior and chewy interior that only comes from authentic, carefully crafted dough.
What really sets Crusty’s apart is their expansion into BBQ offerings, and wow, are they knocking it out of the park! The wings are perfectly smoked and sauced and their homemade southern coleslaw is the perfect complement. It’s clear they’ve put the same attention to detail into their BBQ as they have with their pizzas.
The atmosphere is fantastic – the outdoor patio is cozy and inviting, especially around the fire pit on those cool mountain evenings. Their selection of beer and wine perfectly complements the food, and the live bands on Sundays and Wednesdays add such a great community feel to the place.
Brian has truly established a top-notch eatery that welcomes everyone. Whether you’re a local or just visiting McCall, Crusty’s is an absolute must-visit!
Nelida Safrit
Best thin crust pizza in McCall. First time we visited there was no one there yet. Brian was super friendly. He mentioned that they had live music on certain days. We were so happy with our pizza choice. Service was amazing! We returned for the live music on Sunday evening.
… morehappi “Joyful” NES
Sweet little delicious pizza parlor! Live music with uneven photos on the wall. Delicious dive pizza parlor!
… moredaniel christensen
This is by far the not only the best pizza I have ever had but the drinks whether it be the beer on tap or the non alcoholic drinks are local and tasty! I especially love coming on live music nights. The atmosphere is great inside and out all year round. They provide a nice bonfire outside during the colder months. Everything is hand-made, from the sauce to the pizza dough, being thrown in the air right in front of you. On non live music nights they still provide great music inside and out of the building. One great option is any pizza they offer can be made into a salad. Got to get them greens in! The owner and employees showcase care and attention to all orders and customers. I personally love the spicy elk sausage and the homemade in house spicy honey adds a smorgasbord of flavors. They also offer a few different in house made dipping sauces, my favorite is the garlic parmesan. If you’re in McCall it is a must have staple within the local community. If you haven’t been to Crusty’s Pizza you’re not getting the full mountain experience. On Mondays and Tuesdays they have smoked meat which is to die for. I can’t get enough of this place! I have to give a HUGE shout out to Crusty’s Pizza, the owner Brian, and all employees, for always making it a fun and delicious place to stop by when I’m in town!
… moreKelley Martin-Adams
Delicious pizza! Lovely thin crust, and obvious homemade sauce. We had the Margherita! There was local music that was the perfect energy. The entire place is low key, warm and inviting.
… moreKenneth Ashley
We walked out of our truck and immediately where just absolutely drawn to the smokey sweet smell of peppers being skillfully smoked for the house made habenaro honey… but was quickly embraced by the absolute quaint atmosphere of this pizza place… the owner Brain was ever so gracious to come to our table and tell me the story of the place and about their menu and their pursuit to continue to stick to the tradition of the original owner to source good local ingredients to keep a wide selection of also local beers and very choice wines…. they do live music every Friday during the winter as well as a fire crackling in the hearth. They recommended their signature pie and it (the SmokeJumper) didn’t disappoint it paired with a Big Crusty and a couple of local draft beers was an absolute must if you find yourself in or near McCall Idaho…the absolute best pizza in south western Idaho… hands down
… moreKorynne Van Riper
Yes, this place is crusty but they have the best pizza in Idaho. We love their elk sausage pizza with cranberries, smoke jumper I think. There isn’t a lot of seating inside, ordering to go might be the best option for most. We love the hometown crusty vibes though. The staff are always nice and helpful. We always stop when we come to my grandpas in McCall and I wish we had this pizza place in Coeur D’Alene!
… moreJenna R
This was the worst pizza we have ever had. I have never had such a terrible pizza before. A frozen pizza from the grocery store is better than this. The crust was a joke. The sauce tasted like nothing. The quality was the lowest. The place is not clean. Along with the employees. The prices are a joke. I will never return and I will tell everyone I know not to. This place needs shut down for so many reasons. The only thing I can think of when I see the 5 star reviews is they are friends or don’t have taste buds. Do not waste your money here or find out the hard way like I did.
… moreJen Olsun
After skiing Brundage all day, this place was the best decision for dinner! We were greeted by the biggest smiles and the really nice guy who took our order seemed genuinely happy to serve us and make us pizza. Also the trees outside were dazzling with Christmas lights, which made me happy lol.
We chose the 12” Smokejumper pizza which had elk sausage, cranberries, jalapeños and feta. It was SO DELICIOUS. The sourdough crust (made in-house) was thin and crispy. To top it off he gave us two little containers of I think roasted garlic sauce which was fire. The pizza with the sauce was so juicy, flavorful and exciting. And the man working was a genuinely happy guy, we felt so welcomed and left happier than we entered.
Something to note, they don’t sell by the slice! Our 12” smokejumper pizza came out to about $26 and it fed my husband and I. Will definitely come back if skiing in the area again! ✨
… moreWe chose the 12” Smokejumper pizza which had elk sausage, cranberries, jalapeños and feta. It was SO DELICIOUS. The sourdough crust (made in-house) was thin and crispy. To top it off he gave us two little containers of I think roasted garlic sauce which was fire. The pizza with the sauce was so juicy, flavorful and exciting. And the man working was a genuinely happy guy, we felt so welcomed and left happier than we entered.
Something to note, they don’t sell by the slice! Our 12” smokejumper pizza came out to about $26 and it fed my husband and I. Will definitely come back if skiing in the area again! ✨