Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 231 North St, Madison, WI 53704
Phone: (608) 241-4284
Website: http://crostinimadison.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Crostini Sandwiches – Maple Bluff, Madison, WI
Always fresh, always delicious, great variety of options. It’s the bomb. Similar prices to other fast food sandwich shops but the quality makes stopping here …
About Us – Crostini Sandwiches in Madison
Crostini Sandwiches serving Madison, WI with outstanding food and service.
Crostini Sandwiches | Madison WI – Facebook
Crostini Sandwiches, Madison. 1346 likes · 15 talking about this · 594 were here. Wide array of sandwiches including Italian beef, hotdogs, panini, sub…
Reviews
Emily DeRusha-Kozik
The staff is so nice, food was fantastic and quick. The portions and prices are very reasonable. The meatball Panini was the best!
… moreRandi Lindberg
Ahhh-FREAKING-mazing. Food was fire. Service was fire. Will be one of new favorite spots!
… moreSharon Bjyrd
Food was good and serving size was big. The gyro had plenty of meat, the fries were super sized and made from real potatoes, the burger was heavy (bought it for someone else. Not sure if the taste but the package felt heavy). Service was really good. The place was a bit dusty and old. But some might like the charm of that.
… moreErin Murphy
I was hungry for a sandwich and soup and knew I could find that here. Ordered the chipotle turkey sub and the chicken noodle soup. Sandwich was delectable, but I didn’t get to taste the soup due to a food allergy. Didn’t think to ask if zucchini was an ingredient since it’s not a typical chicken noodle soup addition, in my experience anyway. Total bummer town. They were nice about it and I swapped out for a bag of chips. Not a super fair trade on my end, but I don’t need to hassle anyone over a few bucks for soup. They did offer me chili instead, but I wasn’t feeling that today. Staff is super nice. The place could really use a facelift which is why it’s getting 4/5 here. It’s so dark and the seating is odd, but the food I did eat was great and came out fast. It has the potential to be really cute inside and brightened up a ton. Add some plants and get rid of the games!
… moreMatt
Panini great – good flavor and large size
Fries – meh, I’ve had worse but wouldn’t get again.
“Home squeezed” lemonade is a complete and utter lie. It 100% was powdered lemonade with a slice of lemon for garnish.
… moreFries – meh, I’ve had worse but wouldn’t get again.
“Home squeezed” lemonade is a complete and utter lie. It 100% was powdered lemonade with a slice of lemon for garnish.
Candice Sandvick
10/10! Got the frisco fries (which is fries topped with mozzarella, parmesan, white and green onions, Crostini signature mustard sauce, black pepper, & fresh parsley.) and a chicken & steak Philly sandwich’s! So fresh and amazing!
… moreJosh Sorenson
The other day I popped into Crostini Sandwiches and grabbed a beef sandwich and fries. I’ve got to say, it was stellar! The cheese topping was spot-on – just enough to make each bite gooey and delicious. It seriously took me on a nostalgic trip back to when I was a kid enjoying my mom’s homemade Italian beef. The bread was just right too, not to mention the perfect balance of meat, cheese, and sweet peppers.
One suggestion though, it would be nice if they kept salt and pepper on the tables for some added customization.
The place itself has a quirky charm, with an old-school vibe and even a couple of arcade machines for some post-meal fun. The bathroom is tucked away in the back corner, just so you know. Parking’s a bit tight in their lot, but you’ll usually find plenty of spots on the nearby streets.
All in all, I’d say Crostini Sandwiches is definitely worth a visit. I’m already excited about my next trip there and introducing my friends to this gem when they’re in town. Give it a shot, you won’t be disappointed!
… moreOne suggestion though, it would be nice if they kept salt and pepper on the tables for some added customization.
The place itself has a quirky charm, with an old-school vibe and even a couple of arcade machines for some post-meal fun. The bathroom is tucked away in the back corner, just so you know. Parking’s a bit tight in their lot, but you’ll usually find plenty of spots on the nearby streets.
All in all, I’d say Crostini Sandwiches is definitely worth a visit. I’m already excited about my next trip there and introducing my friends to this gem when they’re in town. Give it a shot, you won’t be disappointed!
Caitlin Fitzpatrick
John (manager/owner) was startlingly rude when I called for help with an order. I was excited to check out a local place but I’ll never come here again. Really disheartening. EDIT: Owner replied to my review and is denying this, but I have the call log, bank transactions, and email receipt to prove it. Call was placed at 2:18pm on 1/9/26. If this gets deleted I will be reposting. They are denying there’s a manager but I was put on hold by the first person who answered the phone and told he had to get a manager to cancel my order. The person who came on the phone identified themselves as John, who then proceeded to be so rude to me that others in the room with me gasped. I’m not sure how denying any of this is easier than just apologizing.
… moreilein taipe
It was my boyfriend and I’s first time here we ordered Italian beef and a Gyro platter. Wow! Wow!we felt we felt like we were in Chicago or New York Thank you to the cooks and the service!! we will be back. We finally found a place that knows how to make these!! Delicious and fresh! ❗️
… moreLauren Grabau
The guy working behind the counter was nice and the service was fast, but I cannot recommend this place for anyone who doesn’t eat meat. There are 0 vegan options and all 7 of the vegetarian sandwich options felt random or coincidental (my sandwich turned out to have both slices of carrots and French fries in it). I’d looooove if this place invested in adding some thoughtful vegetarian/vegan options
… more