Craft Tacos & Tequila in Mohegan Lake, NY serves fresh, chef-driven tacos, handcrafted margaritas, and a vibrant seasonal dining experience. Known for Taco specials, cold beers on tap, upscale cocktails, and immersive holiday décor, Craft is Westchester’s destination for tacos, tequila flights, and weekend vibes.
jdorset1 (That Dude)
My wife had the Bang Bang shrimp taco and that was a very delicious taco. I had to try their Al Pastor taco and I have to say it was good taco. Wasn’t as smoky as I like it but I would still order it again. Now as far as the 4 tacos on the table, I haven’t been here before but my wife has. She ordered hers and I was exploring. Unfortunately when they delivered the food, they gave us the wrong food. So needless to say my experience was up and down. My wife was let down cause she had her heart set on these delicious tacos that I ate. So for now my wife and I will go at different times till I become more familiar with menu to give better reviews. Overall I give it an 8. Definitely coming back.
… moreLauren Martinelli
Everything was so amazing. Their happy hour is so good, cheap cocktails and beer (6$ mojito!). They also have a great happy hour food menu as well. Definitely will be coming back for trivia nights and the Thursdays they have live music! Btw my server/ bartender Allen gave amazing suggestions that I loved!
… moreDeborah Kole
I visited Craft Tacos & Tequila for dinner with friends and was impressed by how organized the service felt from the start. The host seated us promptly and our server walked us through the menu, explaining the different taco options and house-made sauces. I ordered a combination of grilled steak and shrimp tacos, and the presentation was clean and thoughtfully arranged. The tortillas tasted fresh, and the fillings were well-seasoned without being overpowering. Our server checked in at appropriate intervals and refilled drinks without us having to ask. The restaurant maintained a lively atmosphere while still feeling comfortable for conversation. The overall experience felt structured and professionally managed.
… moreEcedro Perez
SECOND EDIT: This business creates fake AI generated reviews after ever poor review someone leaves to keep their rating at least to 4 stars and they slander all the REAL reviews saying they’re fake. What a pitiful joke. I’m disgusted I ever gave this business money. Clearly the management does not care about customers. This place needs to work on social etiquette and basic respect how they treat customers is disgusting.
EDIT: I am absolutely appalled by the response of the negligent owner/manager slandering every customer’s poor review as “fake” to avoid accountability for their carelessness, mistreatment of customers, and lack of class.
I have attached a photo of my receipt. I never leave reviews but this place was so distasteful and disturbing I decided to leave my first google review… Congrats!
Original review:
I used to come here all the time a few months ago, ever since management has change the establishment has went down hill. First I ordered a mojito it took 20 minutes and when served to me it was watered down like it had been sitting. After 50 minutes of waiting we finally got our food and it was cold and the tortillas tasted stale. It was disgraceful so we didn’t even eat our food I just wanted a refund at that point. When we asked to speak with the manager she was nowhere to be found. When they finally found her she treated us as if we were incompetent and was extremely condescending. Completely unprofessional and was refusing to refund our food even though we had not taken more than one bite of our taco. It’s sad to see a restaurant that was once good and lively be completely destroyed by arrogant and inadequate management.
… moreIsiah Konnor
I stopped by Craft Tacos & Tequila for lunch and appreciated the detailed menu descriptions. The staff explained portion sizes and spice levels, which helped me decide on the chicken tinga tacos and a side of street corn. The food arrived quickly and was plated neatly with fresh garnishes. The flavors were balanced, and the ingredients tasted fresh rather than overly processed. I also ordered one of their signature drinks, and it was prepared carefully with noticeable attention to detail. The dining area was clean and well-maintained throughout my visit. Service remained attentive without feeling rushed.
… moreMadelynn Jeremy
I visited Craft Tacos & Tequila to celebrate a small occasion and found the atmosphere upbeat but comfortable. The staff provided a detailed overview of taco combinations and recommended pairings with their drink menu. I tried the carnitas tacos along with a house margarita, and both were prepared with noticeable care. The balance of seasoning and freshness stood out compared to other places I have tried. Food timing was well-managed, with appetizers arriving promptly and entrées following at the right pace. Tables and surrounding areas were kept clean throughout the evening. The service felt professional and consistent.
… moreNathanial Haiden
Our family chose Craft Tacos & Tequila for a weekend dinner, and the experience was consistent from start to finish. After being seated, the server reviewed specials and clarified dietary options for one of our guests. I ordered fish tacos with a side of rice and beans, and everything was served hot and well-portioned. The fish was crisp yet tender, and the toppings complemented the flavor without overwhelming it. Staff monitored tables regularly and cleared plates efficiently. The environment felt welcoming and organized even during peak hours. It was clear that both kitchen and front-of-house operations were coordinated smoothly.
… moreEthen Lexie
My experience at Craft Tacos & Tequila was well organized from the moment we arrived. The host managed the waitlist efficiently, and we were seated within the estimated time. Our server explained ingredients clearly and answered questions about spice levels. I ordered a trio of specialty tacos, and each one had distinct flavors and fresh toppings. The kitchen presentation was tidy and visually appealing. Staff maintained steady communication with guests and handled requests promptly. The combination of structured service and quality food made the visit enjoyable.
… moreJaime Sahadeo
My $15 grilled shrimp quesadilla. Ummm…. No. Just no. The person who took the order was Mexican food hearing impaired – I say “shrimp quesadilla”, she says “Okay, short rib quesadilla”. Shrimp quesadilla’s only flavor was “salty”. The pico was tomato & onions with 2 pieces of cilantro; again, no flavor. Could not understand “maudros” and put another employee on the phone. They did not have them “in stock”. Better off going to the gas station grill and getting what they offer. This is not worth the $$$.
… moreClay Payton
During a casual lunch at Craft Tacos & Tequila, I noticed how efficient the ordering and service process was. After seating, our server provided a detailed overview of the menu and offered recommendations based on spice level and portion size. The kitchen prepared our meals quickly, and each plate was garnished thoughtfully. Drinks were served promptly, and any requests for substitutions were accommodated without confusion. Overall, the service felt structured and attentive, and the combination of food quality and staff professionalism made the visit enjoyable.
… more