Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family owned & operated, the Miller Family opened Courthouse Pizzeria in 2015. We converted the former Whitey’s Army Navy store and prior to that the original Medina Courthouse, into a local gathering spot for families and friends to be able gather and enjoy a slice or whole pie of authentic NY Style Pie. Courthouse Pizzeria only uses quality ingredients to offer our Guests award-winning NY Style Pies (AKA Pizza). We make our dough & sauce in-house every morning, our veggies are cut fresh, we use the best cheeses available and our proteins are only of the highest quality. We recently added a full-service bar offering a wide variety of beer, wine and cocktails. Hope to see you soon!
Warm, family-owned spot serving NY-style slices & pies with creative toppings in casual environs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2 Public Square, Medina, OH 44256
Phone: (330) 952-1743
Website: http://www.courthousepizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Courthouse Pizzeria
Courthouse Pizzeria is a Family-Owned Pizzeria, offering true NY-Style … Medina Courthouse (built in 1821). We serve traditional NY Style Pie, making …
Courthouse Pizzeria, LLC – Visit Medina County
Courthouse Pizzeria, LLC … We opened Courthouse Pizzeria in 2015, converting the oldest building in Medina, Ohio into a gathering spot for local friends and …
Review of Courthouse Pizzeria in Medina, OH – Facebook
Courthouse Pizzeria Medina, OH. Was out of town on a camping trip with the boys. This place was very solid, especially the pepperoni …
Reviews
JF Jones
Great pizza joint in downtown Medina, OH. Service was excellent, polite, and fast. The pizza had a crisp crust. The sauce wasn’t over powering and the cheese was real mozzarella. Order by the slice or by the pie. The NY style was amazing. True NY style with slices as big as my hand. They have a bar but it was not open while we dined.
… moreMika nedeljkovic
Completely disappointed!! My daughter ordered the margarita pizza …so wet and soggy it was not able to be eaten. I ordered a supreme as you can see a pile of COLD raw veggies and even told the worker it was awful and not offered anything in its place!! Paid $ 28.00 for 3 people and only 1 ate…. Very upset and disappointed…. Money wasted and still hungry!
… moreJeramie Ellsworth
Very neutral critic here… first time at courthouse pizza
– Staff was very inviting, explained everything you need to know for your first time.
– Pizza was just Ok, absolutely nothing special like some reviews state.
– I waited 15 min for two slices of NY pizza, originally I was the only customer in the restaurant before I ordered, just to have a party of four who came in after me get served first. That was interesting.
– Pizza was mediocre at best, definitely had the memorable NY size. But the crust color, flavor profile and sauce reminded me of frozen middle school lunch pizza.
– Atmosphere was awesome, great historical pictures on the wall, warm inviting space and lighting.
This place could be so much more. Maybe I’ll try this again in 6 months. But I highly doubt it.
… more– Staff was very inviting, explained everything you need to know for your first time.
– Pizza was just Ok, absolutely nothing special like some reviews state.
– I waited 15 min for two slices of NY pizza, originally I was the only customer in the restaurant before I ordered, just to have a party of four who came in after me get served first. That was interesting.
– Pizza was mediocre at best, definitely had the memorable NY size. But the crust color, flavor profile and sauce reminded me of frozen middle school lunch pizza.
– Atmosphere was awesome, great historical pictures on the wall, warm inviting space and lighting.
This place could be so much more. Maybe I’ll try this again in 6 months. But I highly doubt it.
EL
Courthouse Pizzeria is a must-visit! The pizza is always fresh, loaded with toppings, and baked to perfection. The crust is just the right mix of crispy and chewy. Friendly staff and a great atmosphere make it even better. Highly recommend!
… moreS L
Great NY style pizza the pizza wasn’t cheep but you get what you pay for hand tossed delicious pizza. The pepperoni cups were so good!
… moreC Sanyk
Their take on NY style is very good, and accurate to what I remember from my trips to NYC. Really nice place to sit down for a piece.
… moreDavid Howard
Jazz band plays every Thursday night. Place was packed, band was great. NY style slices or rock crust whole pizza. Just traveling through the area, glad i bumped into this place. Very well worth effort!
… moreJohn Schuck
Good pizza, although not as ‘New York Style’ as is should be. The meat lovers was excellent. The Gluten Free cauliflower crust was a disappointment, too small for the price. The restaurant was cold and drafty. The service was acceptable. Three pizza’s, with 4 drinks, comfortably feed 7 people for $85.
… moreAlly
Literally the best pizza shop in Ohio I drive 40 minutes just to get pizza here. It’s the only place that actually tastes like authentic New York styled pizza. Love
edit: after reading the review of this place jesus the bad reviews sound dumb not one of them was valid. you all need to think before you’re posting
… moreedit: after reading the review of this place jesus the bad reviews sound dumb not one of them was valid. you all need to think before you’re posting
Shawn Wilson
Absolutely amazing New York style thin crust pizza! Very generous with the toppings and fun atmosphere.
… more