Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Classic American fare, including a Sunday prime-rib brunch, in a restored barn & banquet hall.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 345 Hickory Hollow Rd, Waterford, WI 53185
Phone: (262) 534-9291
Website: https://www.cottonexchangewi.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cotton Exchange – Gift Card – Cotton Exchange
Cotton Exchange Welcome to the Cotton Exchange where a unique blend of … 345 Hickory Hollow Rd Waterford WI 53185 · (262) 534-9291 · cottonexchangewi …
Cotton Exchange | Waterford WI – Facebook
Santa Brunch is this Sunday. Join us for an all you can eat Prime Rib buffet featuring the big guy himself! Reservations available from 10A.M. until 1:30P.M.
Cotton Exchange | Venue – Waterford, WI – Wedding Spot
A relaxed yet chic venue for your big day! With a recently renovated banquet hall, restrooms, and bar area, it is contemporary and sleek with stylish remnants …
Reviews
Steve Reeves
Delicious food! Fast, friendly, and helpful service. Fun atmosphere and great place to eat. Family and kid friendly. Everything we ordered was incredible! I had the Fried Fish…. It came with 4 pieces of cod, 2 potato pancakes, bread, coleslaw, apple sauce, and tartar sauce… I was stuffed! I can’t wait to come back. I highly recommend eating at the Cotton Exchange.
… moreMartha Meyer
I love this restaurant and will definitely return but I was very disappointed yesterday. I ordered a 10 oz. filet, medium well. When I got it, it didn’t even look like a fillet and was almost burned. I should have sent it back. The waiter told me, before I ordered it, it would melt in my mouth. It was chewy. I hope it’s better next time. It also was very noisy at the bar. We had a great waiter, Kenny.
… moreColleen Weber
Went to Cotton Exchange for their Bunch on Sunday. It was great. They even had prime rib sliced along with the regular breakfast sides. The eggs are made individually for you how you want them done. They had salad, desserts, spaghetti, beef and noodles, chicken and many other dishes. It was very reasonable priced. Party of 6 with 2 children and bill was only $107.
It was so good my husband and I went there to celebrate our anniversary 2 weeks later after looking at pricing for steaks at closer establishments. We made the right decision. I had Steak Oscar and my husband had a 10 oz Filet. It came with salad or soup, vegetables, rolls and baked potatoes. It was awesome. They only purchase the top beef from approved sources. Steaks were under $40. It my favorite restaurant and atmosphere is country with great wood design for warm and cozy feelings.
… moreIt was so good my husband and I went there to celebrate our anniversary 2 weeks later after looking at pricing for steaks at closer establishments. We made the right decision. I had Steak Oscar and my husband had a 10 oz Filet. It came with salad or soup, vegetables, rolls and baked potatoes. It was awesome. They only purchase the top beef from approved sources. Steaks were under $40. It my favorite restaurant and atmosphere is country with great wood design for warm and cozy feelings.
Scott W
Have been to the actual restaurant a couple of times. I remember it being a good (but not great) experience. I was happy to see that they were a vendor at the Waterford River Rhythms concert at the Village Hall Park.
They offered a couple of sandwiches. We got one of each. The Italian Beef and the Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap. Both were good. The beef was tender, and so was the chicken.
Couple of suggestions. They add the giardiniera into the beef. My preference is to have it available as a condiment, so you can add as little/much as you like. The wrap was large, and stuffed full of chicken, which would think was a good thing, but it could have benefited from having a bit more of the green salad fixings inside. To give it more textures and flavors. Also, they only have one type of potato chip, plain (and boring). How about offering another choice (Sea Salt and Vinegar)?
Super nice service, and it’s a reasonable value for what you get.
… moreThey offered a couple of sandwiches. We got one of each. The Italian Beef and the Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap. Both were good. The beef was tender, and so was the chicken.
Couple of suggestions. They add the giardiniera into the beef. My preference is to have it available as a condiment, so you can add as little/much as you like. The wrap was large, and stuffed full of chicken, which would think was a good thing, but it could have benefited from having a bit more of the green salad fixings inside. To give it more textures and flavors. Also, they only have one type of potato chip, plain (and boring). How about offering another choice (Sea Salt and Vinegar)?
Super nice service, and it’s a reasonable value for what you get.
Mary Therese Bloechl
It’s been a minute since I’ve eaten here last. The seafood was good, steak flavor was delicious. I felt the server could have been more friendly. The busser had more personality than the waitress. Hoping maybe she had an off night. It seemed quiet in there & expected a better serving experience for the price. I’d give the specialty drinks an A+.
Great drink menu!!
… moreGreat drink menu!!
Darrel Hossalla
Gotta say we had a terrible meal last night,, Service was good.. I had the prime rib and got a generous cut,,But it was so dry and extreamely tough. My wife had the Walleye and it was a very small filet. And we both had a scoop of the cold cheezy hash browns. There was only a handful of tables at 6:00 on a Saturday night. We each had a cocktail,, NOT Complaining on the price but we walked out with a $90 bill including tip for a awful meal.. Think we will put cotton Exchange on the back burnner for a while
… morerenee martin
The steaks are ALWAYS tender and well cooked. The drinks are reasonably priced and amazing, especially the pineapple upside-down martini! The staff is super friendly! One of our favorite restaurants!
… moreKim M.
My friends and I came for the Sunday brunch buffet because the restaurant was next to the authors fair venue. It was around noon and the soup looked coagulated and unappetizing. The food was adequate at best. Lower your expectations if you ask for a waffle. It’s so small it fit on an appetizer plate. The desserts looked as if they were once wrapped in plastic.
… moreJulie A
At the Cotton Exchange as a wedding vendor. Having a blast partying and celebrating the newlyweds tonight.
The venue is amazing and the staff is so friendly and attentive to the guests’ needs! Was great working with them tonight. Clean bathrooms, clean bar, excellent food. Can’t wait to come back!
Julie
Ring Tunes
Photobooth assistant
… moreThe venue is amazing and the staff is so friendly and attentive to the guests’ needs! Was great working with them tonight. Clean bathrooms, clean bar, excellent food. Can’t wait to come back!
Julie
Ring Tunes
Photobooth assistant
Jessica Lynn Gibbs
This restaurant is amazing. The food is very fresh with fantastic taste and flavors.
We came for Sunday morning brunch. I ordered an omlet with everything. This is the best omlet I’ve ever had.
We will be very frequent return customers 🙂
… moreWe came for Sunday morning brunch. I ordered an omlet with everything. This is the best omlet I’ve ever had.
We will be very frequent return customers 🙂