Jackie Adler
We stopped here on a late Monday morning at the end of June. It was fairly quiet with just a few other customers while we were there. I was excited to try the place after seeing so many great reviews.
First, I will not that the customer service was polite, but not warm or friendly. We ordered 2 breakfast sandwiches and a muffin and I initially opted to wait inside for my order. The employees rather abruptly asked me to go outside so as not to crowd the small space inside. I did as they asked, but the staff member who later came out with our items seemed annoyed. I was very confused by all of this.
As far as the food goes, it was okay. The blueberry muffin was fine. Our breakfast sandwiches were good, but I felt they were on the pricier side for an item that was pretty much the same as it would be anywhere else.
If you are in the area and curious to see what the excitement is about, you might stop by. I just wouldn’t go out of the way.
… moreHeather A.
Perfect stop for muffins and hot coffee (or other treats). We had the dirt bomb muffin (nutmeg muffin rolled in butter & cinnamon sugar). It was amazing!! Cute spot with outdoor seating.
… moreAndrew Halloran
Great breakfast! The omelette sandwiches on croissant and bread are delicious. We also had muffins and scones, also good. The scones were moist and had the texture of muffins, not dry like we expected, nonetheless they were great. There was no line when we went which was awesome, unlike other breakfast places in the area. I’d recommend trying the specialty muffins that you can’t get anywhere else. We had one called “dirtybomb” That was cinnamon and sugar, and a real treat.
… moreMike Maria
Very good bakery on the outer Cape. They have a good variety of baked goods. The cakes are good too. We had a chocolate mousse bomb that was delicious.
… morePaul W
Picked up some baked goods for a get together dessert. Nice selection and appropriate size for sharing. Lemon tart was great as was the chocolate covered cheesecake. The key lime was a step below great. Also snuck in a dirt bomb and I really enjoyed it
… morenancy burdick
Ordering a special occasion cake for a surprise party in our new hometown, turned out to be “a piece of cake”. Cottage Street Bakery was recommended by a friend and the cake they made was out of this world! While the bakery offers online custom ordering/payment, I phoned the shop a few weeks early to inquire about business hours on Thanksgiving weekend and for cake flavor combination recommendations. The chocolate fudge cake with chocolate ganache filling and cream cheese icing impressed the newly engaged couple and our other guests. The icing was finger-licking-good and no leftovers. This is a neighborhood gem and our new go to bakery.
… moreKayla Bauerlein
Quite literally the best muffin I’ve had in my whole life. I got the raspberry lemon poppy seed and it was not overly sweet, incredibly moist, and the perfect size/texture. I will be going back here and trying others!
… moreDanielle Korell
The dirt bomb is delicious! Excellent breakfast sandwich, cheese danish, and muffins!
… moreThomas Wessling
Such great food. Lovely staff. They accomdated a food request readily and quickly for one of our kiddos without us actually ever asking actually. Delicious vegetarian sandwich. So many baked good to choose from.
… morelucy wightman
Today I got the last Dirt Bomb muffin. The lovely cashier warned me, “it’s broken.” Fine by me!! I would have posted a photo of it but it’s gone.
The Dirt Bomb is served warm and is a delectable, moist, mouth-watering treat with melted butter throughout. It’s like eating cinnamon sugar toast but oh so much better.
… more