Alexandra Rutigliano
Cotardo’s is one of my favorite Italian restaurants. The food is consistently delicious; the prices are super reasonable; the portions are large (love leftovers!); they give you bread, a little soup and a little salad with entrees; it’s BYOB; and the servers are consistently kind. No reservations so plan ahead for the weekends and larger parties 🙂 Pictured is the frutti di mare in white sauce – YUM!
… moreEveline Dickens
I’ve lived in the area for a while and somehow never tried this place until today and honestly, what was I waiting for?! The food was good (just needs a little more seasoning), and the portions are huge. You definitely get your money’s worth and will have leftovers for the next day. Everything was delicious, and I’ll for sure be back again soon.
… moreShelly Mason
Had a great meal. The portion sizes are huge, had alot left to bring home. Entrees come with soup and salad so come hungry. There are no reservations so be prepared to wait on busier nights.
… moreMegan P
I’m so disappointed. I went here for a work dinner 2 months ago and it was great. I came back and only got garlic bread to go, and it was still cold and was not toasted at all! Unfortunately it’s gonna be soggy by time I get home from work.
… moreKrista Ellingsworth
This was our third visit to this establishment. The first two visits were really outstanding. They were both well over a year ago. This visit we both decided to try all new entrees. The bread is outstanding. Soup and salad were good. Our entrees were generously portioned. But the shrimp were not good. We sent them back. Our server was outstanding, friendly, and attentive. He made sure to make up for the issue immediately. I’m sure we will be back again to try something new.
… moreMaxine Smith
The food was good but over-hyped. My Mom and I came here with pretty high expectations because we heard really great things about Cotardo’s online. Once we actually arrived (and after a 20 minute wait, Saturday evening), we were excited to see that interior was designed beautifully and felt really cozy. The service was also great as our waiter Avery was very personable and attentive. Sadly, the food was a bit of a disappointment. Not bad, just a bit average! The appetizers we got (calamari, mozzarella sticks) were just okay and I was really disappointed that the mozzarella sticks weren’t fully melted and didn’t taste fresh. It was great that both soup and salad came with our entrees, though the “house salad” is just lettuce with dressing… Our entrees were better, and the Italian sausage I got on the side was definitely the highlight of the meal! The portions of pasta were also very generous as I didn’t even finish my meal because I got full! Lastly, this is a BYOB so it was great getting to bring our own wine to go with our meals. Overall, I’m not sure if I’d come back but if I did, I would probably try something else – their menu is pretty extensive!
… moreSunshine All-Day
I love this place. I’ve experienced heaven eating here. The food is so delicious and authentic Italian cuisine. The service is top notch. The atmosphere is perfect for pasta.
I highly recommend this restaurant.
… moreAugusta Peachey
Food was absolutely amazing. Did not disappoint. Will be going back!!!
… moreMichael Padilla
Everything was amazing. Didn’t take a photo of the salad, but barley veg soup was good and the gnocchi in blush sauce was perfect . The waitress was amazing, pleasant, and friendly. The guy behind the register was also pleasant and friendly.
… morewolf anthony
Cotardo’s is myself and my wifes go to place a few times a month.
We love this restaurant and have been coming here for years.
The food, waitstaff, atmosphere top shelf.
Cotardo’s is one of those places that feels like home. For us its very relaxing and very reasonable price wise.
The only thing i can say is if you never ate at this establishment you have to.
Its a byob so bring whatever your pleasure is.
In my opinion when a restaurant is this good you can’t really say much except its awesome and go there!
… more