Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 615 E Moss Mill Rd, Smithville, NJ 08205
Phone: (609) 652-0378
Website: http://costellospizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Costellos Pizzeria and Wings | Galloway | Hammonton | Smithville
Welcome to Costellos Pizza with three convienant locations in South Jersey.”
Costello’s Pizzeria | Smithville NJ – Facebook
Costello’s Pizzeria is located at 45 S New York Road in the Smithville section of Galloway Town… See more. Italian Restaurant · $$.
Costello’s Italian Ristorante & Pizzeria – Historic Smithville
Make Costello’s your family choice for Eat in or Take out. Dare to try their “Stockton Bomb”, “Legendary Atomic Wings” or their “Famous Fuggeddaboutdit Pizza”!”
Reviews
Joan Marie
Worst pizza EVER! I got a plain pizza and a buffalo chicken pizza. The buff chic was great I was told by my son. My husband and I tried to eat the plain pizza and couldn’t! The bottom was burnt and the top had no sauce! The cheese was dried to the crust and totally inedible! Should have bought a frozen pizza, IT WOULD HAVE BEEN BETTER! I WON’T be back! I usually go to Smithville but it’s closed so this was from the Galloway Nest. You lost a customer tonight! Wasted my money and had no dinner!!!!
… moreAriel Liu
We had lunch specials.
10’ pizza and crispy chicken club.
There are fabulous!
The thin pizza is full of flavor.
The chicken club is tender and juicy.
Especially, I love their fries.
It is extra crispy!
Each lunch is a big portion of $9.99.
… more10’ pizza and crispy chicken club.
There are fabulous!
The thin pizza is full of flavor.
The chicken club is tender and juicy.
Especially, I love their fries.
It is extra crispy!
Each lunch is a big portion of $9.99.
Len Kunzig
We had Pizza. Chef Salad. Chicken Franciase and Wings and everything was very good. The pizza was a thin crispy crust and was delicious. The Wings and Salad were very good and the Chicken Franciase was perfectly prepared and cooked. If you are in the area it is a good place to eat.
… moregabby johnson
Come here for the WORST pizza you’ll EVER have. We order the buffalo pizza and the buffalo chicken Mac and cheese, both were disgustingly sweet, we could not eat either so both ended up in the trash. An absolute waste, DO NOT COME HERE. The pictures look great but the food is inedible. You’ll spend $27 for a picture and nothing more. We threw everything away and went somewhere else to eat.
… moreJess Foss
They constantly mail me flyers for their pizzeria but they don’t even deliver to us since we’re “right on the border of their delivery area”
Stop sending me monthly advertisements then, thank you.
… moreStop sending me monthly advertisements then, thank you.
Kathy Voight
We order delivery the chicken tails are awesome. The pizza very good we’ve had all meat pizza and the cheese steak pizza. Caesar salad is yummy. Staff very friendly and they do a good job.
… moreSamantha Livingston
Best pizza in Galloway. I literally just placed my order about 15 minutes ago, it’s already at my house hot , fresh and good ! One time they forgot my bag of chips with my sub, I let them know and they brought me a bag of chips with no problem.
… moreGeoffrey Lazarus
The pizza is great here: plain, pepperoni, white etc, whatever you get, slice or whole pie is very good. But the steak subs are where it’s at. Probably the best place in Galloway if not the county.
However, the fries aren’t so hot. I think they wrap them up right out of the fryer for pickups. They’re never crisp like fries should be. You guys step up your fry game and it’s 5 stars for sure.
… moreHowever, the fries aren’t so hot. I think they wrap them up right out of the fryer for pickups. They’re never crisp like fries should be. You guys step up your fry game and it’s 5 stars for sure.
southjersey fiberglass
The food here is absolutely delicious. The specials during the week are always amazing and well priced
… moreArelis Diaz
Buffalo tails are great , but it’s a shame just 1single cup of blue cheese, per dozen, at least a second one at no extra charge . Won’t be ordering again
… more