Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out
… View more
Takeout ONLY– NO DINE-IN and NO DELIVERY: Cosentino Pizzeria, located in the heart of Rootstown Ohio, offers stone oven baked pizzas, subs, fresh salads and other authentic Italian cuisine which is made fresh from scratch daily. Our famous family Italian sauce recipe delivers a unique and extraordinary flavor sure to please. Check out our popular catering menu for your next event. Takeout ONLY– NO DELIVERY
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4139 Tallmadge Rd, Rootstown, OH 44272
Phone: (330) 850-5055
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cosentino Restaurants: Pizzeria & Catering in Rootstown OH
Cosentino Pizzeria, located in the heart of Rootstown Ohio, offers stone oven baked pizzas, subs, fresh salads and other authentic Italian cuisine.
Cosentino Pizzeria, 4139 Tallmadge Rd, Rootstown, OH 44272, US
Cosentino Pizzeria, part of the MillCos Hospitality Group, is a beloved Italian take-out spot in Rootstown, Ohio, known for its stone oven-baked pizzas, subs, …
Review of Cosentino Pizzaria in Rootstown, Ohio – Facebook
Cosentino Pizzeria. Tallmadge Rd. Rootstown . Small deluxe with added banana peppers . Good pizza at a very good price . Open 4-9 .
Product
Last Updates
Reviews
Kathryn Ice
Absolutely love this restaurant. Food is amazing every time. The owner is very nice and friendly. My go to for excellent spaghetti & meatballs, salads are fresh every time. Garlic parm fries are an awesome add on. Very generous portions.
… morek b
Ordered a medium eggplant/fresh mozzarella with white sauce, Italian wings & cannoli…some of the best cannoli I have ever had, just the right amount of sweetness! The wings were amazing and pizza as well with the perfect crispy crust, even my picky eater devoured it!! Staff was super friendly and an all around good atmosphere. Definitely a new favorite spot!
… moreAmy Senters
Pizza is amazing from the crust to the sauce and toppings! Look forward to ordering again. Staff is kind.
… moreTodd Kortright eXp Realty Guy
I love Cosentino’s! Stromboli is on point. Italian Wings YUM! Subs amazing. The one that keeps me up at night thinking about though is the Bolognese pizza!! Pepperoni and Meatballs!!! OMG. Homemade goodness you can taste it. Thank you Cosentiono’s.
… moreValerie Sommers
Amazing food & customer service every time! Highly recommend, we’ve tried almost everything & never disappointed!
… moreCarrie Sims
I wish it was possible to give a rating beyond 5 stars for my catering experience with Cosentino’s this past weekend! The food was delicious, presentation and packaging we perfect, communication during the ordering process so very helpful, and the price is very fair considering the high quality! We will definitely be ordering from them again…. Especially the Stromboli . Thank you Cosentino’s!
… moretheresa babbo
Best Italian take out, hands down. Everything in prepared by 5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ chef David. Nothing is frozen or processed. Everything is prepared fresh daily, from the sub buns, to the pizza crust. Everything is freshly cut and prepared as you would do it in your own homes. You walk into Cosentino’s Pizzeria as a customer, and walk out feeling like family. Would recommend this place for all your catering needs. From the first bite to the last bite, you can taste the care that went into preparing your food. So much great italian food, for an unbelievable price!
… moreMic-Nog
Great Real Italian foods!! Even Italian desserts!! Oh my very authentic Italian restaurants !! A must !!
… moreEric Naylor
Awesome quality food. If you love top quality food for a great affordable price this is your place. Every dish is handmade from scratch, the Chef has years of experience and takes his food quality serious.
Don’t listen to the nonsense reviews, these people give, give, give to the community and only care about making customers happy with their food. If you have a issue call them and I guarantee you they will do whatever they can to make it right.
If I were able to eat this food daily I would honestly probably buy a dinner every night! Dinner, pizza, whatever is on the menu is delicious.
Do yourself a favor and go grab a pizza, but if you’re expecting a chain restaurant style pizza then this isn’t your place.
… moreDon’t listen to the nonsense reviews, these people give, give, give to the community and only care about making customers happy with their food. If you have a issue call them and I guarantee you they will do whatever they can to make it right.
If I were able to eat this food daily I would honestly probably buy a dinner every night! Dinner, pizza, whatever is on the menu is delicious.
Do yourself a favor and go grab a pizza, but if you’re expecting a chain restaurant style pizza then this isn’t your place.
Abigail Schlarb
Just tried this pizza for the first time tonight. I got the caprese on cauliflower crust and legit this was the most delicious pizza I’ve ever had! They clearly use fresh ingredients and make their recipes from scratch and not from a can or bulk jug. Even the garlic butter tasted home made. DELICIOUS! thank you and we’ll be back. I’ll be thrilled if you add more gluten free options to your menu.
… more