Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in
… View more
Snug, no-frills American diner with a straightforward menu of sandwiches, hot dogs & milkshakes.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 250 Dr M.L.K. Jr St N, St. Petersburg, FL 33705
Phone: (727) 822-4493
Website: https://www.facebook.com/Coney-Island-Hot-Dogs-143757712362928/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Will St. Petersburg’s Coney Island Sandwich Shop reopen?
Petersburg icon Coney Island Sandwich Shop has not closed permanently — at least not yet. The owner of St. Pete’s oldest family-operated …
Vintage St. Pete: Peter Barlas and Coney Island
N, opened next door in 1926. Photo by Bill DeYoung. St. Petersburg mayor Rick Kriseman, via official proclamation, declared Nov. 19, …
With Coney Island Sandwich Shop closing, is there a list somewhere …
Regardless, if it does close for good it will be another gem of St Pete that will be a great loss to many for sentimental and taste bud memories …
Reviews
Deneen Ritter
Absolutely love this place. It reminds me of home. The only thing missing from the menu is fries with gravy LOL. The chili is outstanding the hot dogs are great the staff is friendly. If you are in the mood for a chili dog, or real beef hamburger make sure you come on down.
… moreMaggi Smith Hall
Was told to visit. We did. The historic ambiance is worth the trip. The food average and the rudest group of employees I’ve ever experienced. There are historical items left intact in the place and it’s the history I love. It opened in the late 1930s and still retains that long ago feel. The food is average and frankly not half as good as Steak and Shake in quality.
… moreSonia Cook
Good place to grab a quick bite. Burgers are small like a McDonald’s burger and $3.95. No French fries here. Only chips. Chocolate shake is great! Chili dogs too! It hasn’t changed since 1926 when our first relatives started coming here and they first opened!
… moreSS “GooseHead” Saw
Being from Detroit, we see Coney Island totally different. Was not the Coney’s I’m accustomed to at home for sure. Dry, meaty, salty, dash of mustard and sprinkle of onions. However they were only $2.50. No fries.
Below are Coney’s I’m accustomed!!!
… moreBelow are Coney’s I’m accustomed!!!
Jaime Mottler
I’m absolutely loving this place. Quick and easy great food decent prices. Chili and grilled cheese I’m addicted too!
… moreTricia C
Quaint no frills felt like I was in a time capsule from my youth. Good food, limited menu.
… moreDebi Mitchell
This is old St Pete!! Dogs with chili are excellent! They keep chocolate Hershey bars in the freezer! Hamburgers are great too!
… moreVirgil Raines
The best dogs I’ve had in my life!!!!! Visiting from Houston and the James Coney island there are complete trash. I’ll be back again and again.
… moreCristina
I absolutely love this little local gem! The menu is simple yet delicious! Old fashioned chili dogs. The homemade chili is the perfect and I love that the hot dogs are cooked on a flat top grill. Fresh, fast, friendly service with yummy food! If you are near by you should definitely give this place a try!
… moreAli McKeever
There is a reason this place has been in business for 90 years. They stick with what they know and do it well. The hot dogs and burgers are great and the Cole slaw is amazing. This is a no frills sandwich place that you can count on. The servers are so nice and food is out quickly. Definitely recommend for a quick bite.
… more