Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
In the heart of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, Conestoga Restaurant enchants guests as a versatile, charming eatery. As an inviting American restaurant, our passion for serving tantalizing dishes and providing a casual yet sophisticated ambience shines through every offering. With an extensive beverage selection to accompany your culinary journey, prepare for a memorable dining experience.
Stylish restaurant & bar serving New American fare inside an 18th-century stone inn.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1501 E King St, Lancaster, PA 17602
Phone: (717) 869-4718
Website: https://www.conestogarestaurant.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Conestoga Restaurant
Nestled in the heart of Lancaster, PA, Conestoga Restaurant exudes warmth and welcomes guests with open arms. With its cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and a …
Best new restaurant in Lancaster, PA – Facebook
Conestoga Restaurant was voted Best New Restaurant in Lancaster, PA! I certainly agree. The food is excellent, prices are reasonable, …
Conestoga Restaurant, 1501 E King St, Lancaster, PA 17602, US
Enjoy casual dining at Conestoga Restaurant; A remodeled historic landmark in Lancaster county right next to the Conestoga River. We offer regionally infuse …
Reviews
Keith Edwards
Disappointing experience for a Tuesday afternoon meal. Crab dip, liked by many people was heavy cream with fishy smelling crab filler. Plenty of hot bread with it. Had the potato and scallop soups. Can’t tell one from the other. Slight spice and texture of heavy flour mixed in. Unremarkable. The pancetta is big enough for 2 people and tasty enough. Caesar salad wrap is fine but mushy with lots of dressing. Bill was $68 for us. Clean bathrooms with limited space. Limited parking.
… moreApril Zook
I can’t understand why this place isn’t packed! The outdoor scene is lovely by the water, the food and service are great, ample parking, nice, indoor dining, and pub with plenty of room, good music, and drinks! I’d like to highlight their incredible soft pretzel that totally blew me away, because I don’t even like soft pretzels, and this thing was amazing, made fresh in-house. Next highlight is their pizza, just wow. The prices are good too, why isn’t there a line to be seated?! Another hidden gem!
… moreHunter Bradley
Had our first meal here this weekend and it was delicious. So reasonably priced and so many things on the menu I want to try. Then I checked out their facebook page and saw additional specials which I am excited to try! We tried a pasta dish, the margarita flatbread, and the pretzel. Everything was perfectly cooked and sooo sooo good! I am already excited to go back and try something else!
… moreBrandon Harriford
So we visited Dutch Wonderland in Lancaster, PA earlier in the day on Sunday. The food inside the theme park was terrible, so we needed some great food to make up for that part of Dutch Wonderland
When we got there it was already dark out and was actually colder inside the restaurant than outside so we decided to sit outside which was fine because they have a beautiful outdoor seating area that overlooks the Conestoga River.
Our waitress was so nice and took her time explaining some items on the menu and how they could accommodate one of our daughter’s allergies. The food began coming out and the cheese sticks came first with the perfect crunchy outside and gooey cheesy inside that made for the perfect cheese pull. I haven’t begun filming myself yet so those small details being captures on film for the public to see will have to be saved for a later date. Our 4 year old said her personal pizza was excellent and she ended up eating it all so that speaks volumes. Our 9 year old got a burger patty, steamed broccoli, and orange slices and proclaimed, “This is the best burger I’ve ever had!” Success! My wife ordered a pizza and didn’t realize she had ordered a whole pie, but it was a mix of veggies and pepperoni and she loved it! Said it was very tasty. I got a personal flatbread pizza that was originally supposed to have pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon. I personally am not a big fan of ham or bacon on pizza so I asked for extra sausage and pepperoni and they absolutely delivered! One of the best pizzas I’ve had! Would definitely recommend to anyone visiting Lancaster, PA.
IG & TikTok: @bmh_reviewer
… moreWhen we got there it was already dark out and was actually colder inside the restaurant than outside so we decided to sit outside which was fine because they have a beautiful outdoor seating area that overlooks the Conestoga River.
Our waitress was so nice and took her time explaining some items on the menu and how they could accommodate one of our daughter’s allergies. The food began coming out and the cheese sticks came first with the perfect crunchy outside and gooey cheesy inside that made for the perfect cheese pull. I haven’t begun filming myself yet so those small details being captures on film for the public to see will have to be saved for a later date. Our 4 year old said her personal pizza was excellent and she ended up eating it all so that speaks volumes. Our 9 year old got a burger patty, steamed broccoli, and orange slices and proclaimed, “This is the best burger I’ve ever had!” Success! My wife ordered a pizza and didn’t realize she had ordered a whole pie, but it was a mix of veggies and pepperoni and she loved it! Said it was very tasty. I got a personal flatbread pizza that was originally supposed to have pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon. I personally am not a big fan of ham or bacon on pizza so I asked for extra sausage and pepperoni and they absolutely delivered! One of the best pizzas I’ve had! Would definitely recommend to anyone visiting Lancaster, PA.
IG & TikTok: @bmh_reviewer
Jungle queen Sheena
The food so good!! I love that it’s all made in house. Even the breads and pizza doughs, even the salad dressings!! When you wanna eat natural this is the place to go !!! Everything I ate was soooo good! The menu has some things I’ve never heard of. I’m so glad to see a unique menu. Not just the same old , same old. The southwest egg rolls were great! And the crusty French bread served with my crab dip was literally perfect!!! I come back time and time again because I can’t get over how good the food is here! Just went again yesterday and had the prime rib. Oh my Lord!!! The food is great. The atmosphere is amazing and the staff is incredible!!!
… moreChristopher Straub
Stopped by Conestoga Restaurant and had a really pleasant experience. I ordered the Chicken Caesar Wrap with a side of onion rings. The wrap was fresh and filling, and the onion rings were crispy and flavorful. What really stood out, though, was the service — everyone was friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome. Overall, a solid meal with great service. I’d definitely come back to try more items on the menu.
… moreJohanna Schaaf
Delicious lunch with many options on the menu from appetizers to main dishes. Happy hour available on weekends as well. Enjoyed the leisurely afternoon meal.
… moreA. Burkhead
For a historic building the ambiance is lacking. Cleanliness could be much better. Food definitely average and a bit higher than we ever expected. Waitress staff Sophie was a angel we tipped her very well despite the disadvantages of dining here. We won’t return presentation and quality matter , historic building should reflect the historic energy. Get rid of the table by the owners office as a elderly gentleman stood up to leave with his party and he fell hard over the partition thst borders the owners office stairs. Parking space tight.
… moreChetan Patel
Our company had the pleasure of dining here for a holiday dinner, and it was an absolutely wonderful experience from start to finish. The service was exceptional, thoughtful, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. The prep and details were handled with care, and it truly felt like the staff went out of their way to make sure our group was comfortable and taken care of. The food was amazing and well presented.
Thank you for helping make our holiday dinner so memorable. We left feeling appreciated, well cared for, and already looking forward to coming back.
… moreThank you for helping make our holiday dinner so memorable. We left feeling appreciated, well cared for, and already looking forward to coming back.
Martin Fastag
Pleasant surprise! Great tasing food. Reasonably priced. We shared multiple appetizers, a couple of Entrees, and 4 “over 21” drinks… Our server (Nathalie) has a great personality; friendly and attentive.
… more