Sarah Pope
Every Sunday 9pm-1am OPEN MIC/JAM. All musical styles welcome, solo acts and full bands encouraged to play!! $3 PBR’S and drink specials all night. There is a nice deck out back for smoking where you can bring your drink with you. They have events and live music every week. This Saturday is Comiskey Park Loves Boobies, an annual breast cancer fundraiser. There will be tons of live music, a Chinese Auction with awesome prizes and food!
… moreAnthony Alessi
Local favourite, often open late. Great service, happy people, good prices. Known this place since I was a kid and it’s not going anywhere. Great stuff all around as well and a nice night cap!
… moreJennie Golden
Owners are great and treat everyone with respect. Fair prices and good company. Its clean and crowd is mixed ages but all get along together. Every visit you meet new friends and share in the fun atmosphere. I’ve enjoyed visiting for 20+ years and look forward to return of normal abilities to have shows and more people able to come in. It’s literally next to train station so you have ability for safe travel if you drink. Take a chance and go on down…wont be disappointed
… moreRebecca Pilotte
Love this bar! Very low key with friendly bartenders. Owners are awesome and very personable. DJ Los is really good. I always have so much fun when I come here. They have different bands on some nights and host parties for all holidays running open bar specials. If you’re looking for a low key fun friendly bar Comiskeys is the place.
… moreThomas JC Grimaldi
The best pub in the Town of Smithtown! Swan, Jeff and the gang..
Any persons willing to hold yearly breast cancer benefits and seriously go all out like the carnival just set up shop; to me, that shows good people and good people I know personally for many many years are nice to me and cut me off when I didn’t know my limit? All around good vibes and fun and caring management. Mad respect and love y’all.
… morePatrick Gaggin
Unique experience to say the least. Great live music for open mic night, a free buffet on Sunday supported by the bartender, who’s an absolute doll, and games including darts and pinball. Excellent vibes!
… morePhilip Hennings
Quaint bar with a nice selection of drinks. Gives the latest sports showings and games. Has a juke box and a small amount of fun, classic games such as a pinball machine and a Broadway. It has a pool table as well and darts board. There is a smokers area in the back. Staff are friendly and the music played is very nice with many genres being chosen. They have events of many different occasions on the weekends as well as weekdays.
… moreBen Macaluso
A great little local bar up in St James, small and quiet but also has a jukebox that you can play whatever you want on. They also have a pinball machine which is awesome if you like old types of games. Local entertainment comes through here every once in awhile be sure to check with the bartenders. Have an outdoor back smoking area as well which is convenient.
… moreIrena Morris
If I could put zero stars I would. As a young woman, do not let your guard down. I got groped by a guy and nothing was done. I spent money just to be told I don’t matter through their lack of action. I ended up leaving out of discomfort because they wouldn’t address the man harassing me.
… morecairn
I performed with my band at this bar on tour. I didn’t book this show, but I was definitely expecting a bigger venue. Not Comiskey’s Park’s fault. When we entered, the place was filled with middle-aged people. Not our demographic at all. Unfortunately, not all of the members of other bands were friendly (also not Comiskey’s Park’s fault), but the promoter was quite friendly and tried to be accommodating for our long drive to this bar since we played to an extremely minimal amount of potential new fans. Although I wouldn’t come back, that is not Comiskey’s Park’s fault, and all of the middle-aged people there, while setting up and tearing down gear, seemed to be having a great time.
… more