Social Profile: 
… View more
Down-to-earth ice cream shop featuring familiar flavors & toppings, plus sherbet.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1075 St Georges Ave, Colonia, NJ 07067
Phone: (732) 634-5885
Website: https://coloniadairymaid.shop/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Colonia Dairy Maid (@coloniadairymaid) – Instagram
Over 40 flavors of homemade ice cream, custom ice cream cakes, and novelties! Voted best ice cream in New Jersey! 732-634-5885 …
Colonia Dairy Maid – Facebook
. 90% recommend (213 Reviews). . $. . Closed now. . 1075 St Georges Ave, Colonia, NJ, United States, 07067. Contact info. . coloniadairymaid. . (732) 634- …
Colonia Dairy Maid: A Flavorful Ice Cream Experience in Colonia, NJ
Located at 1075 St Georges Ave in Colonia, NJ, Colonia Dairy Maid is a charming ice cream shop that has been delighting customers with their extensive range of …
Reviews
Mitali Singh
They consistently have some of the best ice cream/sorbet in the area. The portions are very generous, but keep in mind that they’re a cash-only establishment. In the summer, there’s usually a line out the door, but during off season, you can go in and out quickly. They have an ATM inside and benches outside for seating.
My go to flavor is coffee chip (not overly sweet with thick dark chocolate shards; sooo good).
Some honorable flavor mentions: chocolate covered strawberry (this is a seasonal flavor I had around February which I beg them to make a permanent flavor because it’s PERFECT); cookies and cream, SpongeBob, devil’s food cake, and lemon Italian ice.
… moreMy go to flavor is coffee chip (not overly sweet with thick dark chocolate shards; sooo good).
Some honorable flavor mentions: chocolate covered strawberry (this is a seasonal flavor I had around February which I beg them to make a permanent flavor because it’s PERFECT); cookies and cream, SpongeBob, devil’s food cake, and lemon Italian ice.
Marie McGovern-Hayes
Awesome! HUGE portions. VERY reasonable prices! Unique and delicious ice cream and old school (i.e. pizzeria window) Italian ices. Staff was awesome, helpful, and friendly! Only complaint, getting in and out is a little tricky, but worth it!
… moreSteve Clark
Very retro look exterior. The young woman helping us was very nice. She got our order correct and was done quickly. Reasonably priced. I got a medium hit fudge sundae and it was huge. A great deal with plenty of hot fudge and whipped cream. I went here when I lived in the area. I now live an hour away. We were close by and decided to visit and glad we did!
… moreFarouq
Very nice and cute little ice cream place. Has many flavors and different varieties of cones,ice cream, etc. Has a nice little seating area outside. Workers are also nice and kind.
… moreThoughtful Reviews
Very busy ice cream shop that is open year-round. There are so many choices of hard and soft ice cream, toppings, Italian ices as well as cones and bowls. The shop is clean and the lighting is very bright. There are many cup or cone size choices. While the ice cream choices were eye appealing, the flavor was very underwhelming, milky not creamy and almost tasted sour. Counter staff is friendly and efficient. They also provide wet wipe packets on the counter, to help with sticky fingers. Seemingly overpriced, with strange pricing amounts for some sizes. Payment is CASH ONLY. Parking lot is provided along with picnic tables under shady trees in the back area during warm weather.
… moreTiffany Cheng
Slushies are great, ice cream is okay, lines are long. The staff move quickly, but customers linger. Cash only. Not sure I’d return; it’s a try it once kind of place because it’s too much trouble.
… moreM B J
I absolutely love Colonia Dairy Maid!! So many great flavors. It’s definitely worth the 25min ride!!!
… moretkeyah palmer
Worker Kailey is very rude and lacks patience. Got angry because a 6 yr old took too long to choose what flavor she wanted. When she went to place the ice cream in my hand, she missed my hand completely with a attitude and tossed the ice cream cone across the counter causing it to fall on the ground and walked away. When I addressed it she said “oh” and chuckled then went to make me another one. Not only was she rude but the ice cream cone landed on my $170 Birkenstock shoe and left a stain. When I asked to speak to a manager, she also pretended like she was a manager which turned out to be a lie. I am a regular at this establishment but unfortunately I will not be returning!
… moreKassandra Mancino
Stopped by yesterday with my boyfriend for some quick ice cream! It was pretty good just wished for some more sprinkles. Also cash only which is a little annoying, but they have an atm conveniently.
… moreMona & Suvra
This place looks old school, fun & nostalgic!!
it brings with it lots of childhood memories, no matter where you are from , I guess we all grew up loving ice cream as children and I bet we all have at least one local street corner ice cream shop which we remember from our childhood days that makes us smile when we think of the uncomplicated beautiful times spent. Well Colonia Dairy Maid reminds me of just that, modest , pocket-friendly , huge in portion yet yum!! They serve very creamy ice creams in loaded varieties of flavors , from the popular ones to seasonal fruits, also quirky ones as pina- coladas. You get it in cups cones sundaes & floats!! This was my first time with my frds who are regulars, so they ordered their favorites, the orange pineapple was outa world, it was indeed refreshing, & pinacolada wasnt as great though as per my taste bud, the pineapple was very fruity & fresh, Black rasberry was loaded in flavor too. I ordered a butter crunch, it was buttery creamy & crunch from the caramel made it stand out even more, the sea-salty touch from the caramel perfectly balanced the sweetness of the butter..& omg their portion is HUGE, a small cup has four scoops & their smallest size is “Dixie” which is quite big I feel
But how much Ice cream is more ? Lol
A great hangout spot & is opened till 10.30 pm on a summer night, people usually come for a night binge & this place could be very busy, but servers are quick & polite!! There are benches on the backside where you can hangout & enjoy your creamy scoops while chitchatting !! Overall an amazing place & I definitely recommend!! ALSO DO REMEMBER ITS A CASH ONLY place*****
… moreit brings with it lots of childhood memories, no matter where you are from , I guess we all grew up loving ice cream as children and I bet we all have at least one local street corner ice cream shop which we remember from our childhood days that makes us smile when we think of the uncomplicated beautiful times spent. Well Colonia Dairy Maid reminds me of just that, modest , pocket-friendly , huge in portion yet yum!! They serve very creamy ice creams in loaded varieties of flavors , from the popular ones to seasonal fruits, also quirky ones as pina- coladas. You get it in cups cones sundaes & floats!! This was my first time with my frds who are regulars, so they ordered their favorites, the orange pineapple was outa world, it was indeed refreshing, & pinacolada wasnt as great though as per my taste bud, the pineapple was very fruity & fresh, Black rasberry was loaded in flavor too. I ordered a butter crunch, it was buttery creamy & crunch from the caramel made it stand out even more, the sea-salty touch from the caramel perfectly balanced the sweetness of the butter..& omg their portion is HUGE, a small cup has four scoops & their smallest size is “Dixie” which is quite big I feel
But how much Ice cream is more ? Lol
A great hangout spot & is opened till 10.30 pm on a summer night, people usually come for a night binge & this place could be very busy, but servers are quick & polite!! There are benches on the backside where you can hangout & enjoy your creamy scoops while chitchatting !! Overall an amazing place & I definitely recommend!! ALSO DO REMEMBER ITS A CASH ONLY place*****