Ainsley
Pizza is great and so are the calzones. Salads are also yummy. I’ve gotten Columbus dozens of times and it’s always been good. The only reason I’m giving 4 stars is unfortunately I recently ordered a veggie pizza and found some stray chicken on it. I’m vegetarian. Who knows how much chicken I’ve eaten now :/. I do think that this could have been prevented and would like to be sure this does not happen in the future.
… moreCaroline
Super long time customer of Colombos! They have some of the best calzones and pizzas around. Unfortunately our pizzas are burnt and black on the bottom more often than not which is disappointing.
… moreGigi
Ordered chicken wings and shrimp scampi pizza and it was the worst I’ve ever had. The bottom of the pizza was burnt, the topping was super heavy on the garlic, not cheesy, and it was dry. The chicken was dry, overcooked, and flavorless. Will never order from there again.
… moreJon Doe
Steak Bomb calzone was thin crusted not full of dough nor grease Pepper’s onions & mushrooms were cooked to perfection not soggy or over burnt they were fresh and hardy but cooked. The steak was very minced nothing to worry about having to chew on or choke on maybe too minced but I enjoyed it. The flavor throughout the calzone was very well balanced not over seasoned salty nor once again greasy like you would expect. Tasted like a very healthy steak bomb. Food was ready as stated no waiting.
… moreMadeline Coats
The pizza and baked ravioli were both delicious! Fast service, too. We’ll definitely be going back!
Update: went back and got salad and it was delicious!! Highly satisfied 🙂
… moreJessi P
Closest thing I can find to NY style pizza in the area! The crust is perfect and it tastes authentic. I will continue to drive the 15minutes just to get this pizza
… moreM J
Were out and needed something to eat. Saw this on google maps and decided to try it. The service was fast and friendly. I couldn’t believe how quickly our pizza was done. We got a vegetarian pizza without mushrooms and it was cooked perfectly and tasted just as good. The bathroom and dining areas were clean as well. There is no menu board, you have to pick up a hand held one on the left side of the counter which is no issue but nice to know if they are ever busy when you go. I only wish I lived closer so I could go there more often.
… morePhoenixAfterglow
We’re sure everything is great here! Tried the “Caprese” salad. It was good but didn’t have any basil. Must be the Americanized version since it had mixed greens. Greek pizza was pretty good but might try a red sauce next time instead of white. Brownies are soft. Portions generous. Children’s high chair available. Good hospitality. Take out. Catering. See the big / diverse menu! And yes — tables and chairs for a casual dine in. The wonderful aroma of the food can be smelled outside!
… morePeter Carbone
Wings are delicious always well cooked, very good taste.
… moreLuis Fernando Azevedo
Whenever you need a salad or pizza, this place is my favorite. Their service and care is impeccable.
… more