Niko Meurett
There are a few great coffee shops in the Green Bay Area and Coffee Wizards is constantly going to mentioned as one of the best. The location can be a little tricky to get to when there is a lot of construction like there is right now (sept 2025) but it is worth it. They have a lot of partners in town that sell their coffee as well. If you love magic the gathering or DnD the. You will enjoy the vibe of this place
… moreAmaya
Coffee Wizards is da bomb and a reliable spot to get a strong, tasty, and unique cup of coffee. Cute space. Family friendly too. Ultimately what keeps me coming back is their commitment to standing in solidarity with their neighbors and community. much love <3 in a time when paying attention to where we spend our dollars is so important, I am more than happy to spend my money here.
… moreBLueeyzCaL
Halfway to the Shire with an espresso machine! Upon parking, one is met with an overture of mystical, almost cryptic, art etched upon the building, as though the shop itself were warded by ancient runes. Crossing the threshold, I was greeted by a rare harmony: service both extraordinary and humbly kind, delivered with the warmth of an old innkeeper and the precision of a practiced wizard. The beverages, rich, aromatic, and undeniably otherworldly, seemed brewed from secrets whispered between realms. Throughout the space, living flora flourishes in quiet balance, tastefully scattered like enchanted relics, lending the air a sense of calm wonder. A modest yet thoughtfully curated trove of themed wares awaits the traveler, each piece contributing to an experience that feels less like a coffee stop and more like a brief, magical sojourn beyond the mundane.
… moreChris Wilharm
I loved both things I ordered. I had the PSL coffee; this was truly the first cup of coffee I’ve ever been able to finish. It was incredibly smooth. I also ordered the Shire Sammie. It was absolutely delicious. The staff was incredibly kind, and the atmosphere was cozy and inviting. I will definitely go back.
… moreJosh Beier
For those seeking a unique coffee experience, this cafe is a hidden treasure. Its understated design is complemented by a carefully curated coffee selection, and I highly recommend a double shot of espresso and a pour-over. While it may be off the beaten path, it’s a must-visit for coffee aficionados and worth the trip from Milwaukee.
… moreAbi LaJoice
Very cool place! It has a unique vibe inside and all the workers were very nice!! The lattes we got were spectacular! They have their very own homemade pumpkin spice syrup for their seasonal drinks which was amazing! Definitely recommend coming here!
… moreAmanda Hunter
The atmosphere is very unique with beautiful wood work designs on the bar. The coffee is excellent. The staff was very friendly
… moreSpencer Guo
Really awesome new coffee roaster and shop – they have not only a nice selection of modern-style (i.e. light) roasted beans but also really good drinks. The espresso drinks and the pour over were both impeccable, on par with the best places in, say, San Francisco. Great ambiance too and love the interior decoration. Service was great and they answered all my questions about the coffee and the brewing methods.
… moreWhite Arrow
My favorite place! The staff are always polite and friendly. The atmosphere is very quiet and cozy. The coffee is incredibly delicious and made with love. I recommend everyone to visit this spot.
… morealchemistjoshua
Oh wow, the Coffee Wizards is a great up and coming place. The interior is very welcoming and cozy. It has an old world, almost medieval feel to it; It fits the “wizard” theme very well. The coffee, roasted in house, is very fresh, not bitter, and the smoothest I’ve ever had. The food is simple, but still very good, and well prepared. Have a croissant, they are super flaky and taste buttery and delicious. If you haven’t been to coffee wizards yet, this is your sign to try it out.
… more