Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 358 Princeton Hightstown Rd, West Windsor Township, NJ 08550
Phone: (609) 750-1234
Website: https://www.classicotomatopies.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: classicotomatopies.net
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Classico Tomato Pies | View Menu and Order Food Online
Classico Tomato Pies Located in West Windsor, New Jersey. Known for our authentic Italian dishes and tomato pies. Serving lunch and dinner as well as …
Classico Tomato Pies – West Windsor Township, NJ 08550 (Menu …
Online ordering menu for Classico Tomato Pies.
Classico Tomato Pies – West Windsor, NJ – 358 Princeton …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Classico Tomato Pies in West Windsor, NJ. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Reviews
John Miller
First time here and I think this was one of, if not, the best pizza I ever had. Thin crust, great sauce, and perfect amount of cheese. My wife gave it a 9.5 out of 10 and the kids loved it too!
If we are ever in the area again, we will definitely be stopping by. Thank you for a great pizza!
… moreIf we are ever in the area again, we will definitely be stopping by. Thank you for a great pizza!
Neha Gautam
First time here, delicious pizza! Thin crust, crispy! Very clean, spacious interiors and bathroom! Friendly & fast service
… moreSammy Berger
As someone that loves De Lorenzo’s, and only 15 minutes away from it, Classico had a very high bar to clear for my recommendation. Happy to report that Classico cleared it!
The good: The pizza was thin crust, nice and dark – just how I like it. Good balance of cheese and sauce. Service was fast, though that might have been due to few customers when I was there.
The less good: A bit too oily. I also thought the flavor wasn’t strong enough, but couldn’t say why.
As a thin crust pizza enjoyer, it’s nice to know there’s somewhere nearby to get my fix without a 45 minute wait.
… moreThe good: The pizza was thin crust, nice and dark – just how I like it. Good balance of cheese and sauce. Service was fast, though that might have been due to few customers when I was there.
The less good: A bit too oily. I also thought the flavor wasn’t strong enough, but couldn’t say why.
As a thin crust pizza enjoyer, it’s nice to know there’s somewhere nearby to get my fix without a 45 minute wait.
Manik Gupta
The pizza here is fantastic — full of flavor, fresh ingredients, and that perfect balance that makes you want another slice every time. The pies are thin, crisp, and well-balanced; you get the tomato flavor without it being overpowering. Two people can easily finish one, and honestly, it’s the kind of pizza that disappears fast.
The restaurant itself is spacious, clean, and welcoming. You can tell it’s a local favorite, and now I see why. My wife tried the veggie pie and loved it just as much.
Pro tip: Enjoy it fresh in the restaurant — because the crust is so thin, it probably won’t travel as well. Definitely worth coming in person to experience it.
… moreThe restaurant itself is spacious, clean, and welcoming. You can tell it’s a local favorite, and now I see why. My wife tried the veggie pie and loved it just as much.
Pro tip: Enjoy it fresh in the restaurant — because the crust is so thin, it probably won’t travel as well. Definitely worth coming in person to experience it.
Anders Evju
Been going here for years. Something has happened. Stay away. Picked up. They told me 15 min, was there in 12. Pizza was not really hot when I picked it up. I had a pizza carrier but still had to warm it up. It was all real hard flatbread, very disappointing. I’m out.
… moreAnita Taistra
First time at Classico Tomato Pies. This place did not disappoint. Ordered The Works, minus the anchovies. Crust was thin, the slice itself is difficult to eat with your hands but I made it work. It was fresh and delicious! Place is BYO. The one knock was having to wait 15 minutes and then flag down someone to take our drinks order. Place was no busy at the time. But our server was so friendly and made up for the wait. I wish I got his name.
… moreMichael Tunick
Came here for the first time. Ordered curly fries and a pepperoni pizza. The fries were pretty tasty (ate some before taking the picture). The pizza wasn’t really to my taste. Very very thin crust and too much tomato. These are personal preference issues though, not commentary on bad cooking. Preference aside, I didn’t care for it and I think the price was a few dollars too expensive. I don’t plan on coming back.
… moreTim Atwood
Great spot for Tomato Pie! My family and I shared 5 large pies… sausage, garlic, mushroom and onion, plain and one more that didn’t make it down to my end of the table. They were all delicious and had plenty of toppings.
… moreNicole Persichilli
I’d like to preface this by saying my family has been regulars at Classico since they opened. I mean pretty much weekly regulars, singing Classico’s praises and sending all their friends there. The food is great. The place is clean, big, and open.
The issue at hand is sadly with the incompetent/entitled wait staff:
A month or so ago while we were dining in, the waitress snuck (yes, I say snuck, as we were not informed nor did we meet the criteria) auto-gratuity on our check.
My 90 year old Grandma picked up the bill and double tipped by accident. She did not catch the 18% gratuity charge, as we didn’t think to look for it. Why would we? We were a party of 5. We tip 25-30% always as it is…
When auto gratuity is put on a check, I expect to be told. I find this to be INCREDIBLY disingenuous. The service was so horrible I’m actually sitting here laughing that she really stole $18 from my Grandma.
Waitress, who did not introduce yourself, I now speak to you directly:
Did you really think you were getting a $40 tip for two pizzas and two salads? No. You smiled and waved as we left knowing you stole from an elderly woman because you lack decency and transparency. Do better.
A shame.
… moreThe issue at hand is sadly with the incompetent/entitled wait staff:
A month or so ago while we were dining in, the waitress snuck (yes, I say snuck, as we were not informed nor did we meet the criteria) auto-gratuity on our check.
My 90 year old Grandma picked up the bill and double tipped by accident. She did not catch the 18% gratuity charge, as we didn’t think to look for it. Why would we? We were a party of 5. We tip 25-30% always as it is…
When auto gratuity is put on a check, I expect to be told. I find this to be INCREDIBLY disingenuous. The service was so horrible I’m actually sitting here laughing that she really stole $18 from my Grandma.
Waitress, who did not introduce yourself, I now speak to you directly:
Did you really think you were getting a $40 tip for two pizzas and two salads? No. You smiled and waved as we left knowing you stole from an elderly woman because you lack decency and transparency. Do better.
A shame.
Misty
The tomato pie was really good (especially if you like the super thin crust). My 8 year old had 8 slices! And my 5 year old and I agree they have the best fries.
… more