James Greenberg
This was my first time trying City Slice. Their slices are huge. Pricing is $5 for slice of cheese, $5.50 for slice of pepperoni and $6 for deluxe slices (supreme etc) The pizza was very good. I stopped in around 11:30 AM and ordered three pieces of supreme style pizza to go. The pizzas are very large sitting in the front case I believe they’re 30 inch diameter pizzas. The lady working at the counter was very nice. She took the three pieces of pizza to the back and put them in an oven to warm them. Two of the pieces were put inside of a pizza box and the other piece was put inside of a paper bag on top of a paper plate for my to go order. When she rang me up, the total came to $19.44. I didn’t realize until I got back to work that I was charged sales tax on Food ($1.44 more) that was taken to go. In Ohio /Cuyahoga county any food (non soda) that is taken to go is not subject to sales tax. I hope they fix this problem or I will just go back to my other pizza spots downtown that don’t charge tax on to go orders. If they had charged me correctly I would have rated 5 stars.
… moreRita
This was our first time here. It’s close in our neighborhood! It was definitely great to go in and talk to the owner and find out all that they plan to do in the neighborhood. The food (pizza, wings, & salad) was wonderful and we are excited. Great addition to the St. Clair Superior Neighborhood.
… moreSteven Stanis
This pizza is freakin incredible… flavor is unbelievable for the size it’s is and the price for it is solid to say the least, if your looking for New York style slice you have to give this place the chance it deserves, should be a staple in Cleveland in no time! + the owners are down to earth and want you to have a good experience… very personable, great spot can’t wait to come back!!
… moreArneda C
The Best Pizza I’ve had in Years. S,Johnson’s review took me to my new pizza shop. Worth every penny. Customer service is Excellent!
… moreBrandon Dohner
The pizza slices are huge, the sandwiches are great, & the staff is very friendly. But my favorite thing is their new menu item: the quesadilla. This place rules.
… moreJoseph Iarocci
I work close by in midtown, we had been meaning to try this place for lunch so we finally did and we were all blown away by how good it was. I had the chopped cheese sub, best one Ive ever had. Pizza looked amazing true. Will definitely be a regular here. So glad you guys opened this place!
… moreMargaret Bowers
Toooo Salty !
Ordered veggue pizza and pepperoni. Received ano veggie but 2 pizzas , 1 with pepp & Sausafe and one witj pepperoni. Called a n d response was sorry won’t hsppen again. The veggie members of the family got nothing. Never going back – touted on youtube. Not good at all.
… moreJack Bacevice
Awesome. Pizza incredible. Enormous slice. Bigger than Crust (which is also awesome). Chopped cheese amazing. Girl who made my chopped cheese super cool lady
… moreMariah Leight
A really good pizza. I was in the area and wanted some pizza. I trusted the reviews and they were right! I’ve had a lot of pizza from a lot of places, so I wouldn’t say it’s THE best, but it’s certainly up there and better than I was expecting.
A tad pricey but very worth it.
… moreSusanna Dzejachok
The immense pizzas on display were impressive looking. The staff person was perfunctory. Ordered a slice and they heated it up in the pizza oven without telling me they were doing that. They seemed to have some ethnic food for sale that wasn’t on the online menu. If I go back, I will order that. I did not find the gold lights on the outside inviting.
… more