4.0 – 887 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Social Profile: ![]()
![]()

Cicis Pizza, founded in 1985, offers the best pizza value anywhere with an unbeatable all-you-can-eat buffet experience in Lumberton, NC. Savor a diverse selection of freshly made pizzas, pastas, salads, and desserts, all crafted with dough baked fresh daily. With a lively game room to keep the kids entertained, Cicis Pizza is the ultimate destination for family-friendly dining that’s both delicious and affordable.
Italian chain offering an array of specialty pizzas, plus classic pastas & salads.
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
cicis.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Last Updates
Reviews
meredith Bohanon
Went today with my child for her field trip for school. Lady up front working the register around 1130 am highly rude with attuide. She asked us how old our daughter was and my husband didn’t hear her, she threw up her hand and started shaking her head with a nasty attuide, all because he didn’t hear her instead of asking again politely. I dont know if she was having a bad day or what but I won’t be back until it gets resolved. She was rude to every person up in there. One parent even told her so. Please get better help.
… moreNathan Godwin
Wish they had better pizza , maybe thicker crust instead of thin crust and hard after a few minutes the crust would hard to bit bc of how thin the crust was. I do like salad section and pasta or soup though. I went just get salad and soup and pasta so.
… moreAngela Shelters
I asked for a specific pizza, the girl had an attitude. I didn’t receive the sign with the number like I have at other places. I never received it and when I asked about it she told me to look on the buffet. Alot of the plates and silverware were dirty. I’ve been to other locations but this was my first at this one and probably the last.
… moreDavid Kilpatrick
Clean inside. It was slower during my visit, so buffet selection was light. Pizza was fresh and hot. Dining area was clean. Drink machine area could use some TLC.
… moreKerry “C-Lo” Belcher
Just need more ppl so can get more pizzas on the bar for buffet.
… moreRosa Hunt
Bar is never kept filled. Always have to wait now. It was never like that before. That being said past management knew their job.
… moreTamika S
Today, Sunday August 13 I came here. I asked the girl at the front about the price per slice. She said it was .50 so I asked for 10. She then goes to the back and said that they have to add $1 to it. I was confused because the other two times I came I got the same thing w no problem. Then the manager said that they changed stuff around as far as pricing goes. She even asked me who took my order so she could let them know they didn’t charge me right. I’m like huh. I haven’t been there in over a year. I liked the pizza the other times so I traveled a little bit to get there. So since I traveled so far I didn’t want to leave empty handed and got five slices since they were charging me a dollar per slice. Later on when I looked at my receipt I see that they charged me 5 dollars for the 10 slices I originally wanted for .50 per slice. But I thought yall didn’t do that anymore. So they basically lied and cheated me. Even though it was for a couple of dollars it still ain’t right! I work hard for my money just like everybody else. I will not be wasting my gas patronizing these folks again. I’m posting the receipt. I don’t like what happened and my ancestors don’t either!
… moreJohnice Williams
My husband asked the Indian lady nicely, if she could cook a fresh meat lovers pizza. She acted as if she didn’t hear him and then she went to the older lady talking about my husband while we were at the dinner table eating. He asked nicely so I don’t understand what the problem was.
… moreDelano Archevald
Tables were dirty wasn’t the cleanest place but I was only there for
… moreThe Freedom Advocate
Do not go here. Place is filthy! Wanted to order a specific pizza but nobody would acknowledge my existence to allow me to. The table was nasty, the floor was littered with refuse, half the restaurant was barred off to prevent patrons from sitting, nobody spoke to us when entering or exiting the restaurant and the quality of food was lacking.
… more … View more