Hanna Hill
Only taking it to 4 stars on the atmosphere just due to size of the building. This is a small location so plan accordingly when choosing to come. During the lunch buffet hours it can be hard to find seating. The food is excellent every time. We ordered the thick crust Skyline and breadsticks, both pure perfection!
… moreJess L
We were staying in a hotel near by and decided to try their pizza. We were not dissapointed at all. For under $40 I ate the salad bar and my family had an order of bread sticks and a large meat lovers pizza. We are water drinkers. The salad was fresh, pizza was yummy, and those bread sticks were awesome and given to us right away. The restaurant was clean and staff was friendly.
… moreStephen Plimpton
Good pizza. You order at the counter and they bring it to you. There is plenty of seating. Many times we order then pick up and take home. We really like the pizza. Staff is friendly. This is our goto pizza place.
… moreShawnna Clement (Pathfinder76)
Chicago’s has been our favorite on family trips to French Lick over the past decade. It’s always clean. The service is fast and friendly. The salad bar is fresh and worth a make- your- own salad. We love the crispy deep dish edges and the meatballs are delicious too. My kids love the spaghetti. Everything is still a big portion/ great value.
… moreMindy Milburn
We do not come to French Lick without stopping at Chicago Pizza. The food is fantastic, and the service is always fast and friendly. The deep dish pizza is my go-to, and it is so delicious that I have a hard time branching out to try anything new.
I prefer to dine-in, but this past weekend we picked up a pie on the way to the hotel, and it traveled perfectly. It didn’t have far to travel in all fairness, but it was still piping hot and delicious.
… moreVeronica Reed
Beautiful pizza place in the heart of West Baden and French Lick with outstanding customer service, affordable for all tastes and ages
… moreLinda Richardson
Decent pizza, I don’t know if I would really call it true “chicago” style though. It’s kinda just regular deep dish pizza. It’s good, but did not WOW me. The wait staff was very nice, but food came out very slow. All in all, not bad. I’d stop by again if I was ever in the area.
… moreHannah Moore
Gave 5 stars bc they dont show you the bad reviews. Hated to see this place turn into its sister location. Mitchell restaurant is the only good one left.
… moreAndrew Beck
Nice salad bar. Pizza buffet is a roulette. Not bad. Cinnamon roll pizza is delicious.
… moreC. Morgan
This review is based on a call in order of a Traditional Cheese pizza. The order took 15 minutes and was ready when I arrived on time, and pie still hot. The employee who waited on me was nice and friendly. As for the Pizza, it appears to be a cheese blend, and it is a good one. The sauce is tangy and in my opinion one of the best I’ve had. It works very well with the cheese blend mentioned above. The dough or crust had a nice subtle flavor and very nice chewyiness (is that even a word?!) It wasn’t dense. I do wish it had a bit of crunch or snap when you bite into it, this had absolutely none. Overall really good pizza, great service. Will be back.
… more