Timm Maynard
We were having a day out and have been through Lancaster many times, but have rarely stopped for anything other than drive thru food. Today we asked locals where was a good place to eat. Several said Cherry Street Pub. So we gave it a shot. First off the inside is amazing the atmosphere is inviting. The person who took care of us was Charity and she was absolutely the best. Great recommendations and great drinks. We had a few things to try – burgers are amazing, fish and chips are off the hook. The hush puppies are excellent and the Nashville Hot Chicken and Mac-n- Cheese was outrageous. Try it out you won’t be disappointed and this is a spot we will definitely come back to enjoy. Did I mention time… Food was out quick so avoid the fast food and have some good food fast.
… moreCris Feeny
I was expecting a good experience, but Cherry Street Pub surpassed both my husband and my expectations. Food was 10/10, server was wonderful and friendly, the atmosphere felt cozy and laid back. The wait was not bad, we probably waited like 10 min total. Chicken quesadilla was the best one I’ve ever had!!! Definitely would recommend to anyone visiting Lancaster!
… moreAdrean Jones
Absolutely amazing! If you are in the Lancaster area be sure to stop for lunch or dinner at this pub. I had fish n chips and added 2 hush puppies. My husband got the buffalo chicken sandwich with tater tots and we both got beers to drink. My piece of fish was huge and I had to bring half of it home. The tarter sauce is delicious definitely dill based it’s so flavorful and paired nicely with my flaky fish. The cole slaw is also very good. The best thing I did was add 2 hush puppies for $2.50, they came with cinnamon butter and they were hands down one of the best things. They melted in your mouth, you need them! All together we spent just over $52, our server was nice and knowledgeable. I highly recommend stopping in and sampling anything on the menu you won’t be disappointed.
… moreMegan Schwarzenberg
Literally my favorite place in L-town. The staff are friendly and fun. You can absolutely tell the manager Kristen is top notch and has created an amazing culture for her staff.
Food is amazing, obsessed with the Sweet Onion Bisque, Sweet Thai Chili wrap but as a bowl, and their current grilled cheese special has me in a relationship I didn’t know I needed.
10/10 recommend.
… moreCarolyn Maynard
Excellent food. The French onion burger is so good!! Also highly recommend the Nashville mac n cheese. Charity was our server and was so helpful with many questions! Recommend most highly.
… moreJosh and Chrystal
The food was delicious the service was great. We plan to come back several times.
… moreferguitar 22
Such a unique place….1st time here and I gotta tell it was excellent!! Will definitely be back !!! Highly recommended. This place never ever fails you.
… moreElke B
My husband got fish and chips they were excellent, I got the Reuben sandwich which was ok had to much fat on the meat had to pick off. The mushrooms were excellent and the smothered burrito was very good. We will definitely go back.
… moreKimberly and Sean Henry
Oh my gosh! We don’t always go to Cherry Street Pub but when we do my wife and I ALWAYS know that we will be treated great. The service they provide to us and those around us every time is amazing. The knowledge of the servers remarkable. If one doesn’t know the answer they bring another server to the table that will make sure your experience is great. The Chef/cooks have always made my Ruben Sandwich (Top knotch) the same way every time. The tater tots with the spicy seasoning is wonderful.
My wife loves the Pickle Martini and the beers on hand along with the tasty Old Fashions are amazing. Please try this experience, you will be glad you did. If I write a long review like this, you know it’s a must.
… moreKatie Klaus
Delicious! We were in town for the Otter Experience at Paws and Claws Encounters and Lyle recommended Cherry Street Pub for lunch. Fried bologna sandwich was to die for as was the Pulled Pork Mac N Cheese. You could tell the pulled pork was smoked here and had wonderful flavor.
Local beer was also fantastic. Service was quick, very friendly and attentive. Choco Taco was also very good. Highly recommend!! Definitely one of those small town food places that is always better than the chains.
… more