Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Recently named the best waterfront restaurant in the state of Delaware, Catch 54 is committed to serving beautiful simple coastal cuisine in a beautiful setting overlooking the bay. House specialties include our signature crab cake, buttermilk fried oysters, and our famous 54 burger, all accompanied by an extensive wine list and a great selection of craft ales and cocktails. Stop in and enjoy one of the top seafood restaurants in Fenwick Island, Delaware!
Waterfront eatery featuring Atlantic seafood & steaks along with cocktails amid minimalist decor.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 38931 Madison Ave, Selbyville, DE 19975
Phone: (302) 436-8600
Website: https://www.catch54.com/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=gbp
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Catch 54: Seafood in Fenwick Island, Delaware
Catch 54 is the best seafood restaurant in Fenwick Island Delaware. Located just over the bridge on Route 54, Catch 54 features fresh, local seafood.
Catch 54 | Selbyville DE – Facebook
During the second season, we accept reservations all night long and you can book same day! To make a reservation, please visit our website: www. catch54.com.
Catch 54 | Selbyville DE – Facebook
Catch 54, Selbyville. 3182 likes · 136 talking about this · 468 were here. Named the ‘Best Waterfront Restaurant in Delaware’, Catch 54 is committed to…
Reviews
Samantha Monteith
We came here for New Year’s Eve at the beach and were seated immediately at the bar without having reservations. On Wednesdays they do one dollar oysters on the half shell & they’re not to be missed! Very tasty. They also have great shrimp plates- Baltimore style and the pours of wine are generous. Great meal and great service even though it was a full house. Definitely recommend if you’re in the area.
… moremark marsico
10⭐️ meal, top to bottom. Masterfully exquisite without being a bit pretentious. We were a party of 14, adults and young adults, and every single dish was fantastic. Oysters, soups, wings, salads, scallop fried rice, fried shrimp, crab cakes, crab deviled eggs, clam pasta. EVERY dish was . Even non-happy hour oysters are a bargain!! Service was warm and inviting and beyond attentive. Arrived just before 5:00 and we were sat immediately on the bay on a perfect evening, although the restaurant filled quickly. Recommend an after dinner drink or dessert upstairs at the bar for more great views.
… moreJake Wechsler
One of my favorite restaurants. Beautiful views. Phenomenal atmosphere and even better food. There are dollar oysters on the half shell on Wednesdays which has become a regular event with my girlfriend and parents.
Staff is always so friendly and provides excellent service. Peyton has been our server for the last few months and we have developed a great relationship with her. She is phenomenal at her job and we can tell she really enjoys taking care of customers at catch 54.
Nothing but great things to say about catch 54.
… moreStaff is always so friendly and provides excellent service. Peyton has been our server for the last few months and we have developed a great relationship with her. She is phenomenal at her job and we can tell she really enjoys taking care of customers at catch 54.
Nothing but great things to say about catch 54.
Bruce Shaw
First stop on vacation! We started off for happy hour and in my opinion, this is the best happy hour in the area. It’s a “buck of shuck” that’s one dollar per oyster. You cannot find that price anywhere around here. I got a dozen oysters, a beer and a pineapple martini in which they are known for $24. That’s a great deal. Planning on going back later this week. We also stayed for dinner with a large party. They do not accept reservations between the hours of 6pm & 930pm. so plan on waiting for a table, especially with a large group. But the food is worth waiting for it is very good. I would recommend for appetizer the oysters Rockefeller and I had the special for my entrée which was swordfish, (sorry started eating then took pic) it was very good. Our waiter Caleb was very good and attentive, especially for a large group. Parking is a nightmare. They have a very small parking lot in front of the restaurant maybe holds 10 to 15 cars. There is other parking lots around but with two restaurants in the area, they are full all the time, especially in the peak hours. So plan accordingly. There is a motel next-door do not park in the parking lot. You will get a ticket or your car will be towed.
… moreYisella Vargas
This place is great! The oysters were so fresh. The scallops fried rice and the catfish were delicious and the key lime pie was exceptional! Our server Morgan was very kind and helpful. If you’re visiting Ocean city, this is a must go!
… moreJoseph Shriver
On January 6th for my 28th birthday we had to Catch 54 for my special birthday dinner at Catch 54
… moreKyle Kelly
Tonight, the Delaware blue crab soup was quite bland, and for $12, I expected lumps of fresh crab meat—instead, it came in clusters that looked like they were from a can. The soups also arrived late, and we had to remind the server. The shrimp and grits were fairly standard—nothing memorable. From the daily specials, we ordered the salmon with a side of green beans. I was glad I asked for the roasted chili vinaigrette on the side, as it turned out to be very greasy. Unfortunately, the green beans never arrived.
The manager did check in and asked about the food—we were honest with our feedback, and she kindly removed one of the two bland soups from the bill. However, after we mentioned this to our server, the service noticeably declined. We were pretty much forgotten after that and had to wait around for the corrected check and to have it swiped.
… moreThe manager did check in and asked about the food—we were honest with our feedback, and she kindly removed one of the two bland soups from the bill. However, after we mentioned this to our server, the service noticeably declined. We were pretty much forgotten after that and had to wait around for the corrected check and to have it swiped.
Butch Thayer
We went for a birthday dinner with a few friends. The food was good and reasonably priced. There were 8 people in our party and we all found plenty of choices. Three server (sorry I don’t remember her name) was very friendly, thoroughly knew the menu and made excellent recommendations. We also went on a day when there was a good discount on the meal. The ONLY down side was we seated too close to the front door on a very cold and windy day.
… moreTyler Poeti
Fantastic waterfront view of the bay! The parking lot was crowded but we were able to walk in around 5:30 and got seated at an outdoor table. The food was delicious and the drinks were wonderful! Carley T. was a fantastic server!! 🙂
… moreLinda
We have been a customer for many years. Tonight was a major disappointment. The menu changed and is very limited. There were 4 of us and not one of us were happy about their meal. They use to have some great dishes and lots of choices. What happened to the country fried chicken, the scallop fried rice bowl. They had a great fish and chips and buttermilk shrimp. Totally disappointed.
… more