Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1 Cherry St, Lambertville, NJ 08530
Phone: (609) 397-2992
Website: https://www.facebook.com/CatanzaretiPizza/photos/p.5413832538637708/5413832538637708/?type=3
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Catanzareti Pizza: Italian Cuisine | Lambertville Restaurant Guide
Check out Catanzareti Pizza & Italian restaurant in Lambertville NJ. Offering pizza and italian food in a family setting. Located at 1 Cherry St, …
Catanzareti Pizza & Italian Restaurant | Lambertville NJ – Facebook
. 86% recommend (5 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 1 Cherry st., Lambertville, NJ, United States, 08530-1838. Links. . instagram.com/catanzaretipizza …
Order Catanzareti’s Pizza – Lambertville, NJ Menu … – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Catanzareti’s Pizza at 1 Cherry Street in Lambertville. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
Dave Klotzbach
Hate to be a Debbie downer, but after reading reviews, we decided to try this place.
To start…the cheesesteak was absolutely phenomenal. Only thing that brings it down a tad is it belongs on a seeded roll.
That’s where the good part ended. The mozzarella sticks were absolutely bad. Frozen mozzarella sticks should be banned. Some were even hollow inside.
The pizza just wasn’t good. It was chewy, sauce too sweet. We even ordered half our pie with garlic…we tasted no garlic. Expected fresh garlic, but even if they put powder garlic…didn’t taste it.
… moreTo start…the cheesesteak was absolutely phenomenal. Only thing that brings it down a tad is it belongs on a seeded roll.
That’s where the good part ended. The mozzarella sticks were absolutely bad. Frozen mozzarella sticks should be banned. Some were even hollow inside.
The pizza just wasn’t good. It was chewy, sauce too sweet. We even ordered half our pie with garlic…we tasted no garlic. Expected fresh garlic, but even if they put powder garlic…didn’t taste it.
Shari Javines
Stopped here on my way to New Hope and was pleasantly surprised. Not only do the people greet you with kindness but the vibe of the place really makes you feel like you’re with family. You can tell they have years of experience and put their all in the food—would travel far just to eat the cheesesteak again. And special shoutout to Jake for a great experience! Highly recommend!!
… moreD M
Not great pizza, people are rude and the calzone was terrible. Not sure what the issue is that they can’t follow a simple order. Been there twice, first time pizza was ok, nothing to write home about but edible. We also ordered a plain, yes plain, stromboli but it came with pepperoni and sausage. Should have thrown in the towel then but everyone has a bad day, so we try again. Second time the pizza which should have had extra cheese which we paid was almost devoid of cheese entirely. As for the plain calzone we ordered this time, while it did not come with pepperoni or sausage it came with peppers. They are not that busy that they can’t take 5 mins to make sure the order is correct. Will not be a third time.
… moreChris Earhart (Endrp)
Best pizza in the area. We got 2 cheese slices and they were perfect. Crispy and very flavorful sauce. I saw on other reviews the last bite is as good as the first and that is true. Can’t wait to come back and get a full pie. The service was also great. Local family owned.
… moreMr BBQ
I really like the place brings a nice retro old school vibe I love it ❤. People are very nice and helpful thanks guys! Food was amazing!
… morePenny Morris
The most proper slice of pizza I’ve have in a long time. Environment and everything-10/10. Can’t wait to come back.
… morePenny Rawlings
•Update to add: if you haven’t tried their grandma pie which is a square garlicky perfection, please do. It is outstanding and incredibly delicious. You’re welcome 😉
Great place for a local pie. Their pizza is our go-to for our weekly pizza fix. They were closed a day recently and we were forced to try another Lambertville pizzeria. What a disappointment. This place will always have our business. Fresh and delicious.
… moreGreat place for a local pie. Their pizza is our go-to for our weekly pizza fix. They were closed a day recently and we were forced to try another Lambertville pizzeria. What a disappointment. This place will always have our business. Fresh and delicious.
ash
The best pizza in New Jersey. Have been coming here since I was a kid with my parents, now I’m turning 28 and coming here with my daughter frequently.
… moreAngryGoat 6.0
If, you like your pizza crust chewy you will like the pizza. The crust was a little too chewy for me. The crust had a nice taste and the sauce also. Good amount of cheese.
The sitting area is small and could be a little cleaner. Then again I went when it was very late.
… moreThe sitting area is small and could be a little cleaner. Then again I went when it was very late.
Kenny Robinson
Stopped here on a whim. Large pie to go, peppers and onion. Awesome tasting pizza pie with generous toppings that were fresh. Ordered the pie and waited in the car. Thunderstorm broke out. Pouring… Gentleman behind the counter saw me getting out of my car and came to the shop door to indicate that I should wait and he would deliver our pie to car. I declined his offer but, really, this level of service for an order less than $20.00? Where do you see that anymore?
We consider ourselves pizza snobs from New York City. This is only the second pizzeria to pass muster in 15 years of living in New Jersey and we will be regular customers going forward.
Thank you, Catanzareti Pizza. Kenny
… moreWe consider ourselves pizza snobs from New York City. This is only the second pizzeria to pass muster in 15 years of living in New Jersey and we will be regular customers going forward.
Thank you, Catanzareti Pizza. Kenny