4.3 – 221 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Social Profile: ![]()
Since 2009, Castello’s Pizza in Windermere has been a cherished local favorite, offering a vibrant taste of Italy with a modern twist. This family-friendly restaurant and wine bar specializes in fresh, hand-tossed pizzas and a range of Italian dishes. They cater to all tastes with dine-in, takeaway, and delivery services, alongside catering options for any event. Castello’s commitment to quality is evident in its daily-made dough and sauce, crafted with a focus on fresh ingredients and authentic flavors. It’s the perfect spot for a delicious meal, whether you’re dining with family or grabbing a quick bite.
Simple, modern shop offering typical pizzeria fare & specialty pies for takeout & delivery.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
castellospizza.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Last Updates
Reviews
donna hicks
Ordered a pizza and lasagne to be delivered. Absolutely dreadful. Cheap slices of deli ham in the lasagne. Never experienced that on a lasagne before!!! Gross. Melted cream cheese as a white sauce, terrible. Semolina on the base of the pizza and again cheap cubed deli ham. Worst Italian meal ever. Ended up throwing it away and making sandwiches for dinner instead.
… morejosie hernandez
Great service, I was received with a smile and good vibes. Delicious, warm, and fresh pizza. Definitely a 10/10.
… moreCarolina Zornoff
I recently visited castello’s pizza and it was fantastic from start to finish! The pizza was perfectly baked — crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and loaded with fresh toppings. You can really taste the quality of the ingredients, especially the sauce and cheese. The service was excellent — friendly staff who made great recommendations and ensured everything was just right.
… moreNancy Lara
10/10 must recommend the pizza so goodi would definitely be coming back and the workers are so kind and they’re so fine.
… morejazmin Rey
Ive visited this establishment frequently, the most recent seemed off, just did not taste as good as before. Something about the pizza was different? i think the mozz cheese doesn’t taste as good anymore? i’ll have to find a new go-to-spot….
… moreRenata Carvalho
I had a surprise birthday party and my friend brought pizzas from Castelllo’s — hands down some of the best pizza in town! Everything was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly baked. Everyone loved it. Highly recommend!
… moreBill Barnes
Always a delicious pizza! And Fabio makes each visit so special. We get take out and it’s always ready and fresh from the oven when we arrive. Small gem in Windermere!
… moreShakole Spence
The food was amazing, the server came out and served the food to us and gave us a excellent service. Thank you so much!! Please come and visit.
… moreEmran Timory
This place had the best pizza I have had in my life! It’s an italian restaurant that has been there for 17 years! The costumer service was also a 10/10 experience. Overall I really recommend this. 10/10
… more