Matthew Kreps
You wouldn’t expect gas station pizza to be good, but this is a pizza place, that happens to be inside a gas station. The dough is made fresh, that’s the secret to why it tastes good.
… moreBrian Bodimer
Not sure about anyone else but I showed up ordered a pizza and 10-15 minutes later had the exact kind of Casey’s pizza is get at any other location. Maybe a but in the slow side? Then again I was ordering pepperoni at like 730am, so maybe different crew?
… moreJosh Meumann
Ordered a brisket n taco pizza. Brisket looks good, the taco has nothing but sausage,wasted money and no time to go back. Sad day.
Ok so let’s try this location again, it can’t be that bad right?
Taco pizza, again missing chips, and all toppings. HOW. Veggie pizza. Let’s talk about it. Pineapples and pickles added to this? What is happening out here . We paid in advance, when arrived. We were given two pizzas. When asked about our third pizza. The attendant simply said, Oh, I thought that was a mistake on your end. Ummm we paid for three pizzas why would I not want it. Turns out we didn’t want any of them and wasted so much money again at this location. Unreal.
… moreCharlie Gutierrez
I ordered a medium thin crust pizza and 2 orders of cookies. Didn’t receive any cookies and wrong pizza was delivered. I called Casey’s to get the order rectified. The individual that answered the phone had absolutely no idea what to do. He couldn’t help me because the person that made my pizza had left already. Went through DoorDash and they refunded the cookies, but I’m SOL on the pizza. This is the 2nd my order has been wrong from start to finish.
… moreKsp 193
My past SEVEN visits there has been no pizza slices made. Mind you this is usually between 11 am – 1 PM. How is this possible?
… moreSunshine Miracle
I GO IN THEY NEVER SPEAK AS MANAGERS THEY TALK BOUTMe,,I SAD MNG NAME WRO NG AND IT has BEEN THREE NMONTHNTS SHE OR NEVA SWYS HI AND GET MAAD AT ME AS IF I HOLD UP LINE WHEN CASHIER DT KNOW HOW TO WORK LOTTERY!!!???????OH AND THEY SPEAK RO ITHER BUT NE,if I made a mistake SAY NANE INCORRECT AS A MANAGER THEY SHOULD B PROFESSIONAL TO SOEAK AFTER CORRECT ME
… moreGordon Sennett
Pumps aren’t 24/7. Station isn’t 24/7. Got there at 5:45 expecting to get fuel but dispensers were closed. Store opens at 0600 according to the clerk I talked to inside. But got told the pumps don’t normally open for 15-30 minutes after store does. I went across to Meijer.
… moreDena G
I can only imagine the amount of money this gas station is losing. Casey’s pizza in a bigger suburban area can be making a substantial amount more and beat local competition. Not to mention, taking orders for pizza will bring in customers and in turn marketing strategy to buy other items. Y’all are failing big time.
The place is disgusting and never any food except one time! At this point, I’d reschedule a new opening after a massive revamp.
With a review for Casey’s under 2.5 stars, the owners should be ashamed. It makes me think this gas station may be needing looked into.
It’s such a shame they are running this place so poorly. Myself and all of the other people who wrote reviews have more passion for Casey’s than you owners do. There are die hard Casey’s lovers out there and you’re ruining it.
… moreSadie Fox
Always clean everytime I go, so happy a Casey’s came to Bolingbrook. Their pizza is delicious and for a good price! Casey’s rewards is so wonderful! And their gas prices are just so good not to high compared to other places.
… moreCrystal Zaragoza
I am honestly floored by all the negative reviews. I have had nothing but exceptional, yes – exceptional, experiences at this Casey’s. I have ordered pizza from here a few times now, and despite interacting with different people each time, I have encountered some truly above and beyond fantastic customer service every time. Sweet little touches like adding a nice note to the top of our pizza box, or having a unique and positive interaction with the employees. The breakfast pizza is always super good. I grew up around Casey’s stores, and was thrilled to learn one was going in so close to us. I’m looking forward to trying their taco pizza – another Casey’s favorite of mine from younger years.
… more