Address and Contact Information
Address: 850 E Western Reserve Rd #6, Youngstown, OH 44514
Phone: (330) 758-0544
Website: http://carmellascafeyoungstown.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Carmella’s Café: Home
Wine · Daily Specials · Catering · Contact & Directions · Family Tradition at Carmella’s. 850 E Western Reserve Rd #8, Youngstown, OH 44514 (330) 758-0544.
Carmella’s Cafe – MapQuest
Ribeye. … Carmella’s Italian Eatery in Youngstown, OH is a family-owned restaurant that has been serving authentic Italian cuisine for years. Located on East …
Carmella’s Cafe | Boardman OH – Facebook
Carmella’s Cafe is a family run Italian Restaurant open for lunch and dinner Monday thru Saturday.
Reviews
Brian Saghy
Came here to have lunch with my parents.
I thought the food was just alright. Totally acceptable, nothing was bad, but nothing really wowed me.
The wines were pretty basic, some mass produced grocery store brands like 19 Crimes.
The free side of bread was like sliced Wonder bread.
Server was nice. Service a tad on the slow side but we weren’t in a hurry.
… moreI thought the food was just alright. Totally acceptable, nothing was bad, but nothing really wowed me.
The wines were pretty basic, some mass produced grocery store brands like 19 Crimes.
The free side of bread was like sliced Wonder bread.
Server was nice. Service a tad on the slow side but we weren’t in a hurry.
Aidan Robinette
Food is incredible as always, but the hostess needs some SERIOUS attitude adjustment. My mom had a full knee replacement and cannot use high top tables as a result. The hostess recommended a high top table and my mom replied, “No, I’m not that athletic unfortunately.” Trying to make light banter. The hostess then replied, “it’s not that hard.” Excuse me? That comment was completely unnecessary and inappropriate as a professional. I am hurt as I love Carmella’s, and have enjoyed their food since I was in diapers. I ask that you please have a conversation with the hostess scheduled on the evening of Saturday, November 29th, 2025. Thank you.
… moreDebbie Kim
Cozy Italian restaurant with real veal parmesan. No frozen patties here! Nice size portions, couldn’t eat it all. Zach was our wonderful server & made our visit great. We will definitely go back! The picture shows my plate after I ate about half.
… moreKathleen Mulligan
I had some time to spare and an appetite, so I stopped in and I’m glad I did!! The atmosphere is calming with an Italian theme and Italian music playing in the background. I got the Italian greens appetizer and added chicken to it and it was the perfect size!! (The mountain of parmesean is all me LOL.) I ordered the Pistachio Gelato and it topped the meal off perfectly!! The staff were friendly and overall it was a wonderful experience!! Definitely recommend with a 10/10!!!
… moreLori Hayda
We were so disappointed with our meals from here! We were expecting some good things! We ordered a 10 oz sirloin steak which significantly must have gone on a diet before we got it because the onion rings were more plentiful and bigger than the steak! We also ordered a dish called Victoria Chicken. It was listed as two grilled or fried chicken breasts covered with sauce, cheese and greens. We asked for no greens but what was left was confusing. There was sauce..but it was loaded with red peppers and tomatoes and onions. The coating was soggy and the cheese had all but disappeared. The fries that came with it were mediocre at best. We got a cup of wedding soup..uh..all it was was spinach stems and 2 shredded pieces of chicken and 2 count them 2 meatballs. Amazing…$40+ dollars for horrible food!
… moreRyan Williams
The whole experience was amazing, I felt like I was in Italy! I got a Chicken Parmigiano Sandwich and I’m not kidding you it was one of the best I’ve had in my life. The waitress was extremely friendly and kept checking on us to make sure we were doing okay! Overall, it was an amazing experience. I highly recommend people to visit!
… moregeorge maidaa
It’s a neat place, cozy.
The apps were great, Kagoot was delicious, hot pepper as well, Calamari was good.
Haddock was very tasty. I wouldn’t recommend the Steak though, I ordered 10 oz Sirloin, I think the quality is not that great.
Otherwise, it was a nice experience
… moreThe apps were great, Kagoot was delicious, hot pepper as well, Calamari was good.
Haddock was very tasty. I wouldn’t recommend the Steak though, I ordered 10 oz Sirloin, I think the quality is not that great.
Otherwise, it was a nice experience
Tom Akers Jr
What a great little restaurant. I was pleasantly surprised at the quality of the service and how wonderful the food tasted.
… morePatricia Winkler
Both seafood and beef dishes were delicious. The server was friendly, efficient and accurate.
… moreNisha Franks
Charming Italian restaurant. Salmon is good but the eggplant Parmesan is excellent. My husband got the grouper and crab cake tonight, he was so happy with it. We really loved our server. He was extremely sweet and was very good with our two little girls. He made so many accommodations and was very hands on. Carmela’s is definitely a gem because of the food but their staff is what makes this place next level.
… more