Captain Bill’s | Seafood Restaurant

  3.9 – 308 reviews  $$$ • Seafood restaurant

Wood-paneled place with a classic American menu of seafood & steaks, plus a patio with lake views.

Captain Bill's | Seafood Restaurant 53562

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Captain Bill’s in Middleton to close permanently due to COVID …

MIDDLETON, Wis. — The owners of Captain Bill’s in Middleton announced Monday that the restaurant will be closing permanently due to …

Captain Bill’s Seafood | 2701 Century Harbor Road Middleton …

Captain Bills Waterfront Restaurant features Amazing Seafood, Grilled Favorites & Creamy Pasta’s in a rustic, … Off Hwy M & Allen Blvd in Middleton, WI …

Captain Bill’s – Middleton Restaurant – OpenTable

Get menu, photos and location information for Captain Bill’s – Middleton in Middleton, WI. Or book now at one of our other 5753 great restaurants in …


Patrick Jones
All the Von Rutenberg restaurants have good food.
… more
Jere Foley
Took my family out for my father’s birthday. The only negative was just a part of eating outside – bugs in the water and loud conversations at other tables. Our server Jen was amazing and attentive. The meals were delicious and flavorful. A great time was had by all!
… more
Hank Bodette
Just finished a fantastic meal. Service was great. I had surf and turf. The stake was perfect. Medium rare to perfection. The shrimp was great too. The outside seating had great sun and rain umbrellas. Yes it’s Wisconsin. We needed both sunshade and rain protection. We were also treated to a beautiful rainbow. Our server invited us to stay as long as we cared. The view was great. I would highly recommend this restaurant.
… more
At the end of the meal I regretted going here. With so many good restaurants in town, I shouldn’t have picked this one. We had a reservation and we were on time for it. There was a crowd in the waiting area and a lot of confusion on the part of the staff. Most of the people waiting had a reservation and we were all told “we’re not honoring reservations and we are trying to do our best”. Huh? A customer should feel welcomed instead of made to feel like they are a problem. They did seat us about 15 minutes later and the inside was barely half full. There were also people seated outside. It was obvious to all that they were seriously understaffed. The food was fine. We ordered fish fries and it seemed to take longer than it should have for those to come out. Kitchen was understaffed as well. The only reason I’m not giving this one star is because our server was friendly and made the best of the situation.
… more
Adam Buckingham
Pretty much exactly what you would expect from a generic seafood restaurant. Steak, lobster, fried shrimp, fish. The clam chowder was good. The food was above average. The staff seemed frazzled. We had a reservation, but were told we would have to wait with the rest of the people who just showed up. They said the wait would be 45 minutes after our reservation time. The hostess told us that she want allowed to give estimated wait times, only the manager could do that. Thankfully, their estimate was way longer than reality. It was fine, but I don’t need to go back.
… more
Mary Updike
The food was fantastic! I would recommend the coconut shrimp, crab cakes and clam chowder. Our wait staff, “Admiral” Kirsten, as we dubbed her, was fabulous, attentive and has a great sense of humour – so ask to be seated in her section! And, Captain Bill’s hosts a monthly memory cafe and is a dementia friendly restaurant…how amazing is that! Our group of 11 would highly recommend this restaurant!
… more
Maribeth White
Awesome meal at a reasonable price. We are obsessed with the clam chowder. My steak was perfectly done (m. rare) and the scallops were tasty. We also got some cocktail shrimp that were delicious. AND my margarita was very good!
… more
Dan Beardmore
I worked here about 10 years ago as a bartender because my friend was the manager, and discovered their amazing view and menu. Most importantly, though, is pointing out they have the most phenomenal clam chowder you’ll ever find, and today after all this time I confirmed it’s still the same great stuff! Hearty, savory, thick, plenty of clams – its such a unique and delicious recipe it really must be tried!
… more
Riley Shumway
What a terrific evening! The Crab Cakes were delicious and the drinks festive! We ordered from the lighter fare menu but the portions were perfect for us! My steak was perfectly done and my wife truly enjoyed her salmon. Our waitress Naomi was attentive and sweet. We were so touched when she surprised us with a wonderful desert for our anniversary. We will be back! Thank you for making the night so special!
… more
KC Kurtz
My mother and I had reservations for Thursday night at 7:15. We arrived around 5:45 and drank at the bar. Thursday’s are all day happy hour with $2 off beer and wine, $3 off any mixed drink, $5 off any small plates of appetizers and $10 off any large plates of appetizers. The deal is only good as long as you order from the bar. I would highlky recommend (and what a lot of patrons were doing) is make a meal out of that, just ordering and sharing apps. They have a lot of nice choices. The drinks were good, and my scallops were cooked to perfection. My mother ate her scallops and two of mine. I thought the seasonal vegetables were a little underwhelming on the plate. It was just basic green beans and corn on the plate in butter. Nothing special and a little odd combination, but the green beans were cooked perfectly. Service was good at the table, but It was also quite dead. The bar service could be described as spotty and confused. Lots of people not knowing what to do, however when you got your drink they did taste good. It also didn’t help that a man I’m assuming was the boss just stood in the way of everything talking to his buddy at the bar for over an hour. Bar seats are very limited, so it can be hard to find a seat.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment