Social Profile: 
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No dine-in ✔️ No delivery
… View more
We grind fresh nut butters. Grab a sandwich to eat in our courtyard or take to the beach. Come by for a bite to eat and coffee for breakfast, or get a peanut butter cannoli for a snack from our bakery case. We have 9 fresh ground nut butters plus all that accompanies. Your dogs will love our PB Dog treats too.
Snug counter-serve café making multiple flavors of housemade nut butters, plus sandwiches & coffee.
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 516 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204
Phone: (609) 898-4444
Menu
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Cape May Peanut Butter Company | Homemade Peanut …
Visit one of our two locations in Cape May and Smithville New Jersey for the best homemade peanut butter selection provided by Cape May Peanut Butter …
Cape May Peanut Butter Company | Smithville NJ
If you LOVE peanut butter the Cape May and Smithville locations are “must visit” destinations. The first thing that hits you is the great smell of freshly baked …
Peanut Butter Company Locations & Driving Directions
For driving directions from your location, click on the “Directions” link in the designated map above. Locations in Cape May and Smithville New Jersey …
Reviews
Dana Salvatore
Cookies are DRY as a desert. Do not let the smell of this place fool you. Are they serving cookies that are days old?? There’s no reason why the cookies should be this stale and stiff.
… moreKate
Seems like they have awesome peanut butter and flavors of such. However we just got a cookie and scone here but they were pretty dry so I wouldn’t recommend getting their baked goods. Service was also not incredibly friendly
… moreStatler Willand
You’d never think you’d find a specialty peanut butter shop in Cape May, but hey, weirder things have happened. I would eat my weight in this peanut butter if I had the intestinal fortitude to do so. The tastiest peanut butter in all the land for sure. Don’t bother buying the cheap supermarket stuff, just buy Cape May instead. Special shout out to the butterscotch. Whatever they put in that stuff is top class. Well done!
… moreTrevor collinsworth
Cookies in the case are hard as a rock. Peanut butter is good though. Bought some cookies though hard as a rock asked for refund and still haven’t received it. Customer service is very poor.
… moreRohit Nayak
Cute little place in cape may. Absolutely delicious peanut butter. My mom is a crazy peanut butter fan and she absolutely loved this 🙂 she’s come in from India and is taking a few packs home because that’s how much she adored the flavor and freshness of the peanut butter.
… moreHeather Boswick
This place is both dangerous & magical. A peanut butter lovers heaven. Seriously. Love all their hand crafted nut butters (more than just PB!) and fun flavors. This place is seriously dangerous- have I said that yet? So many treats & goodies & sweet things full of peanut butter & dipped in peanut butter await you. Don’t say I didn’t warn you!
… moreRick Broyles
I absolutely love this place. Everything I have is delicious. I have had the peanut butter cups, the super large peanut butter cups, The cookies, but my absolute favorites are the peanut butter nonpereils, peanut butter cookie dough peanut butter, and the peanut butter marshmallow.
… moreRyan Reclaim
Excellent staff and gourmet peanuts a must stop in Cape May Gourmet tasting of several. Customized peanut butter flavors. Great stop for families and peanut butter lovers. Easy walk from Congress Hall and you are located at the Washington Street outdoor mall.
… moreMrs. McCorry
My husband loves peanut butter so we quickly went in when we saw it through the alley of the main thoroughfare. The woman inside was very nice and encouraged us to sample the different butters. I like the almond butter and my husband also liked the cashew butter. There were also ghost pepper peanuts which were super spicy and we got a large container. I had to eat a peanut butter malted milk ball to get the spicey taste out. And I bought a bag of that as well! Great little shop.
… moreGabriel Garcia
Great boutique store specializing in peanut butter and jams. There are free samples available and the staff walks around with samples of the bakery products. Store is really small so couple of customers in there makes it really cramped.
… more