Butterfield’s Buffet at Choctaw Casino & Resort – Durant offers a diverse, all-you-can-eat dining experience with a wide selection of cuisines. From BBQ and Asian dishes to Italian, seafood, and a delectable dessert station, Butterfield’s Buffet has something for everyone. With multiple stations serving freshly prepared dishes, you can enjoy everything from slow-cooked ribs to stir-fried noodles, all under one roof. Perfect for family dining or group gatherings, the buffet provides a variety of flavors to satisfy every taste. Whether you’re craving comfort food or exploring new flavors, Butterfield’s Buffet delivers a dining experience that keeps you coming back for more.
Large casino buffet eatery offering international & American fare from spring rolls to prime rib.
Brad Glass
Delicious buffet with loads of options! We had prime rib roast and fried shrimp. Crab legs are smaller so a lot of busy work and not as much crab meat. But they are good! Delicious bread pudding! Excellent service with keeping us in everything we needed. A +++
… moreJulia Rivera
I have been here 3 times. I feel the food is not made with love. I tried the jambalaya and etouffee and both were way too salty. The pho also too salty. The ground beef for the tacos without flavor. The sides were ok. Not sure if 55 per person is the right price. People come to this buffet but the food quality needs to improve. The employees are great but the food quality is not there.
… moreRita Figueroa
Came to visit this beautiful casino. The buffet isn’t to big, food was delicious especially the fried catfish! The lunch price with your card was $20. Great deal and value.
… moreShadowSiren88
Seafood buffet on Saturday at 4 pm $45 each. Crab and prime rib were good. Come early, no line, and the best cuts are out early. Everything else was kind of lacking. The only other items I liked were curry chicken and the sausage at the craving station. Dessert was great variety but all items were lacking in quality. I could taste the metal from the canned peach cobbler. The carrot cake was pretty and had spice flavor but frosting overpowered it. Chocolate silk pie tasted oily/artificial and my aunts chocolate cake was a bit dry. Come for crab and prime rib but nothing else. Ana was our waitress and was awesome, she kept our table clean, glasses full, and brought us coffee for dessert. (Coffee was watery, but hot).
… moreJimmy Ly
This was a very basic buffet which featured a carving station, country style options, Italian, Tex Mex, and Asian food items. The country and Asian options were enclosed so a server would scoop your food on a plate for you. I went on a Wednesday around 3 so I paid about $20 which is pretty good for a late lunch. You get what you pay for so for the most part I was satisfied.
My only knock is the variety isn’t that great and the food you can tell has been kept warm for a while. The servers were good about clearing plates and refilling drinks.
I’d probably spend close to the same amount if I ate elsewhere in the casino, so I would probably give it another try in the future.
… moreCentrifugal Muse
I just visited the buffet last night for the very first time.
Most of the food here LOOKED good, but was cold, tasteless, and such a let down.
We went on a Thursday at dinner time and I can’t believe we paid $40 PER PERSON for food that tasted worse than Golden Corral.
The crab leg buffet served cold, dry, flavorless crab that I refused to eat after my first piece. The moist towelettes provided were literally DRY?!
The garlic knots were hard as a rock. The pizza was old and luke warm. Even the food that tasted decent was lukewarm or cold.
The fruit was okay, but the dessert was fabulous! A large variety too.
I’m giving 2 stars instead of 1, because even though the main food was an absolute abomination to mankind, the staff was amazing, and I got full on YUMMY dessert.
Will I be back? Absolutely NOT.
I can’t believe I spent some of my winnings on this place. Yuck.
… moreVickie
Absolutely do not recommend! We went for brunch and it was outrageously overpriced for mediocre at best, 90% fried food. Limited choices, repetitive dishes. Should have drove on to Golden Corral. Would have been better food with more choices at less than half the price.
Plus, the website prices are wrong. We were charged $10 more than what is on the website, because the prices had raised (months before). We almost left, and I wished we would have. We could have had a nice steak dinner. Cold dishes, over/undercooked food, greasy, bland.
Don’t waste your $$$
The only good part was our server, who was 100% attentive and friendly.
… moreNicholas Jenson
A lot of protein options. The orange chicken I got was good, definitely a quality chicken – all white meat, but didn’t have the more crunchy-ish fried outer texture I get at Panda Express. Might’ve been understaffed as no one was working the butcher station when I arrived to it. The brisket was surprisingly good – very fatty and moist. The pizza looked comical, I can’t believe they serve that. Overall not a terrible value, I definitely left stuffed.
… moreApril
This is one of the best buffets I’ve had in a long time. Brings back childhood memories of my dad and I going to the buffet and loading up on crab. I like that it’s served my someone, as to us seeing it ourselves. Seems more sanitary this way. The crab legs are amazing. Meats are good as well. Service is great. My drink was never empty.
… moreKatlynn Cha
After the pandemic the selection of available dishes drastically changed as well as the opportunity to scoop our own food. Mid-level cuisine and had to go back to the buffet bar multiple trips since they scoop tiny portions for each person. They didn’t have pizza at the time we went during pre NYE dinner which was very surprising. Their dessert variety was great and I will give credit to how delicious the cakes were – most of which came w cake pops. Alright dining for the prices paid especially for crab legs weekend but besides the selection of desserts and seafood, the American food available was very mid.
… more