Ian Christiansen
Great food and varied menu. If you are traveling 322 it is worth stopping in. It’s barely out of the way.
… moreconnie pinzone
We found this restaurant by accident traveling to NJ to see family. Now we make a point to stop here every time we go. Everything we have tried is simply delicious ! Pizza, eggplant, stromboli, salads…even the tuna sandwich! So good and nice portions! Check it out, you won’t regret it! And see you in March !!
… moreCarl Oberg
We have been to Brothers Pizza several times over the past couple years and are never disappointed when we go there! They have great pizza, stromboli and sandwitches. The servers and staff are also always very nice and friendly. We highly recommend stopping there for a bite to eat!
… moreDaniel Schaeffer
Loved and enjoyed the food. The portion was great. Photo do not it justice.
… moreCarrie Kolesar
Super nice waitress, classic Italian restaurant atmosphere, great eggplant parm but, guys, get the gnocchi! It’s out of this world: soft little pillows stuffed with cheesy goodness! Paired with the excellent vodka sauce, this was the best restaurant dish I’ve eaten in a long time!
… moreLily Russell
This was the first time that I have gone out to eat since March. As you may guess, I am rather cautious and this was a rather nerve wracking experience for me. But I was very pleasantly surprised by the experience that I had here and wanted to share that. They had signs (pictured) that provided clear direction for customers regarding the expectations for masking and social distancing. All employees were always wearing masks. Our server, Brent, was very respectful and helpful. At one point I saw an employee exit the back (from the bathroom I believe) without a mask. After 2 steps, I saw a look of panic cross her face and she ran back to grab a mask. The bathrooms smelled clean and had some touchless features. Our silverware was wrapped in paper. The cheese came in small cups. Over all, I felt very safe and felt that the employees were taking the situation seriously and that the restaurant was taking steps to ensure that the customers were as well.
But it wouldn’t have been very helpful if I had felt safe but the food was lacking. However, the food here is amazing and that holds true now more than ever. Thank you to everyone who worked hard and made this trip out a successful one!
… moreAvida Zarei
The food was good and the menu has a lot of variety and it’s not only consists of Italian which is good. The only flaws was you can’t change the food to your taste. I mean sometimes you want for example some preferences like mozzarella cheese over provolone but they won’t take your preferences ♀️
… morePaul Messer
Stopped in for the first time after driving by several times. Our experience was great. Hidden gem for sure. Just wish we had a pizza shop, Italian restaurant like this where we live!
… moreBabiuc Sergiu
We stopped here for lunch with friends before our Penn’s Cave tour, and the food was absolutely delicious! The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and perfect for sharing.
What really stood out, though, was the kindness of the staff. My fiancée accidentally left her coffee mug behind, and they went out of their way to send it to our home at no cost. That level of care and generosity is rare these days and speaks volumes about the people who run this place.
Amazing food, wonderful people—highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area!
… moreJIHYE KIM
Basil tomato soup
Breaded eggplant sticks
Brother’s all meat pizza (with galic crust)
I think it’s a good restaurant with excellent service, elegant interior, and the garlic crust is a great idea. However, I wish the pizza had been less salty; it would have been much tastier.
… more