Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ No takeout
… View more
In 2021 the Brotherhood and the entire property was given new life. The Brotherhood was recreated to be the best it ever was and three more concepts were added – a beer garden patio, the Notch Whiskey Bar and Cisco Kitchen & Bar. Brotherhood of Thieves is open year -round on Nantucket Island.
Family-friendly pick featuring hearty eats, craft beers, a patio & a cozy fireplace.
Hours
| Monday (Labor Day) | 11:30 AM–12 AM Hours might differ |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
Menu
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Brotherhood Nantucket | Bar & Grill in Nantucket, MA
Family-friendly pick featuring hearty eats, craft beers, a patio & a cozy fireplace.
The Brotherhood of Thieves – Nantucket – Resy
The Brotherhood will be reopening this season, celebrating 50 years of good food and good drink on Nantucket Island. The brand new space will feature a …
What was the Brotherhood of Thieves Riot?
The Brotherhood of Thieves Riot refers to riots that occurred in the streets of Nantucket in the summer of 1842. The unusual sign that hangs over The …
Reviews
Amy Stradling
Absolutely amazing! We loved the clam chowder, a little different than the average chowder. It’s my favorite clam chowder ever. And the fish sandwich!! Now that is a great fish sandwich! Went for lunch at a slowish time and service was excellent! Nicely decorated inside
… moreJen Rogers
Great dinner spot on Nantucket! We went for an earlier dinner before catching our ferry back and the place wasn’t very busy. Veggie burger and fish and chips were both very much enjoyed! Service was pretty prompt as well.
… moreJayson Tomasulo
Came for dinner without a reservation a few weeks ago and it took a couple of hours to get a table. The bartender was friendly and engaging and the drinks were solid. The oysters were excellent and my chicken Marsala was very good as well. The waitress at our table was a bit on the slow side, but overall, it was worth the trip and the food has greatly improved in the past couple of years.
… moreStacey McKenzie
Always is a different adventure. The newly renovated place is cute. Giving a modern vibe upstairs and a cold dark basement.
… moreKaren Sweeney
Always a good spot for great food options . The prices are usually decent too. We had a party of 6 and it went fairly well except the outside seating that we wanted wasn’t getting enough shade from the umbrella but the staff was very accommodating to try , and when it didn’t we easily moved seat inside . Fast and efficient service. Friendly servers and bussers.
… moreRyan Cotton
The staff are welcoming and helpful. The Chowder is excellent and the short rib sandwich also tastes great! Large assortment of drinks from the bar. Very chill and cool atmosphere.
… moreAva Lanning
THE BEST French Onion Soup I have ever had.
… morePeter Stieglmayr
GET THE LOBSTER ROLL W BROWN BUTTER SAUCE…IT WILL CHANGE YOUR LIFE!!! Service was great. Had also the fish & chips battered which was well made! Highly Recommend.
… moreJake Domanski
Nice tavern style restaurant. Got the fish and chips, it was alright, a little bland. Not the worst but not the best i’ve had. Service was good though
… moreDan Ferrara
I picked this spot because of the funny name. Expecting average American bar food but what I was treated to was one of the juiciest and most delicious fried chicken cutlets I’ve ever had. Food, drinks and service were all excellent.
… more