Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Do you want traditional Italian pizza made with fresh ingredients and classic recipes? Are you looking for a local pizzeria that offers a wide variety of Italian favorites? Come to Brooklyn Square Pizza in Toms River, Manalapan Township or Jackson Township, NJ for a pizzeria experience with personality. We combine the true mom and pop pizza experience with years of pizza-making technique to create a pizza that’s worth talking about.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 73 Wilson Ave, Manalapan Township, NJ 07726
Phone: (732) 851-7599
Website: https://brooklynsquarenj.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Brooklyn Square Pizza: Local Pizzeria | Jackson, Manalapan …
Brooklyn Square Pizza is a local pizzeria with locations in Jackson, Manalapan Township & Toms River, NJ. Stop by our pizza shop today.
Brooklyn Square Pizza Manalapan Township – Manalapan …
Get 5% off your pizza delivery order – View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Brooklyn Square Pizza Manalapan Township in Manalapan Township, NJ.
Brooklyn Square Pizza Manalapan Township – View Menu & Order …
Fresh mozzarella, our homemade sauce, and a layer of pecorino romano cheese on our thick and airy crust. $29.00. Vodka Upside Down Square Pizza. Best seller. NJ …
Reviews
Jennifer
I was originally going to give Brooklyn Square Pizza 4 stars based on my first visit, but today I had their 3 cheese with garlic and olive oil square pizza slice and LOVED it! I have to give this place 5 stars because that pizza was so amazing! Their Peters and upside down is also very good too! Their pizza is soft, moist, and doughy. I’m definitely adding Brooklyn Square to my rotation. I highly recommend Brooklyn Square Pizza in Manalapan!
… moreScott Vernborg
I drove a half an hour out of my way to try this Pizza. I picked up the Brooklyn Square not expecting what it would taste like but I was hopeful. When I got home and took a bite, WOW. you ever bite into a square Pizza and it’s Doughy . Well this dough is lite and airy and not Chewy. If I’m out that way again I will stop.
… moreharshil shah
Visited the Brooklyn Square for the first time after hearing so much about it. Tried their most famous upside down and vodka slices. The pizza was very soft but the flavors were ok. It was very basic and nothing extra ordinary. I didn’t think it was worth the hype.
… morez Chu
Well worth the trip from local to far. OneBite 8.9. Pizza is delicious in all aspects. Excellent Sicilian squares. Sauce delightful, not overly sweet or overpowering. Dough is right amount of airy, soft and chewy not burnt or over crisp. Toppings blended well and created more layers of flavor.
… moreD topal
Pizza is great, a little bit behind the Jackson location but still great. I go their chicken parm sub for the first time and it was excellent. The girl behind the counter is very nice as well
… moreJyoti Pant
Their vodka sauce upside down pizza is my new fav. It’s hands down the most delicious pizza I have had in NJ. The staff is super caring and attentive.
… moreAnn Mancuso
If it weren’t for the 2 hr wait for a pie, I’d def have given 5 stars. I ordered online tonite and was advised 45-55 min. I showed up at 1 hour and was told it was an additional 30 minutes!
I attempted to leave and requested a refund as I was very tired and hungry from a long day of work from a 12+ hour shift. It was refreshing that the person at the counter was considerate of the situation and offered a reasonable solution – although I lived just outside their delivery area, the delivered the pie as soon as it was ready.
It arrived piping hot and delicious. Thank you, Brooklyn Sq for hiring a team that connects with its customers and makes an effort to find solutions.
… moreI attempted to leave and requested a refund as I was very tired and hungry from a long day of work from a 12+ hour shift. It was refreshing that the person at the counter was considerate of the situation and offered a reasonable solution – although I lived just outside their delivery area, the delivered the pie as soon as it was ready.
It arrived piping hot and delicious. Thank you, Brooklyn Sq for hiring a team that connects with its customers and makes an effort to find solutions.
Bruce Wayne
Good food, but wildly overpriced & they nickel-&-dime you for everything. I’ve spent $100+ here on many occasions, & they still charge $2 for a tiny cup of Parm or sauce on the side. I’ve honestly never seen anything like it. It feels cheap & insulting as a customer. At this point, I wouldn’t be surprised if they start charge for napkins or just to walk in the door.
On top of that, the girl at the front is rude and acts like she’s sitting on a throne. 0 customer service. Food might be decent, but the pricing attitude & service make it not worth it.
… moreOn top of that, the girl at the front is rude and acts like she’s sitting on a throne. 0 customer service. Food might be decent, but the pricing attitude & service make it not worth it.
Nia, Lens Go
We got take out. The pizza is legit! It has light sesame arpund the edges of the crust. Taste is fantastic! Very friendly staff (nearly everyone said hi in the 5 min we were there). We almost felt like celebrities.
Clean interior and plenty of parking.
… moreClean interior and plenty of parking.
Rosalie B
This Italian lady decided to cater Christmas dinner for the first time ever. My entire family and I were so pleased with the outcome. The food was amazingly delicious!!!!! Everyone raved. Thank you to your staff for being very courteous and helpful with answering questions the many times I called. ❣️
… more