Opened in February 2017. the Brooklyn Pizza company has fast become one of the best Italian restaurants in the area. Everything is made fresh in our kitchen, we even hand grind our own tomatoes for our sauce. One of our owners is from Brooklyn and we pride ourselves on serving the real deal. We are also on Bite Squad and Uber Eats.
Airika
Nice pizza restaurant and food was good. Our
waitress was very friendly and attentive. Menu had great options to choose from.
I do have to say the pizza was a little lacking in flavor, maybe will give it another try next time.
… moreNick Aquino
We were in Indian Shores last week on vacation. I stumbled on this place and it truly was one of the highlights to our trip. We stopped in for take out and the next next we went back again. Being originally from upstate NY, our benchmark for pizza has always been extremely high. Brooklyn Pizza shattered our expectations. I could tell they use only the best ingredients, especially their cheese. The flavor of the food was outstanding! The owner was working in the pizza station when we arrived and he came over and welcomed us. You could tell his staff has learned from him. The entire staff was extremely attentive and friendly. 10/10 – I highly recommend!!
… moreDavid Palermiti
A friend and I overheard one of the owners talking about, while we were out today, and we decided to try it. Glad we did. Friendly atmosphere, amazing service, and top notch quality food. Always love finding hidden gems. If in the Seminole,FL area, do not miss this place.
… moreJonah Spool
As good as it gets. Legit New York style pizza, with quality toppings and at good prices. The meatballs and sausage are seasoned perfectly, so no worries about bland ingredients! Also, it’s one of the few places you can go for a proper calzone made with ricotta cheese. Don’t sleep on this place, it’s one of my go-to joints every time I’m in the area.
… moreE E
Owner is always there & consistently makes an effort to make sure his patrons love the food & feel wwlcomed & appreciated.
Very good food. Very, very good sangria. Jovial hometown place.
… morePat Wipf
Our last night on our vacation and I came across this pizzeria. We had a large order which consist of three pizzas, 50 wings and 2 large Greek salad. They said the deliver time was an hour but I do think it came early. When I say they didn’t disappoint everything was delicious. The pizza was very tasty and the wings were huge. I do believe they bless us with extra pieces of wings as well. Thanks to everyone who made our delivery process tasteful and enjoyable. The pictures were taken after we ate.
… moreRebecca Davis
We couldn’t have asked for a better venue for our rehearsal dinner than Brooklyn Pizza Company. From the moment we arrived, we were impressed by the inviting space, which set the perfect tone for our celebration. The staff went above and beyond to accommodate our needs, allowing our family to arrive early to decorate and personalize the space.
One of the highlights of our experience was the flexibility they showed with our menu preferences. They were incredibly open to our ideas and worked with us to create the perfect menu that suited our tastes and preferences perfectly. It was such a relief to have that level of flexibility and support during the planning process.
However, what truly made our evening unforgettable was the exceptional service we received from our server. He was attentive, friendly, and went above and beyond to ensure that everything ran smoothly throughout the evening. His dedication and hustle did not go unnoticed, and he played a significant role in making our event a success.
Overall, we can’t recommend Brooklyn Pizza Company highly enough. From the great space to the accommodating staff and outstanding service, they exceeded our expectations in every way possible. If you’re looking for a venue for your rehearsal dinner or any special event, look no further – Brooklyn Pizza Company is the place to be!
… moreKenyortta Lewis
I’m giving this place one star rating because my experiences have been completely opposite on two different nights. The first time I ordered, the pizza was genuinely really good — fresh, hot, and full of flavor. It made me excited to come back.
But the very next night told some friends and family about establishment how good food was however next night a completely different story. The quality just wasn’t there. The pizza tasted rushed, the toppings were uneven, and it honestly felt like it came from a different restaurant altogether. It was disappointing, especially after having such a great experience the night before.
Overall, this place can be good, but the inconsistency makes it hard to trust especially for the amount of money your spending
… moreShinji Urushihara
One of our friends recommended this place as having the best NYC style pizza in Seminole, Florida, and as a former New Yorker, I strive for that same quality and taste that a pizza has to offer. My family ordered out for the first time and got one Large Cheese Pizza and a Large Bronx Bomber, and boy oh boy, it did NOT disappoint! Everything was perfect! The sauce, the cheese, toppings, the right amount of crust, etc. Tastes just as good as NYC pizza. We’re definitely going to visit this place in the near future and order more often. Delicious!
… moreMelissa Legge Simas
Went tonight and had the Sicilian pizza and the godfather pizza, both very flavorful and cooked to perfection. The live music was a spectacular touch for Valentines weekend! The service and server were amazing!
… more