Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Brooklyn pizza in the heart of Florida Since 1984 the Brooklyn Pizza Group has been offering authentic New York style pizza in Orlando FL with fresh hand-made dough every day and only the finest ingredients, from homemade sauce to top quality cheeses, meaning every bite bursts with flavor. This is the authentic Brooklyn Pizza Style in Orlando
No-frills venue featuring NY-style pizzas & a range of classic red-sauce Italian bites.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5681 Pershing Ave, Orlando, FL 32822
Phone: (407) 282-0110
Website: https://order.toasttab.com/online/brooklyn-pizza-group-5681-pershing-avenue
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Brooklyn Pizza Group 5681 Pershing Avenue – Order Online
Sign in for a faster ordering experience. Brooklyn Pizza Group 5681 Pershing Avenue. 5681 Pershing Avenue, Orlando, FL.
Brooklyn Pizza | Orlando FL – Facebook
Brooklyn Pizza, Orlando. 674 likes · 1129 were here. Brooklyn pizza in the heart of Florida Since 1984 the Brooklyn Pizza Group has been offering authent.
Order Brooklyn Pizza – Orlando, FL Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Brooklyn Pizza at 5681 Pershing Avenue in Orlando. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Reviews
Horio Morgan
I ordered the 14” Bianca with Tomatoes and Basil pizza. They said it would be $28.00 for a medium pizza.
I paused and I said you guys make good pizza. It’s worth it, and I placed the order. I live 10 minutes down the street from the pizza shop. When it got here it was ice cold and looked like a bunch of slices that were thrown together. I assumed it was a display pizza that did not sell.
When I called back and asked if my pizza was made fresh he said we usually make them fresh, but if I wanted to get in my car and drive the cold pizza back they would make me a new one.
I had to call back a second time just to tell them how awful it was. He said don’t blame them blame the door dash driver.
This place used to make really good pizza. Now? I WOULD NEVER ORDER ANYTHING FROM THESE PEOPLE EVER AGAIN!! The food was terrible and the customer service was even worse.
ALMOST $30 for a medium sized pizza that tased like it had been sitting on a counter all day. AVOID DOING BUSINESS WITH THESE PEOPLE. Way Over Priced and Super Underwhelming!!!
… moreI paused and I said you guys make good pizza. It’s worth it, and I placed the order. I live 10 minutes down the street from the pizza shop. When it got here it was ice cold and looked like a bunch of slices that were thrown together. I assumed it was a display pizza that did not sell.
When I called back and asked if my pizza was made fresh he said we usually make them fresh, but if I wanted to get in my car and drive the cold pizza back they would make me a new one.
I had to call back a second time just to tell them how awful it was. He said don’t blame them blame the door dash driver.
This place used to make really good pizza. Now? I WOULD NEVER ORDER ANYTHING FROM THESE PEOPLE EVER AGAIN!! The food was terrible and the customer service was even worse.
ALMOST $30 for a medium sized pizza that tased like it had been sitting on a counter all day. AVOID DOING BUSINESS WITH THESE PEOPLE. Way Over Priced and Super Underwhelming!!!
G L
Lived over here in the area for 6 years or so now, have never tried this place, and they have been open since before my grandmother was here (20 years)
I tried them tonight and I cannot for the life of me understand why there is a 4.1 review, this pizza is fantastic. A pepperoni, onion, and extra cheese pizza was ordered. It is seasoned and prepared I think like no other pizza I have had from an Italian restaurant, and thats going against my normal place. The pieces are also gigantic, 6 slices for a medium instead of 8 but they are about 1.5 size each piece.
The toppings as well were plentiful, along with some being on top of the cheese and some under, an interesting combo that worked. The garlic knots were also good.
All in all, I will be back to order again.
… moreI tried them tonight and I cannot for the life of me understand why there is a 4.1 review, this pizza is fantastic. A pepperoni, onion, and extra cheese pizza was ordered. It is seasoned and prepared I think like no other pizza I have had from an Italian restaurant, and thats going against my normal place. The pieces are also gigantic, 6 slices for a medium instead of 8 but they are about 1.5 size each piece.
The toppings as well were plentiful, along with some being on top of the cheese and some under, an interesting combo that worked. The garlic knots were also good.
All in all, I will be back to order again.
Kurt Kuhl
Ok. Buyer beware. I ordered the XL Special. $23:99. According to the printed menu available in store. Comes with a topping. I added extra cheese. Now please, the taste of the pizza was GREAT. But no extra cheese. Also when I wanted to pay. It was $34.99. I asked where the additional $10 came from and the cashier gave a real attitude. Great tasting pizza, but they will rip you off. Buyer Beware!!!!!
… morePamela Polsunas
Pizza is incredible the crust is perfect! Definitely Brooklyn style. My son and I enjoyed the food and staff is great too!
… moreJojo aka mambo king
Best pizza , huge slices , seats just like New York . Love this place 10/10 recommendation
… morelisa love
Waitress, Locationand food are terrific!! We’ll be back.. 5stars⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreMigdalia Torres
Good pizza and a great price for 2 slices and a drink only 5.99 but there’s also a card fee attached to it – bummer ! Otherwise decent spot and friendly staff- I’ll come back again
… moreSAJ Universe
Decent Pizza, But the Card Fee Leaves a Bad Taste
I stopped by Brooklyn Pizza because I was in the area and wanted something quick. I also like checking out new pizza spots. I ordered the lunch special: two cheese slices and a drink for $5.99 — a good deal on the surface.
What I didn’t know was that there’s a $1.00 service charge for using a card, which I only found out after I paid. That felt a bit excessive, especially for such a small purchase.
As for the pizza, it was okay — nothing bad, but nothing that really stood out either. It’s solid, standard pizza, but not something that makes me eager to come back. Combined with that card fee, I’d only consider returning if I’m paying cash.
… moreI stopped by Brooklyn Pizza because I was in the area and wanted something quick. I also like checking out new pizza spots. I ordered the lunch special: two cheese slices and a drink for $5.99 — a good deal on the surface.
What I didn’t know was that there’s a $1.00 service charge for using a card, which I only found out after I paid. That felt a bit excessive, especially for such a small purchase.
As for the pizza, it was okay — nothing bad, but nothing that really stood out either. It’s solid, standard pizza, but not something that makes me eager to come back. Combined with that card fee, I’d only consider returning if I’m paying cash.
Adrian Gtz
Had the lunch special…pizza was amazing for such a low price!
… moreKLZ Essentials LLC
I grew up eating this pizza and while in the area I stopped in to just grab a slice specialty and was told the special was $6.99 and to add pepperoni to the the slices the would be an additional $1.50 PER SLICE. Meaning $6.99 + $3 =$9.99 times 2 for 4 slices of pizza $20 what a price gouging is this the cost of goods has not come to this. I don’t want a whole pizza nor am I willing to pay equal to or more than an entire pizza for a few slices and a soda. Needless to say they have lose a longtime customer and I will no longer recommend them either.
… more