Jennifer Burn
The owner apparently doesn’t look at reviews, so I’ll just say my peace and be done with it. New to area/state. I’ve lived in a lot of states, so i know good pizza from bad. Tried thin crust pep a few weeks ago. Was good, but I prefer a hand tossed pie. Ordered thick crust pep with “garlic” breadsticks tonight. Both were horrible. Crust was factory bought and had no flavor. Garlic sticks turned out to be cheese(powdered) with a little garlic butter in the middle on a pie crust. I’ll stick with their thin crust cause their pizza is better than the Pizza Hut in town. Won’t be ordering anything else from them, though.
… moreBryan “Beardedragehere” Guthrie
The pizza is fantastic with almost no flop and very crispy! Highly recommended!
… moreKeith Lopez
It tasted marvelous just like it was the last time I ate it back in 1987 will reccomend it next time anyone is near wellington.
… moreMaria Bisle
We always make sure we stop in for lunch whenever we are in town. Love the small town atmosphere. Great pizza. Awesome people.
… moreAriel Lynn
They now accept debt cards! Now if we could get a changing table in the ladies restroom, that would be amazing! Service and food was good as always, more options on pizza would be nice during lunch time though. Altogether it was a good experience.
… moreGrizzly Bear
We got a giant meat pizza, a giant taco pizza, and a medium chocolate chip dessert pizza. We are also long-time Casey’s Pizza lovers. Personally, I was blown away. The taco pizza isn’t really like Casey’s, but I think it’s BETTER. My husband was quite happy with the meat pizza, and he suggested we go to Big Cheese pizza instead of Casey’s from now on. The dessert pizza was something I wasn’t sure we would like, and it really was hit and miss. I liked it, though I won’t be ordering it every pizza haul because it is really sugary. My husband passed it up because it was so sugary.
If I remember right, we spent about $55. For the amount of pizza we got, it was definitely worth it. The price is fair, the staff was awesome, and the pizza was amazing. What more can you ask for?
… moreMichael Vogt
Fun little small town pizza spot keeping local food history alive. The teens working were courteous and cheerful. So glad I found out this is still down here (I’m from an hour or so away)!
… moreKip Etter
Great pizza for an unbeatable price. The staff are all very nice & pleasent to work with. The pizzas are handmade & cooked in an old school oven not a wire rack conveyor belt. Fast service that can’t be beat. Great choice & your supporting a small town local owned business. It’s been here for over 25years so that should say enough.
… moreSeth Dugan
Building is really run down, employees are extremely rude and make you feel like your wasting their time, with the exception of owner who is patient and friendly. Great pizza at reasonable prices, but definitely recommend carryout to avoid sneers from high school kids who don’t appreciate where their paychecks come from.
… moreJason Bruns
Great place to eat especially during the buffet hours. There are always very friendly and willing to make any kind of pizza that you want,even specialty pizza. Kurt is a great guy and has been a big supporter of Wellington for years! Great delivery. $10 large is a great Buy.
… more