Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Low-key pizzeria with seating inside & out, offering 20+ pie toppings alongside subs, wine & beer.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2651 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209
Phone: (614) 237-3305
Website: http://www.bexleypizzaplus.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bexley Pizza Plus
We deliver! to Bexley, Berwick and Eastmoor. Call 614-237-3305. Only the Best. Ingredients – fresh dough – 100% real cheese blend of mozzarella and provolone.
Bexley Pizza Plus, 3651 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213, US
Bexley Pizza Plus is a charming eatery located in Columbus, OH, known for its delicious, hand-crafted pizzas and welcoming atmosphere.
Bexley Pizza Plus | Facebook
Experience Columbus launches new Columbus Style Pizza Trail. Gregg Dodd … Bexley Pizza Plus 2651 E Main St Bexley, OH 43209 614.237.3305 · Frank Carter …
Reviews
Brianna Dekle
Best pizza place around! They always get the order right and are friendly. I recommend the pepperoni and mushroom pizza or the three cheese and mushroom pizza. Their salad is pretty good too. They can be a bit pricey.
… moreShang “The Realist” Rila
The best pizza in central Ohio hands down. Nice dining atmosphere plenty of seating and choice of drinks the carbonara pizza and white pizza are chef’s kiss. And the mini pepperonis!
… moreDan P
Unfortunately, my recent visit to Bexley Pizza Plus was underwhelming. From start to finish, the experience was “ehh.” The service was lackluster, the pizza was unremarkable, and the overall atmosphere was equally forgettable.
There was nothing particularly offensive about the experience, but nothing stood out in a positive way either. The pizza itself was average, lacking the flavor and quality I’ve come to expect from other local pizzerias. The service was indifferent, and the atmosphere provided no ambiance.
Overall, I left feeling disappointed and would not be inclined to return. If you’re looking for a memorable pizza experience, I would suggest exploring other options in the area.
… moreThere was nothing particularly offensive about the experience, but nothing stood out in a positive way either. The pizza itself was average, lacking the flavor and quality I’ve come to expect from other local pizzerias. The service was indifferent, and the atmosphere provided no ambiance.
Overall, I left feeling disappointed and would not be inclined to return. If you’re looking for a memorable pizza experience, I would suggest exploring other options in the area.
Ryan Johnson
Your pizza was the highlight of my week. It satisfied a craving I have been unable to fill in my home state of Texas.
… moreJillian Farley
Pizza Plus is so good ! Their pizzas are filled with fresh ingredients. I love the farmers market pizza, full of fresh vegetables! And the pepperoni and mushroom is real strong. Highly Recommended!
… moreChelsea Martinez
Came here around 8 to find they were already closing the inside and only serving take out. I was excited to try some Columbus style pizza so I happily took my order to go. Got and 8″ pizza and a salad. Pizza was delicous, would highly recommend, the crust is the perfect crispy thin and the toppings were plenty. I’d pass on their salads. The salad itself didn’t match the menu description, it was missing a lot of ingredients and the salad dressing wasn’t very good.
… moreMark B.
Average pizza, I’d give it something like a 6.5/10. The crust was too thick for my taste and kind of flavorless. Toppings were nothing spectacular but the sauce was just about right for me.
… moreDouglas Lunsford
Hands down one of the best pizza I ate since I moved up here in Columbus got really good crust. Awesome pizza.
… moreJoseph Riley
The best pizza, service, and atmosphere I’ve ever received. There ultimate pizza with thin crust is my first recommendation. If you love mushrooms and two different kinds of pepperoni’s it’s a must try. Dine is awesome very friendly and great conversation. This restaurant actually has received awards for their pizza’s
… moreMiguel Hernandez
Bexley Pizza Plus is good and tasty pizza with a nice and sweet marinara sauce. Decent place to eat pizza and enjoy various pizza options. Bexley Pizza Plus also sell other items that may compliment your choice of pizza. There are a few TVs to watch. Parking in the front of this pizza restaurant and on the side of the restaurant. Nice and friendly staff. Handicapped accessible. Decent prices.
… more