Spacious, family-friendly restaurant featuring house-smoked & barbecued meats, plus classic sides.
Grace Miller
I have a gluten allergy. When I told my server this, she immediately got the manager. I ordered a broiled crab cake with a lemon dill sauce, rice and seasonal veggies. The crab cake was excellent! Our server also made the best Shirley Temple!! The evening we were there they had a live band. The music was good, but extremely loud. We were sitting three tables away from the band. We were there 8/16/25 around 8-9pm.
… moreTom A
Very generous portions. Loved their nachos; they’re a must. The flat iron steaks are done to abaolute perfection. Meat is cooked to exact specifications. Not like some places where a medium rare is a medium or a medium well is just well done. They know what they’re doing here. Super tender! Pork shoulder was good too. Only complaint was seating was as comfortable as I would have liked. Food is 5 stars all the way though
… moreDavid
I am writing this in regards to my elderly parents, who recently had a negative experience here. They are both in the mid to late 70s and enjoy this restaurant, they are local. We order from Bethany Blues our thanksgiving meal and in the past we have enjoyed this restaurant.
They were seated in booths and came to enjoy the special that day. After sitting they were told they would need to move to the bar area if they are to eat the special. Since when do we segregate people based on their food order? I guess the people who spend more get the booths and those that spend less get sent to the bar. The bar is loud and with seating that was inappropriate for elderly patrons. The restaurant was not full. They left.
Its a private business and you can make the rules you want, just don’t segregate those that will spend more from those that will spend less.
… moreTanya Sumpter
Because of a gastro bypass, the maryland crab soup is too spicy and their normal barbecue sauce for wings is too spicy for me. Other than that, my boyfriend ate a hamburger and he enjoyed it.
… moreBrian K
Phew, that was a rough meal! I had the St Louis Ribs and they were so dry and not tasteful. The deluxe Mac and cheese was so dry, and to think I chose to pay extra for it. The mashed potatoes looked like they were sitting out for a while. Please check out other restaurants in Rehoboth, as a local, trust me when I tell you there are so many great restaurants in this town. This, is just not it…
Gave two stars for the service because the waiter was great with refilling our cups!
… moreDennis Wildberger
We stopped in on a Saturday afternoon for late lunch/early dinner. The waitstaff was very friendly, and the food was just ok. The Blues Reuben was dry, and the Black and Blue Burger was tasty, but cooked way past medium. The fried pickle app was interesting, not chips or spears, but thin strips that kind of fall apart when you pick them up. The sauces were very good.
… moreSharon McCool
I have to admit, BBQ isn’t my usual go to meal. However, Bethany Blues made me want to come back for more. By far the best BBQ I have ever had. All staff were friendly and service quick.
… moreEimy Bonilla
Bethany Blues was amazing! There was a wait but the hostess gave us a good estimate on the wait time. Everyone was professional and kind. Our waitress Jen was phenomenal, she has an amazing memory. She took care of us right away, got our drinks, appetizers, and entrees.
The food was great, the location is huge with plenty of free parking. It was clean too.
… moreJessica Ott
It was my first time actually walking in this place and the bar tender manning the bar in the back with the tattoos was very welcoming. It was a great atmosphere and whether u are in ur 70s or 30s everyone got along it was a fun 45 mins
… moreRobert Bleecher
Great place for house smoke bbq. Great food, service. And atmosphere.
… more