Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–7 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Benny’s | Birdseye IN – Facebook
Benny’s, Birdseye. 5079 likes · 51 talking about this · 1915 were here … Happy Labor Day from all of us at Bennys! As we take a moment to …
Benny’s Off the Water – Discover Southern Indiana
Benny’s Off the Water · 2976 Dillard Road Birdseye, IN 47513 · (812) 685-2095 · Email.
Barbecue Restaurant in Birdseye, IN: Benny’s Off The Water
Benny’s Off The Water, located at 2976 Dillard Rd, Birdseye, IN, offers a fantastic dining experience with outdoor seating, takeaway, dine-in, and delivery …
Reviews
Micheal Walker
Texas burger and fries were good. My wife had 10 inch pizza. No complaints with food. Service was timely and good. Sat outside on deck, which had plenty of air moving with fans. Recommended.
… moreTim
Nice atmosphere! Food and service was good with nice and plenty outdoor patio seating! Grab yourself some buffalo chicken dip and the Big Ben’s Half Pound Burger! I would say the burger was more than a half pound! Yummy!
… moreMitch Adam
We were staying nearby for the weekend and this was our closest option for getting something to bring back to our cabin. We ordered some wings and a pizza. The pizza wasn’t the best I’ve ever had, but it wasn’t the worst either, the wings were delicious however. The next day we went there for a late lunch, i ordered the Big Ben half pound burger and my wife ordered the pepperoni pizza. The burger was just a frozen patty, cooked well, dry, and bland, pretty underwhelming for a $14 burger. The pizza on the other hand was a very good New York style pizza, thin slices with nice crisp.
It seems like they pretty much have a monopoly in the area because of the lake and all the lodging surrounding them. I’m sure some days are better than others when it comes to quality.
… moreIt seems like they pretty much have a monopoly in the area because of the lake and all the lodging surrounding them. I’m sure some days are better than others when it comes to quality.
Brian Bruner
It was not that busy when I arrived, and I was a solo diner and I knew exactly what I was going to order. It still took over 90 minutes to get out of the building last night. The service was extremely inefficient, especially for the amount of servers and employees that were around. People were coming in and grabbing tables, and waiting 20 minutes to get attention. Some people were even leaving.
The pizza is very close to being superb. As a pizza connoisseur, I would love to make a recommendation on a brand of sauce to change to. I believe the sauce you are using it’s not near as good as your toppings are. I really like your toppings, especially your sausage. I would do some testing on improving the pizza crust. It’s not rising at all. It stays extremely flat and just doesn’t have a great texture. Do some experimenting and modify the crust to rise a little and get some nice chewing us to it, and that will be an incredible pizza!
… moreThe pizza is very close to being superb. As a pizza connoisseur, I would love to make a recommendation on a brand of sauce to change to. I believe the sauce you are using it’s not near as good as your toppings are. I really like your toppings, especially your sausage. I would do some testing on improving the pizza crust. It’s not rising at all. It stays extremely flat and just doesn’t have a great texture. Do some experimenting and modify the crust to rise a little and get some nice chewing us to it, and that will be an incredible pizza!
Jane Runge Darlage
Had heard their pizza was good, but was pleased to find it was superb! Crust was not too thick or thin; edge was just a touch crispy while rest of crust was delightfully chewy. They are generous with the cheese and toppings. Everything was just perfect! They have a nice kids menu and lots of sandwich, appetizer, salad and beer options. A lovely gem in an out-of-the-way locale. Well worth a drive. Serve was excellent, too, even though they were rocking a half hour before closing!
… moreMargie Weatherholt
Service was wonderful for the crowd! Pizza was amazing as always! Loaded fries were a great buy, too. Tenderloin, wings, and burgers were good (just not as expected). Middle of the deck seating is a little loud/hard to hear your table.
… morePaulina Brown
Very good food served by a sweet and funny waitress. I ordered a grilled chicken salad (no tomatoes) with ranch dressing. It was delicious, but the salad was like a shredded topping kind of lettuce if you don’t mind that. The ranch was also kind of chunky (though I may have just gotten the wrong kind and didn’t realize) but it was still good. The fries were the best I’ve had at any restaurant and the All Meat Pizza was my husband’s favorite, he recommends it to anyone who comes here.
… moreKevin Tower
First visit the waitress was friendly and gave great service. Wife had the BBQ pizza it was hot crisp and very good. The rest of us had the shrimp basket, shrimp were fresh and hand breaded and were delicious, my mom and dad who spend a lot of time in Florida said they were as good if not better then what they could get there. The seasoned fries were also very good, looking forward to going back and trying the hand breaded oysters.
… morejanice theising
Poor timing of bringing food out. Brought my husband food out and then brought other people’s food out at other tables. Finally got my Stromboli and it was cold.. Nobody came back to Check on us at all. Even though Other tables for being checked on. Had to ask for a box in our check. all around it was not a good experience
… moreBecka Holman
The first time I got the bbq nachos from here they were loaded with cheese and ingredients, the past two times I have gotten them they have mainly been chips. The waitress was pushy on me eating literally had just got my food and she brought the ticket I waited over 30 minutes for a refill. Not impressed with this place like everyone made it out to be even more so towards the out of town customer.
… more