Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Small counter-serve joint offering sizable pizza slices & pies along with beer & cider.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 722 Caroline St, Fredericksburg, VA 22401
Phone: (540) 368-1690
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Benny Vitali’s
Benny Vitali’s is a Fredericksburg, VA pizza restaurant slinging 28” pies. Check out our hours, directions and menu online.
Benny Vitali’s | Fredericksburg VA – Facebook
This month’s pizza specials are here •Chicken Bacon Ranch •Sun-Dried Tomatoes & Garlic Pesto Available for a limited time—don’t miss out.
Benny Vitali’s (@bennyvitalis) · Fredericksburg, VA – Instagram
Pizza Makers Kitchen Staff Cashiers Apply in person, online, or email your resume to [email protected]. Come be part of the fun! ✨. Photo by Benny …
Reviews
Genory Carr
The best pizza I have found between Woodbridge and FxBG it’s a favorite a staple and home of the Virginia slice. Amazing thin crust and a special blend of cheese. The epitome of a pizza joint! #GoGetIt
Oh yeah they have a million craft beers and sodas! #Cheers
… moreOh yeah they have a million craft beers and sodas! #Cheers
Brad Brundage
The pizza was better than average and the slices were HUGE like bigger than Costco HUGE! The bottom of the crust was superb being perfectly crispy yet chewey. The crust however was lacking flavor and the sauce was just normal with bright notes. The toppings were fine but didn’t stand out.
… moreMichael Joens
Great pizza if you can deal with the crowded loud packed room. Biggest pizza you can buy around here, every month they have special slices like buffalo chicken chicken pesto ect. Love the pizza wish it was a bigger store cause this is one of my family’s favorites!
… moreFelix A
Craving Pizza while in Fredericksburg and decided to stop in as it had pretty good reviews. Cool atmosphere, and service was average. Good location in the historic district. Pizza was good, average, good flavor and crust was average as well. I would return to try a different pizza as I went with the basic cheese. Note, good price for what you get, very big slices and whole pie. Don’t expect NYC pizza, but good for the average neighborhood spot.
… moreEbony Acton
LOVED IT! When you’re walking past, the aroma wafts and hijacks your nose controlling your steps to come & buy a slice or two — with cold bottled pop soda. The slices are nice size & the prices were great! I love how the employees aim to serve a compliment to each customer entering. The Halloween decorations were so creative so I can’t wait to see what Christmas offers. The pizza was delicious! I waited to finish my pizza before drinking my soda to savor the fresh marina sauce, cheese, & PERFECT crust crisp. I’ll be returning soon!
… moreGaryDZ
Giant, Delicious, thin crust pizza. 1 slice is all you need for dinner.
We stop by here every time we are traveling south… It’s about 2 hours from. My house. Always busy. Limited seating. Fun decorations.
… moreWe stop by here every time we are traveling south… It’s about 2 hours from. My house. Always busy. Limited seating. Fun decorations.
Alonzo Esparza
Making my way downtown and I see walk pass me this lady with this humongous pizza had to go and check it out for myself and man I was not disappointed from the food to service and just feeling of the place was wonderful will definitely be going back.
… moreLeilani M
Benny Vitali’s does not believe in small portions — and I respect that.
We’re talking 28-inch pizza pies. For reference, Costco’s are 18″. This thing completely covers our coffee table.
Now let’s talk crust — because I love a good crust. And this one? Super crispy, perfectly cooked, nothing burnt, nothing floppy. Just the right crunch without being over the top. The topping, cheese, and sauce ratio is spot on, too. No sliding toppings. No sauce overload. Just perfectly balanced.
You can dine in or take it to-go, but seating is limited inside and out. Every single time we’ve gone, there’s been a line out the door. We usually opt for to-go and eat it at home… although sometimes we don’t even make it home and end up eating a slice in the car. No regrets.
We went for a Valentine’s lunch and, of course, they were packed again. What shocked me was the wait time — still around 20 minutes, about the same as on a normal day. With that kind of volume? That’s impressive.
Also, shoutout to the fact that they have a pizza box trash bin that actually fits their giant boxes. It’s the little things.
Service is always quick, organized, and efficient. Everyone in there knows exactly what they’re doing, and they do it well.
Zero complaints. Giant pizza. Great crust. Consistent wait times.
We’ll absolutely keep coming back.
… moreWe’re talking 28-inch pizza pies. For reference, Costco’s are 18″. This thing completely covers our coffee table.
Now let’s talk crust — because I love a good crust. And this one? Super crispy, perfectly cooked, nothing burnt, nothing floppy. Just the right crunch without being over the top. The topping, cheese, and sauce ratio is spot on, too. No sliding toppings. No sauce overload. Just perfectly balanced.
You can dine in or take it to-go, but seating is limited inside and out. Every single time we’ve gone, there’s been a line out the door. We usually opt for to-go and eat it at home… although sometimes we don’t even make it home and end up eating a slice in the car. No regrets.
We went for a Valentine’s lunch and, of course, they were packed again. What shocked me was the wait time — still around 20 minutes, about the same as on a normal day. With that kind of volume? That’s impressive.
Also, shoutout to the fact that they have a pizza box trash bin that actually fits their giant boxes. It’s the little things.
Service is always quick, organized, and efficient. Everyone in there knows exactly what they’re doing, and they do it well.
Zero complaints. Giant pizza. Great crust. Consistent wait times.
We’ll absolutely keep coming back.
Eric DiLoreto
Stopped back in November. My girlfriend, and I each got a slice of pepperoni And we were stuffed. The guy making the pizza talked to us while we ate, gave us the run down of different locations, and kind of how it all came to be. If you go in there and eat two slices, you’re an absolute machine.
… moreK R
Local institution in Downtown Fredericksburg. Offers huge slices and mammoth pies with rotating toppings/specials. Great canned/bottled soda and drink options. Great prices to fill you up quick.
It’s a perfect date spot, with booths and some counter seating, but it gets extremely busy on weekends, summer nights etc. Some outdoor seating or you can always bring your slices to Riverfront Park or the steps of the FAM in the back.
Pizza is always super hot and filling, fun, friendly staff.
… moreIt’s a perfect date spot, with booths and some counter seating, but it gets extremely busy on weekends, summer nights etc. Some outdoor seating or you can always bring your slices to Riverfront Park or the steps of the FAM in the back.
Pizza is always super hot and filling, fun, friendly staff.