Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5 Horseshoe Lake Rd, Kauneonga Lake, NY 12749
Phone: (845) 583-4031
Website: https://www.benjiandjakes.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home | benjiandjakes
For 18 years, Benji & Jake’s has been a beloved staple of Kauneonga Lake, serving up more than just great pizza—it’s a place where memories are made, …
Benji & Jake’s | Kauneonga NY – Facebook
Benji & Jake’s is open and back in action for the weekend! Come by for great food, good vibes, and a cozy spot on the lake. We can’t wait to see you!
Benji & Jake’s #benjiandjakes (@benjiandjakes) – Instagram
♀️ ️ Tomorrow Night – 8PM start Benji & Jake’s on Kauneonga Lake Shades live on stage Bring your crew, your best costume, and your dancing shoes — this …
Reviews
Lindsey Carmody
I’ve been coming here for over a decade and the food is always fantastic! I recommend the golden triangles for an appetizer and I tried the vampire slayer pizza last night and it was very good just pretty spicy next time I’m going with no cherry peppers. I also recommend the sweetie pie pizza. I love this place and the food is worth the price!
… moreJamie Marcella
Benji and Jake’s is always a must have when looking for both ambiance and good food. We made a reservation to sit outside but when we arrived they didn’t have a record
Of it. Luckily there was still room and we were able to be seated overlooking the lake. We ordered a mixed green salad which is a standard salad but what takes it to the next level is the delicious spicy peanut sauce you can order as the dressing. We also ordered the Jackson Pollock pizza which provides a nice flavor combination of smokey eggplant, pesto and vodka sauce. My only complaint is this pizza is incredibly oily which is to be expected to a degree with the pesto and cheese. However, don’t let this stop you from ordering it and the flavor is well worth it. Highly recommend this place for delicious food and a great location.
… moreOf it. Luckily there was still room and we were able to be seated overlooking the lake. We ordered a mixed green salad which is a standard salad but what takes it to the next level is the delicious spicy peanut sauce you can order as the dressing. We also ordered the Jackson Pollock pizza which provides a nice flavor combination of smokey eggplant, pesto and vodka sauce. My only complaint is this pizza is incredibly oily which is to be expected to a degree with the pesto and cheese. However, don’t let this stop you from ordering it and the flavor is well worth it. Highly recommend this place for delicious food and a great location.
Summer Putman
Scrolling through some photos and forgot to post about this gem! We stopped here with a group of friends while out on the motorcycles and it was AWESOME!!! There is plenty of indoor seating and a bar but it was a gorgeous day so we took the seating outside on the deck. We ordered a bunch of different pizzas to share and all of them were delicious!!! Service was great, atmosphere was on point and I took my very first photo of a toilet seat in a restaurant because I never saw one like it and thought it was the coolest thing! Would absolutely come back next time we are in the area!
… moreBuenaJay
Came here on 7/10 for desserts and a drink. The interior is rustic and very cozy. Upon entering the staff greeted us and was very friendly.
We ordered ice cream and a cocktail and sat on the back deck to enjoy the view and sun.
The homemade ice cream and pina colada was excellent.
I would definitely recommend this place at any time of day.
Thank you for a great experience.
… moreWe ordered ice cream and a cocktail and sat on the back deck to enjoy the view and sun.
The homemade ice cream and pina colada was excellent.
I would definitely recommend this place at any time of day.
Thank you for a great experience.
Andrew Erskine
This was a strange experience at a beautiful location , we were warned that they were understaffed tonight and things might take a while, but despite these delays and several false alarms with the wrong meals being brought out, when we got our food it was really good. Tasty wings, mozzarella fire sticks, corn ribs pitta and Houmus all delicious . Pizza and burger excellent too. The staff were lovely if a little befuddled and very young to be running the place , perhaps the management should help them out a bit more .
… morematthew guile
Called up with reservation for 13. They said “sure no problem”. Had us set up in the back. We ordered many appetizers and 8 different pizzas.
Amazing food!
… moreAmazing food!
Rose
The first thing I noticed was a dirty floor and uncleared tables. After we were seated, we waited 30 minutes for a server who was very rude. The pizza was cold when we got it. I might have thought it was an off night except I saw cockroaches scurrying across the floor. Stay away!
… moreRick Shirk
This place was quite nice! It’s right on a lake, so a fantastic view was to be had. We didn’t sit outside unfortunately because it had just rained, but that was an option.
My son and I shared a vegan pepperoni pizza which was AWESOME. We loved it.
… moreMy son and I shared a vegan pepperoni pizza which was AWESOME. We loved it.
Tiffany Denier
Great view of the lake. Inside and outside seating. Large menu. Loved that they had fake meat options.
Food was delicious, did take a very long time to get served and it wasn’t busy but overall a good experience. Will definitely be back.
… moreFood was delicious, did take a very long time to get served and it wasn’t busy but overall a good experience. Will definitely be back.
Susan E
Had the El Monaco pizza ($24.) it was good and unique. Very thin crust almost like a flat bread with toppings. Good taste. We went at 2:30 on Sunday didn’t eat until 45 minutes later. Wasn’t crowded just slow service at tables. Nice view of the water.
… more