Craving a slice of pizza perfection? Journey to Bella’s Pizzeria, where pizza dreams come true with over a hundred unique and delicious pizza creations! More than just pizza, our Italian restaurant also offers a tempting selection of sandwiches, hot subs, satisfying wraps, and hearty dinners. Whether you choose delivery, takeaway, or dine-in, prepare for an unforgettable culinary experience at Bella’s Pizzeria on Liberty Street.
Casual place for pizza, panini & Italian entrees along with burgers & other American options.
Christa L (American Girl Doll)
Delicious gluten free pizza. Welcoming, friendly, accommodating pizza masters. Booth & table seating, clean, comfortable, awesome hot pizza! Delicious sauce, real cheese, great quality ingredients so no grease all over. Chicken parm could have been a bit thicker but good. Get the pizza surprising gem off the beaten track.
… moreJake Spaans
The food was pretty good, it was a pretty basic pizza spot.
That being said I was surprised at how pricey it was, was around $45 for a wrap, 2 drinks, and 4 slices of pizza which feels pretty steap.
That being said I would go there again especially if they have lunch specials. Staff was nice.
… moreNicholas Lauriesson
My family has been coming here for the longest time and we always love this place. From the friendly people that work there to absolutely delicious food. The order always comes out perfect and we’ve never had a single issue. My mom who was always strict with how she liked her pizza always rated Bella’s as the greatest pizza in the area. If you want a perfect pie, Bella’s is the place you are looking for.
… morePeter Masucci
11-2-2025 ordered takeout
Rigatoni bolonese pasta was either old or over cooked it fell apart when I stuck my fork in it.
The sauce was tasteless, did not have the ingredients you would usually find in bolonese sauce i.e. carrots, onions, celery. I also ordered a plain greens salad and got a specialty salad with sugar covered walnuts, raisins, mozzarella cheese and tomatoes let’s not forget the wilted lettuce hanging out of the container. Usually you’d get a piece of bread instead they gave me over toasted garlic bread. $34.
Had to take 4 TUMS just to ease the agita.
This was strike 2 with their takeout meals I’m not looking to strikeout.
Bella’s you are out.
… moreDonna
We are from Michigan (originally from New York). We cannot find good New York pizza in Michigan. Bellas is our go to place when we visit our Mom in New Jersey. Best pizza ever! Thanks!
… moreDavid M. Dwight
Didn’t have a chance to post yesterday’s Lunch Stop.
Busy day on Medic Unit 202, 40+ miles of driving from cancelled call to cancelled call during a 2 hour period, we finally got here.
Today’s slices we’re a Grandpa slice and a Reuben slice.
Yes, a pizza with corned beef, sauerkraut, Russian dressing, cheese and a touch of tomato sauce.
OMG, both slices we’re very delicious.
Also had one of their version of a Zeppolle with powder cinnamon and sugar, also very tasty.
I would recommend all to try a slice or two!!!
… moreAlexander Talbot
The Pizza was incredible however I got the wrong chips. I THOUGT HERRS CHIPS SALT AND VINEGAR WAS A WHITE BAG AND THEN IT TURNED OUT TO BE JUST SALT. THOSE ARENT SPECIAL THEY’RE STANDARD POTATO CHIPS anyways yeah pizza was great. I could eat the whole menu probably.
… moreTiara Ferguson
This place has a very homely type of vibe. I don’t know what’s in the sauce but I’m obsessed. Old pizza, overheated pizza, or freshly made pizza, it’s all delicious. I stop in anytime I’m in town. I live almost an hour away but will always stop there if I’m in the area even when pizza is not on my mind. Lol. Everyone is so friendly. These are the small-town businesses we should be supporting. If you go tell them Tiara sent you. They don’t know me but maybe next time I can get a free delicious slice. Lol
… moreRussell Huntley
Phenomenal pizza, subs, italian hot dogs…the list goes on. Stop in this gem of a place and you’ll be greated with the friendliest of service from everyone behind the counter. If youre in Long Branch or anywhere around stop on in and grab a pie…you absolutely wont regret it!
… moreGianna Tutela
i got a sub & a buffalo chicken slice the slice was mid at best. Decent. But the sub i got is actually not good at all. $20 for half a sub, a slice & a vitamin water yet nothing was enjoyable & seems low quality ingredients all around. This place just doesnt compare to half the pizzerias around wanted to give it a try but not worth it in my opinion. Staff was nice tho.
… more